Do you think its better to have a past or not with....

By Amy
Abernathy, Texas
February 21, 2009 5:06am CST
kids - which do you think is better in teaching them later -having smoked, partied etc or never having indulged in self destructive behaviours?
2 people like this
5 responses
• India
21 Feb 09
i think its good to discuss it as it shows tht u have a open relationship wid them!! but at the same time they'll expect u not to scold them wen they do such things!! so in this case ur athority will b lost!! so telling them is a good idea.. and telling it in a early age is a bad one!! tell them wen u think they have matured. wht say?
1 person likes this
• Abernathy, Texas
21 Feb 09
Great answer...although my question still goes unanswered. Do you think its bettered to have engaged in smoking etc at an early age - to have a past or not with kids? I so agree about having that kind of relationship with them that includes open communication. Oh and not telling them too early!
1 person likes this
• Canada
1 Mar 09
Hi Artemis, It has been ages since our last chat. How are you? I am not here much because David and I have spent the last year or so revamping our business, creating a website, forum, working on the last edits of my book and a variety of other personal and business ventures. From what I recall of our last discussion you and your family were moving and I have ofter wondered how that worked out and how old you little one is now? I drop back to Mylot as time permits because I value the many wonderful friends i have made here and you are among them. I remember your interest in learning more about "light workers" and other metaphysical interests. So I thought I'd check around and see if you were still here and I am glad you are. Whew, enough of the little updates. In regard to your question even though we do not have kids of our own we do deal with these kinds of questions in our life coaching and seminars. Our position is what you tell any child depends on their age and emotional maturity. There is no hard and fast rule with anyone or anything in life because every person and situation calls for different approaches. The most important things in creating a solid relationship with anyone include some of the following: openness, trust, love, walking one's talk, respect for differences, non judgment, attentive listening and accountability. Most people have made errors in judgment along their life path. We learn by making mistakes..but if we learn something then it really isn't a failure. If parents have been involved in some of the things you present and a child is old enough and mature enough to hear the whys and hows of those experiences and what the parent deduced about them it could be an important teaching aid for the child. However, if a parent is spouting a "don't do as I do...but do as I say" philosophy it could be counter-productive. So as I mentioned...each case is different. Interesting discussion and good to be back in touch. Raia
• Abernathy, Texas
12 Apr 09
I would agree with all that you say especially openness, trust, love, walking one's talk, respect for differences, non judgment, attentive listening and accountability. I am going to check out your website and if you need help in your endeavors let me know.
@Aurone (4755)
• United States
21 Feb 09
I think a moderate background would be best. Having done some things but not others. That way you could share some experiences with them, but nothing having been wild yourself, you could encourage them to be moderate with their behavior.
• Abernathy, Texas
21 Feb 09
THat's true and moderation in key. But of course I'm secretly hoping he'll be like me naturally and won't have any interest in engaging in risky behaviour! But I won't blow a fuse if I catch him smoking (yuck) but I do plan to introduce him to people who made it a lifelong habit and now have lung disease, or those who lived closely with those who made it a habit and got it unfiltered and have lung cancer or asthma or compromised immune systems as a result. Same with catching him with a girl. Who I would hope is a girlfriend - not some notch on his bedpost.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
21 Feb 09
That's a bit of a double edged sword. By having a past you are more eqiupped to be aware of a child's behavior and give advice as needed but on the other hand it can give them the go ahead..cause mom or dad done it.By not having done it you can set an example and advocate not doing it. But that also may add a gap between you and the child because.."you don't understand".I suppose when it boils down to it,I think it depends on how you teach them and not so much what you have or have not done.
• Abernathy, Texas
21 Feb 09
Love that answer and I would agree - its how you teach them. Because whatever your past, its going forward that counts.
• Philippines
21 Feb 09
hmm, interesting question. I'm a bit torn cause a part of me thinks it would be easier if you went through all those things but at the same time based from personal experience, my dad he had no vices. he doesnt drink nor does he smoke. and as a daughter of someone who did not do all that, I did feel the pressure of not doing those things as well. so far, so good. havent drunk, havent smoked a day in my life.
• Abernathy, Texas
21 Feb 09
Great answer and the same situation as my husband. His parents don't drink or smoke and he has never had a desire to. I'm the opposite, my mom both drinks and smokes and so I've never ever had any inclination to do either of those - especially around kids. I love your avatar!