Anti-Semitism: Christianity's Dirty Secret.

Thailand
February 19, 2009 11:57pm CST
A disclaimer is in order here. All Christians are not anti-Semitic and should not be viewed as such. The problem is that and anti-Semitism is institutionalized with in the Christian religion. It seems rather odd that a religion based on the teachings of a Jewish rabbi would have the rot of anti-Semitism at its core but sadly this is the case. The New Testament of the Bible begins with the four Canonical Gospels. A chronological examination of them shows the development of anti-Semitism over the time frame of their writing. In the first we see Pilate painted as a villain and the Jewish priests as being relatively benign. As time passes the Gospel of John has done a complete reversal and Pilate becomes almost a victim acting at the whim of the Jewish priests. If this were the only problem than Christian anti-Semitism would be a historical curiosity and not worthy of note. This sadly is not the case. Christianity took on its significance in the modern world when the Emperor Constantine decided to make it the official religion of his empire. Constantine needed to define Christianity because in his time there were a multitude of Gospels and in reality many different forms of Christianity. To have a religion that would serve to unify and strengthen his empire Christianity needed to be simplified and made understandable. To this end in 325 he called the Council of Nicaea which made the critical decision as to what books would make up the Bible and what were the basic tenets and beliefs of his form of Christianity. One of the things coming out of the Council of Nicaea was a decision to separate Easter from the Jewish Passover. The statements that emerge from this decision are representative of some of the worst forms of anti-Semitism. A small sampling of them: "For it is unbecoming beyond nature of that on this holiest of festivals that we should follow the custom of the Jew's, henceforth let us have nothing in common with this odious people.", "we desired therefor brother into separate ourselves from the detestable company of the Jews". If this were an isolated instance it could it could be forgiven as a product of its time but sadly it is not. The history of the Christian Church is a history of anti-Semitism from the time of the Emperor Constantine to the time of Adolf Hitler. Some of the most anti-Semitic statements in history have been attributed to Christian saints. The revered St. Augustine wrote "The true image of the Hebrews is Judas Iscariot, who sells the Lord for silver. The Jew can never understand the Scripture and forever will bear the guilt of the death of Jesus." Another saint who made his mark on history was St. Jerome who wrote the Vulgate translation of the Bible. His statement of note referred to synagogues. "If you call it a brothel, a den of vice, the Devils refuge, Satan's fortress, a place to deprave the soul, an abyss of every conceivable disaster or what ever you will, you are still saying less than it deserves." In 1066 CE one of the first Crusades first acts was to kill 12,000 Jews in the Rhine Valley on their way to Jerusalem. In 1099 after reaching Jerusalem they forced all the Jews of the city into the central synagogue and set it on fire. Anyone who tried to escape was forced back into the burning building. The point of fact here is that anti-Semitism and Anti-Semitic acts were not aberrations and were not a few isolated incidents; they were part of an institutionalized attitude of the church. Anti-Semitism cannot be isolated and limited to the Catholic Church. Martin Luther, when he split from the Catholic Church pronounced his own tirades against the Jews and made and anti-Semitism one of the center points of his new Protestant denomination. The church, both Catholic and Protestant has always and still does view Jews as the killers of God. The worst expression of this, of course, is the Holocaust decreed by the self-professed Christian, Adolf Hitler. The lesson of the Holocaust is a lesson that must be heeded or history will surely repeat itself. The dirty secret of anti-Semitism must be brought out into the open and the church which bears much of the guilt must lead the way in stomping it out in society and change the attitudes of people once and for all.
8 responses
@urbandekay (18278)
20 Feb 09
"The church, both Catholic and Protestant has always and still does view Jews as the killers of God. The worst expression of this, of course, is the Holocaust decreed by the self-professed Christian, Adolf Hitler." What rot! Yes the Church was anti-semitic, there may still be in the Catholic Church but I don't think this is true amongst those that follow Christ instead of the Pope all the best urban
4 people like this
@urbandekay (18278)
20 Feb 09
Sorry, I failed to make it clear that I was drawing a distinction between present and past as well as followers of Christ and followers of the Pope. Yes, Christians were anti-semitic, I do not believe that to be the case now. Let's remember Luther considered himself to be a Catholic reformer not the originator of a new denomination. Council of Nicea, Luther, seems you are taking one tradition within Christianity to represent it all. Adolf Hitler was known to have Satanic influences so can hardly be viewed a Christian all the best urban
4 people like this
@urbandekay (18278)
20 Feb 09
Further I must take issue with your erroneous description of the Gospels, in Mark the earliest gospel and in Matthew it is the Jewish officials that assault and ridicule Yeshua prior to his trial in Luke it is the guards. All a neutral interpretation permits you to say is that there is a difference in the accounts, and provides no evidence of increasing anti-semitism. Re the link; this is hardly a representative of main stream Christianity, you are guilty of portraying all Christians by the acts of a few extremists. I see you have conveniently cut the name of the Church off your picture, are we permitted to know what denomination this was? 14For ye, brethren, became followers of the churches of God which in Judaea are in Christ Jesus: for ye also have suffered like things of your own countrymen, even as they have of the Jews: 15Who both killed the Lord Jesus, and their own prophets, and have persecuted us; and they please not God, and are contrary to all men. Now, this is not anti-semitism, you would need to show that it was a general statement condemning Jews as a whole, not, as it in fact is, a statement castigating individuals. Notice that it is addressed to Jews "Your own countrymen." It is therefore clear that this is a statement warning individuals against their own countrymen and therefore cannot be interpreted correctly as a statement of anti-semitism except by doing violence to the text all the best urban
5 people like this
@urbandekay (18278)
20 Feb 09
It may have been convenient for Hitler to portray himself as a Christian but that would not be the first time a political leader has feigned religious belief to gain power and influence all the best urban
5 people like this
@murderistic (2278)
• United States
20 Feb 09
So because the Bible told the truth about the Jewish rabbis who had Jesus killed, it is "institutionalized" in Christianity? I don't think so. The entire new testament is devoted to forgiveness and the love of all (both neighbor and enemy). Jesus reached out to the marginalized of society that the Jews wouldn't dream of even speaking to. The message of the New Testament is one of hope and forgiveness for ALL people regardless of race or religion. Yes, there were some terrible times in the history of the church, but that doesn't make it Biblical. And today I would say that people have moved from being anti-Semite to being anti-Palestinian and pro-Zionism which is in essence extremely pro-semite.
3 people like this
• Thailand
21 Feb 09
This is not about the Bible, It is about how the Bible has been interpreted and used to evil ends. The history of this is long and tragic. It is not a few isolated instances but rather systematized abuse that has continued for centuries.
21 Feb 09
Anti Palestinian would still be anti Semite. Not only Jews are Semite people, Arabs are also Semite peoples. Most people do not see this though, For a person to say, I am not anti-Semite, I love the Jew and hate the Arab is an oxymoron. it would be like saying, I love your family but I hate your brother.
4 people like this
@bekosfc (235)
• India
21 Feb 09
free, I agree with your post. Semites are not only the Jews.
2 people like this
• India
20 Feb 09
Btw, the worst affect group of people due to Crusade were the Christians themselves. Moreover, there were many priest who risked their lives protecting Jews. Local bishop at Speyer, bishop of Worm, archbishop of Mainz, bishop of Cologne were those bishops who risked their lives. To tell the story of Christians slaugtering Jews, but not the other side of the story is not a faithful retelling of the story. Such people, perhaps, have hidden agenda!!!
2 people like this
• India
20 Feb 09
"The church, both Catholic and Protestant has always and still does view Jews as the killers of God." This is absolutely untrue. The Jews were fearful that releasing of The Passion of Christ will fan anti-semitic feeling, but no such feeling was generated by the movie. Your point is ridiculous.
2 people like this
21 Feb 09
What a fire storm you have created LOL. I do understand where you are coming from here but I have to disagree with your conclusion. The Gospels were not an indictment of Jews, but against the religious leaders, One must also consider this that at this time the Jewish leaders were put in power by the Roman authorities. They were more politicians than real priests. The Gospels point out that the Jewish hierarchy feared Yashua as a threat against their authority, It was not meant to be a testimony against Jews. It was later the church of Rome who began to turn it against the Jews, the phrase "Mata Christo" Christ killers was used as a derogatory phrase for Jews in a whole and Jews were forced to convert or were Murdered. I would not put Christians in a lump with Catholics. Catholics follow Catholicism, So I would agree that Catholicism was and possibly still is anti-semitic. So how many people did I just pi-- off?
2 people like this
• Thailand
21 Feb 09
Some times a fire storm is necessary to garner the attention a topic deserves. I agree with you that the Gospels were not intended as an indictment against the Jews. The problem arises from their interpretation. History gives us a picture of evil men using a good book for evil purposes. The Bible that we have is as much a political document as a religious testament. To give the Bible the consideration that it deserves you must give attention to what was left out as well as what was included. It is only when you do this that the full picture emerges. Christians, particularly those of the evangelical persuasion, go to great ends to distance themselves from the Catholic Church. In some of the comments above there are some fine examples of this. The truth is somewhat different. To put it in evolutionary terms all of today's Christian churches share a common decent from the church established by the Emperor Constantine. It was only later that they split over doctrinal differences. If the use of the term "Christ killers" could be shown to be something that is exclusive to Catholicism I would give other denominations a free pass on that but that is not the case. It is as common among Evangelical Christians as it is among Catholics. This discussion was not intended to indite Christians. It is an attempt to bring the dirty secret of the historical fact of Christian Anti-Semitism into the cold light of day.
• Thailand
21 Feb 09
urban if you read what I posted I did not refer to the Roman church, I referred to the Church established by Constantine. This is a side issue anyway. The discussion is about the institutionalized Anti-Semitism that is a part of the history of political Christianity.
1 person likes this
@urbandekay (18278)
21 Feb 09
You are too quick to say all churches descend from the Roman Church, remember the Catholic Church dates only from the 11th century when the then Bishop of Rome, in a fit of peak, declared himself Pope and split from the Orthodox Church, which, strictly speaking, is the Church established by Constantine. Nor is such split recent, the two arms of the Orthodox Church, Roman and Eastern had lived apart, so to speak, for many centuries prior to the Roman Church splitting away. all the best urban
2 people like this
@GADHISUNU (2162)
• India
22 Feb 09
I was always intrigued by antisemitism. It disturbs me a lot. Even Jesus pardoned them in His infinite compassion.Why should mere mortals hold it in them to hate a race, a people.I was on another discussion forum, and wanted to know why people [read: Christians] are particularly against Jews? Is it because the Jewish priests refused to accept Jesus as the Messiah and got Him declared heretic and hence subject to the then prevalent Roman Law? It was the Jewish priests who pronounced Jesus guilty and forced an unwilling Pilate to declare a punishment worthy of lumping the Lord with common criminals! Oh! What intolerance? Suits the old world. But why make it a rallying point to fan racial hatred and genocide? Or is it just a ploy to hound the prosperous Jews out of their means of living. Sadly, since Israel was carved out of the lands predominantly inhabited by Muslims they have now become the consequential enemies though linguistically Hebrew and Arabic are close. I agree with you that the highest temporal authorities of the various Christian denominations must come out in the open against antisemitism. It is also a wonder that the US(predominantly Catholic Christian?) supports Israel!?!
@bekosfc (235)
• India
20 Feb 09
Nonsense! Where in the Bible do you find anti-Semitic teachings? How would you theologically justify your argument. You did not provide biblical support for what you said but you went on to say whatever you wanted to say quoting some noted Christian leaders. I wonder if you are trying to make Christians hate Jews so that you can created enmity between Jews and Christians, and because Christians outnumber Jews, Christians will slaughter Jews. If that is the case you'd be the one with anti-semitic attitude.
2 people like this
• Thailand
21 Feb 09
headhunter525 my intention is simple. It can be summed up in two words. NEVER AGAIN!
• India
20 Feb 09
Christianity is about deriving its teaching from the Bible. That does not mean all Christians have been faithfully obeying it. And there is no trace of anti-Semitism in the Bible like the way you portrayed. From your tone you are not reminding the past. You are finding fault, trying to portray others as racially prejudiced. Agreed that we need to learn from the past, but that does not seem to be your intention.
2 people like this
• India
21 Feb 09
Where did you you last hear of that? How many people shouted to how many people? Do you have prove that those who shouted at the Jews were truly Christians? I am pressing the matter further because what you are charging Christians of is a serious matter. If what you are saying is true we want to rectify that.
3 people like this
@gjabaigar (2200)
• Philippines
20 Feb 09
^_^ Howdy! Chieang_Mai_boy!.... It's a very nice discussion Chiang_Mai_boy. You may have a lot of knowing of HIStory. Thanks for sharing. BUT, I'm confused Chiang_Mai_boy of what have you discussed. As it is stated foremost at the first paragraph is the essence and spirit of your discussion. The "Anti-Semitism". I can't understand what do you mean as being an Anti-Semitism? Can you please explain and clearly elaborate what is Anti-Semitism? Is this involve only for Jewish people onyl? ^_^ Peace!.... Thanks!.... and Enjoy!.... myLot!....
• Thailand
20 Feb 09
The Semitic people are the Jewish people. Anti-Semitism is by definition against the Jewish people. Hope that helps.
@gjabaigar (2200)
• Philippines
20 Feb 09
Thank you very much, Chiang_Mai_boy for giving your explanation. Are Semitic people are Jewish or Hebrew people only? How about the other ancient southwestern Asian people, like the Akkadians, Canaanites, Phoenicians, Arabs, and Ethiopian Semites? ^_^ Enjoy!.... myLot!....
21 Feb 09
Arabs are also Semite peoples
2 people like this
• Philippines
20 Feb 09
I think you should research further. Constantine made Christianity as the official religion but the members of this instituted religion are not true believers of Christ. They are a mixture of pagan belief and Bible principle blended together that resulted to the Catholic Church. True believers of Christ ascribe to His teachings. This is not the case of this new instituted religion.
1 person likes this