Bush, Obama and Political Good Cop Bad Cop.

@ParaTed2k (22940)
Sheboygan, Wisconsin
January 27, 2009 6:32pm CST
Prs. Obama has scheduled an interview with Arab TV, which has his detractors making accusations and his supporters becoming anything from unquestioningly supportive to scratching their heads and trying to make excuses. I have a different take on it. Hold on to your black helicopters, but I have to wonder something about Prs. Obama and his "kinder gentler" approach to the war on terror. I don't know if it's what he is really doing, but if it is, I'm gaining a whole new respect for him. We already know that one of Prs. Obama's better qualities is the ability to play to an audience. But so far we've only seen that in practice on the campaign trail. We have only seen him action in that one type of situation. However, as most of us know, when we have a gift, it usually comes in handy in a variety of situations. Like all other presidents (which the exception of George Washington), Prs. Obama has to work with what was handed to him by the previous administration. It doesn't matter if the new president wants what is handed to him or not, it comes with having your butt in the big chair in the oval office. One of the things that Prs. Bush handed over to Prs. Obama is Bush's reputation in the Arab and Muslim world. Whether it's true or not, Prs. Bush was percieved as Anti Arab, and Anti Muslim. Good Cop Bad Cop is a tactic often used by police departments while interrogating a suspect of a crime. It is also commonly used when interrogating POWs to get them to talk. The one playing "Bad Cop" comes in with heavy handed talk and actions that scare the ever-lovin' out of the one being interrogated. The "bad cop" finds a reason to leave and storms out the door. Then the "Good Cop" comes in and pretty much bad mouths the "Bad cop" talking about how he's gone rogue, or is under investigation himself. He then turns his attention to convincing the suspect that "good cop" is on his side and if they can just work together, then the "good cop" can protect him from "bad cop". By reaching out to the Arab and Muslim world, Prs. Obama has a great opportunity to play "good cop" here. He can convince them that the days of "cowboy diplomacy" are over, and he isn't as quick to "find a terrorist under every turban". It doesn't matter if any of it is true or not, it only matters what Prs. Obama's audience comes to the table believing about Bush. So far, Al Qaeda and the Taliban have pretty much controlled the propaganda debate. They have played on the incompetent press, the American left, and the perceived Anti Bush sentiment in the world, and played it well. If Prs. Obama can use that as a weapon against the terrorists, then he can turn the tables in the propaganda front as efficiently as Gates and Gen. Patreaus turned the tables on the terrorists in Iraq. I've written about how the propaganda front is an important part of any war effort before. The left and the incompetent press would have rather died that to a have allowed Prs. Bush any success at all, much less in the propaganda front of the war on terror. Now that Prs. Obama is in office though, the incompetent press will be more than happy to help Obama succeed any way they can. This means that whatever Obama does in the "good cop" department, the incompetent press isn't going to get in the way... in fact, with any luck, they will be as happy to comply as they have been with Al Qaeda. There is no way of knowing if this is what Prs. Obama is up to. It's not like Obama (or anyone close to him) is going to come out and say this if it is true. But if it has any truth to it at all... BRAVO OBAMA!
5 responses
@katran (585)
• United States
28 Jan 09
Well, it isn't exactly like the so-called "cowboy diplomacy" of the Bush era wasn't WORKING. I mean, we haven't been attacked since 9/11. I'm not really going to jump on the bandwagon yet, Ted, sorry, because I think we have much more to lose from Obama's "gentler" policies than we did from Bush's heavy-handed ones. I doubt American can ever earn the respect of the Islamic extremists, unless we become an Islamic state ourselves. I don't think being nice to them will keep them from attacking us. But oh well. I guess I wish him luck, because if he fails at whatever he is doing, we're all screwed.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
Oh, I'm not on any bandwagon, I'm just calling it the way I see it. No president should try to earn the respect of the Islamist Extremists, they are enemies that need to be treated as such. However, the propaganda front isn't about the extremists, it's about the hearts and minds of the common, every day people. What Obama needs to do is get the common folks in Arab and Persian nations to turn against the Islamist extremists. Even if that doesn't mean they decide to love the US, it means they might expose the extemists among them.
@katran (585)
• United States
28 Jan 09
Ahhhhh, I see what you mean now. In that case...I wish him luck all the more. However, I fear that the terrorists have struck terror even into the hearts of their own people. They practice repression at home and aggression towards the rest of the world.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
That's what people said about the Iraqis under Hussein... but as soon as they felt it was safe to start dropping dimes, they did!
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
28 Jan 09
Well, that's a very interesting perspective on the situation, Parated. I fall into the scratching my head category...without the making excuses attachment...when I heard about this. My first reaction was that he should have done his first interview with an American journalist...talking to Americans...and I wasn't too happy with his choice. I don't know what the reasons were for his decision but I do agree that playing "good cop" should be fairly easy considering who's act he's following.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
Yeah, I agree, I don't like that his first interview as president isn't to the people of the US. After all, he works for us.
1 person likes this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
Let's just hope it is him working for us.
1 person likes this
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
28 Jan 09
I agree in that I don't have issue that he did the interview, I'm just not thrilled with the fact that he made it his FIRST interview. It would have had just as big an impact on the Arab world if it had been his second interview.
@creematee (2810)
• United States
28 Jan 09
I believe this interview was one that was MUCH needed! Our nation (USA) has become so hated in the world as of late. It makes me feel better to know that someone now is taking responsibility and trying to heal those wounds that have been festering for the last 8, 10, 20 years. I caught a bit of an interview with the journalist who interviewed Obama. He said he felt it was a courageous and respectable move on Obama's part. The Muslim world *should* have listened, and *should* start understanding that we are there to help, not to create trouble. I think that point was never addressed under Bush's administration. I feel better knowing that we are trying to make peace. We aren't the bad guy, and really never intended to be that way.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
Why do lefties still cling to the "the world hates us" propaganda when the French and German people (two of the most quoted haters of the US) both voted out the anti US leaders and voted in Pro US leaders? Why also do lefties think that everything is a popularity contest? I do hope this was the right thing to do, but not because it might make us more popular in the world. People said the Iraqi people hated us, but the minute they figured it was safe to do so, they turned on the terrorists and gave them up to the Americans... yeah, the ones they supposedly hated. 35 million people voted for a new government because we quit putting up with Hussein's crap.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
but of course, it would have been better to do the "popular" thing and just let Hussein continue on. Because popular is what is important here, right?
@grammasnook (1871)
• United States
28 Jan 09
I had responded to another discussion about this that I will cut and paste for you .. hold on let me find it. here it is My husband is a veteran from the first gulf war, being a hard core republican. After reading the article he just had one thing to say. He doesn't know if it is the right thing but he isn't doing the wrong thing either. He is trying to make steps towards peace something the United States always fights for! If they do not respond in a positive way it just makes them look more like the bad guy! It also says to the rest of the world " at least we are trying!"
@jonesy123 (3948)
• United States
28 Jan 09
It would be nice, if it would work. However, the way I understand it there is a different value system in the Muslim world. Reaching out like this is perceived as weakness and equals the waving of a white flag. I'm not too sure that this move was one of the smartest but certainly worth a try, if he is prepared to show that contrary to the perception the US and Obama himself are still very strong. I suppose we'll see soon how all of this will play out;)
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
28 Jan 09
Well, it's not that they consider diplomacy or reaching out a weakness, as long as the diplomacy isn't done from weakness. In the Arab and Persian world, respect goes uphill and among equals only, it is never shown towards someone considered lower. In Western culture respect goes to anyone we feel like respecting. If his motive isn't about kissing up to them, he needs to make sure all talks and meetings are done on an even keel. In other words, he needs to show them respect, but he also needs to demand it of them. If, Clinton and other diplomats can pull that off, they will be able to negotiate openly. If they can't, then they will always be considered "beneath" the leaders they talk with. Prs. Bush Sr. lost the respect of Arab and Persian leaders when he left Hussein standing after Desert Storm. Prs. Clinton never had their respect. Prs. Bush was respected, but never really did much to capitalize on it. We'll see how it goes with Obama.