I was watching the Duggers last night

@cripfemme (7698)
United States
February 25, 2009 11:53am CST
Does everyone know who that is? They are this big family from Arkansas with now 18 kids. Their oldest just got married. As a rule, they don't believe in dating. They believe in this practice called "courtship". I don't really know what the difference is, except that I think, you're only supposed to court one person, ever. That seems a little weird to me. How are you going to know what kind of person you like? I mean, some things are obvious, for myself these would include no bigots, good personal hygiene, and a commitment to social justice. But there are 50,000 small factors you never realize are important to you unless you court more than one person. The young married people on this show seem very nice. They seem to really love each other and I don't think that's all their parent's doing. You can't fake love, even if other people want you to. Still, I wonder what they missed out on. I wonder if their kids will miss out on it too. With all my reservations about this method of mate determination, I must admit that I don't like the idea of my child, or for that matter any child, being "loose" in terms of their sexuality or having 57 different partners before their 18th birthday. This is dangerous. But there has to be a middle ground. In my own parenting, I will strive to find it and guide myself towards it as the best path. What do you think of courtship and no dating? Have you ever tried this approach yourself? Can you explain the difference?
1 person likes this
5 responses
• United States
25 Feb 09
I have not seen this but many people who home schooled were looking into this when I was home schooling my daughter. There is a very positive to this from the perspective that there is no intimate relations before marriage. Hmmmm, many young people would frown at this. Over the years I have realized that when physically intimate acts takes place before marriage, the man does not develop himself in the relationship as he should. Courtship without intimate physical relationship forces a man to socialize with the woman and learn about her. You will notice many young girls living with men and being frustrated and not knowing why. It is because the communication skills were never developed. There is so much to relationship. I liked what my mother taught me. She always encouraged us to pray for our mate, trust in God, and be friends with a lot of people to develop your social skills and begin to know what you might want in a mate. I never had to be jealous if someone else "stole" the guy I liked. Of course, intimate physical relationships were meant for marriage. My daughter is a very well grounded individual in this area. We have talked about relationships for many years. I have prayed for God to prepare her and a mate for her from the time she was very little on. I am still waiting to see what God will provide. I also pray that they will really love each other through good and bad times. The young men she has dated come to the house. I have been well pleased with all of her choices so far.
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
25 Feb 09
So basically I was courted for 11 months by my college girlfriend. She and I didn't "get it on" for the first 11 months of our official relationship. Not counting the 6 months when were unofficial. I was really sure that she loved me when I opted to do the actual act. If all courting means is being focused on the non-physical parts of your relationship (rather than the physical), I would think and hope a lot of people do that. The physical isn't everything and people need to be aware of that.
• United States
25 Feb 09
There you go! A young person needs a lot of friendships before they can figure out what they really want. I learned that you think a whole lot different about people when you are out in the work world and have finished school. People you meet in school most generally reflect their parents more than their real selves. They are still dependent on parents for money and everything else. It is a process to see how a person will handle their own money, what values they have (their parents or their own), how they handle tough times, can they run a home, etc. That is why it takes a little growing up to figure it all out. Or that's my guess. In the meantime, a parent can make an atmosphere that a child can bring friends home to. We always had a house full but the rule was no drinking, no smoking, and no touching. When you supply the food, 61" TV, and the gaming system you never lack for a crowd. The good 'uns rise to the top. You can also observe and have conversations with your children about relationships outside of the gatherings. The job of educating is extremely important during this time. Not preaching...observing, praying, and gently teaching.
@lampar (7584)
• United States
27 Feb 09
I believe dating include discreet and public courtship, it is mainly not religious based term for couple. Dating is a more casual term and a successful date does not necessary mean will result in marriage like courtship. I did find courtship is kind of weird probably is only acceptable to very religious people or members of certain religion groups.
@KrauseHome (36445)
• United States
26 Feb 09
In a lot of ways I can understand where they are coming from. They are trying to protect and teach their kids the importance of things from a Religious Christian standpoint and they feel you should not date someone just to date. When you date someone you need to be open to them, willing to talk and share your life, and at the same time be open and honest. I am sure they make sure they keep a tight hold to prepare their family for the future, and I am sure they want their kids to only date someone they would want to marry as well.
@dvschic (1795)
• United States
25 Feb 09
i'd prefer to date.. but thats just me. these kids are being raised in a quiverfull baptist religion, so they aren't having much exposure to the outside, everyone around them is just like them. they seem a lil immature to be getting married, but thats just me, i suppose if you can't kiss someone until you are married, u'll run out and get married pretty quick.
@ersmommy1 (12587)
• United States
26 Feb 09
Courtship is the traditional dating period before engagement and marriage. During a courtship, a couple dates to get to know each other and decide if there will be an engagement. Usually courtship is a public affair, done in public and with family approval. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Courtship dating etiquette in Western culture has become more relaxed during the twentieth century, there are considerable differences between social and personal values. For example, when an activity costs money (for example, a meal), traditionally the man was expected to pay; but in recent times the practice of "going Dutch" (splitting the expenses) has become common and acceptable. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dating I wasn't clear on the difference. But after reading, I think I prefer dating. The whole having people watching everything so that perhaps even a conversation isn't private would bother me.