If your friend told you

United States
March 8, 2009 11:37pm CST
If your friend told you something about another person would you take it at face value, or would you investigate on your own? Yes, you remember those days on the school yard where Mary said she didn't like Jane anymore, so you went along with her and said "I don't like Jane anymore either". Well, it doesn't seem that this little school yard game disappears when you grow up. So, what do you do? Do you go along with it? Do you speak with the other person? What if you are friends with the other person? Quite the delimena in my humble opinion. In my own past I've taken things one person at a time. I get to know people and make up my own mind about them. I tend to filter out and stay out of rumor mills. Perhaps it's because of being a teacher and hating the student rumor mills of "Oh, you don't want that child, he's a handful". I just can't bring myself to do it to another adult. How about you? What are your experiences?
7 people like this
34 responses
• Mexico
9 Mar 09
Normally I would not pay attention to rumors really, but it really depends on if your friend who told you those things is trying to warn you about something bad and if you can really 100% trust your friend that he/she is doing it to protect you but I would try to find out by myself I guess and not judge anyone just on gossip but yes be more careful!
3 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
I tend to find out for myself. I understand that a friend may warn you about someone, but in my experience it's not worth it to just go along with the crowd and believe anything they say. Some people though seem to become mean for whatever reason and go after innocent people with rumors. That's what I was getting at with my original post. Wondering how many friends would go along with their friends if their friend told them something about a person they didn't know. Seems like some would and some wouldn't. Thanks for responding. Anora
1 person likes this
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
11 Mar 09
ok ..I'm on the flip side of your original post. My very best friend of all time...that has been my friend for 40years plus...has this other friend that has been her friend for about 35 years (sort of). This friend has ALWAYS been jealous of my friendship with OUR friend. If I came over to visit and she was there...she'd leave. She always told my friend that she felt that I was interfering with their friendship which was not true....would have loved to get to know her too. I bit my tongue and swallowed it when my friend made plans with her and I could not be included and even at times when I had to be cancelled out because it bothered this girl. I did feel hurt but just dealt with it knowing my friend was in the middle and trying to please us both. Then there came a time when for whatever reason this girl stopped communicating with her. It devastated her and I sympathized. Oh I was angry at this girl but as always bit my tongue. One day, my friend was rushed to the hospital with 2 anorysms in her head. One hit her brain and she coded out and it was uncertain if she would live or die. After a little thought, I called this girl and told her what was going on...basically out of respect for their friendship even tho she'd not talked to her for a long time. My friend came out of the surgery which was a miracle in itself. This girl thanked me for reconnecting them. She was a good friend for a few months and then again ...disappeared for no reason and would not answer calls..anything from my friend. I watched her get hurt all over again. Years passed and recently, we ran into each other...all of us. She ran and hugged my friend so hard. I was the papparazzi! I took the pics. I made copies and sent them to her and told her that she best pay attention to their friendship as this was the last time I was going to try to reunite them...Pics don't lie. They have been good friends again and now I am her friend. She appologized to me for all the bad treatment & thanked me for reviving their friendship. I warned her...don't ever hurt her again or I will be on the other side of this coin and I will not be so willing to promote your friendship.
@chookie1971 (2271)
• Australia
9 Mar 09
I have just recently had a situation. An old good friend says that he doesn't hate me. Nor does his partner. With what has been happening, I don't believe him. I have told him that if she doesn't hate me, then I want her to tell me face to face in front of him or for her to send me an email. I won't be taking what he said for face value. I would like to hear it from her and to keep her honest.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Chookie- I'm sorr you are going through this. I know that it hurts when you are told one thing and yet experience another, especially where rumors are concerned. I hope you are able to resolve it. Many blessings-Anora
• Australia
9 Mar 09
I am trying to resolve it, but I really don't hold any faith that I can. There has been too much said prior. I am just happy to know that I have told my old friend my side of the story of what happened. If he doesn't believe me, then that is not really my problem. But I don't like it when people speak on other people's behave. I have told him that. I have told him that if she doesn't hate me, the I would like to hear it from her. I have to wait until he responds which may not be for a while as we have been communicating via email.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
lol. i was like before. i trusted a classmate based on her judgment. but that's how i met one of my bestfriend. before, we used to dislike each other because of our classmate's judgment. but then by chance, we became seatmate and found out we liked the same band. we were inseparable since. now, i try not to judge the book by someone else's review. lol. i try to read them because i want to. i hope i make sense in a way. cheers!
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Thanks so much for sharing. Yes, that makes absolute sense and was well said! Namaste-Anora
@dawnald (85130)
• Shingle Springs, California
20 Mar 09
I had a situation over on Yuwie where I had a friend who didn't get along with several other people over there. I actually got to know both of the people he didn't like and determined that I did like those people. My friend has his flaws (as do I , shhh don't tell anybody) and much as I like him, I'm not going to base my judgments of people on what he has decided. I have a former friend at work who used to get quite worked up that I didn't automatically hate certain people here that he hates. If the person had a bad quality, but I could point out that they had other good qualities, his position was that if they had bad qualities they were evil and never mind pointing out anything positive about them. I just can't see things that way. I'm still friends with the first person because, even though we don't agree on everybody, he is willing to accept the fact that I can be friends with people he doesn't like. I'm not friends with the second person because he couldn't and he thought that he had the right as a friend to dictate my behavior.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Mar 09
It's such a shame when that sort of behavior occurs. Thanks for sharing. Namaste-Anora
• China
10 Mar 09
hello..yes i think what your friend have told you will affect your value about others. but on my way i will still investigate it by myself.just like we can't judge person only by his/her appearance. though goodlooking always help. what your friends told you is just like the first sight and you gonna to know something more and different by yourself further more. happy mylot here.
2 people like this
• United States
10 Mar 09
Thanks for responding. I know that we're always affected even if we don't listen. It's like a jury who has heard something that is asked to be stricken from the record, it's already in their mind. Namaste-Anora
@kirei24 (251)
• Philippines
17 Mar 09
Whatever they say, rumors are just rumors. It is not right to just believe it because it will just cause you too much trouble. You could also hurt somone if you spread it. It is not a valid statement to begin with. So why waste time in listening and spreading this rumors. I think everyone of us knows that too. Just be observant and careful in passing stories just to make a conversation.
2 people like this
• United States
17 Mar 09
Very well said. Thanks for responding. Namaste-Anora
@silverglint (2000)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
I don't really believe in people who has the guts to bad mouth someone to other people. I may be polite enough to just listen but I always choose not to believe it nor do I have any intention of sharing it to someone else. I mean if you were the victim, how would you feel about the rumors that is spreading about you, especially if its bad. I always want to give people a chance to be themselves without a pre-conceived impression from other people. I become wary and more careful when I am around gossipers, who knows, they might be eyeing me as their next victim, people like that do not choose who they hurt, they just want the excitement of being able to spread a juicy tale about someone without really thinking if its true or not.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Silver- You've brought so much to this thread, thank you so much for sharing. I am very weary around gossip mongors too, and for much the same reason. Most groups eventually turn on each other. Not that it should be that way, but where gossip is concerned that seems to be how it works. Blessings-Anora
@yoyo2323 (465)
• China
9 Mar 09
that's really a good question !sometimes or most of the time we stand by our friends'side and belive in what they've said. their remarks about someone have great influence on us .but we must do things on our own judgement!
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Yoyo- Good point indeed. We must think for ourselves! Namaste-Anora
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
9 Mar 09
I like to take people on individual merit too. I experience this kind of rumour mill with some of the mothers at my daughter's school; I'm sure the children can be more mature! I hear all sorts of gossip and information that I don't always want to know about. It is temping to be influenced by another's opinion of a person but I have taught myself to wait until I know the person. It is better to avoid rumour mills whenever possible.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Paula- Thanks for responding. I definately find I'm much more happy when not subjecting myself to the rumor mills, or in my profession-the teacher's lounge. Namaste-Anora
@deejean06 (1952)
• United States
9 Mar 09
Hello Anora - I think that each child or adult - each person interacts differently with everyone. As a part time teacher I have encountered students who have given me a hard time and others who have been absolute angels. But in other circumstances their behavior changes and they are no longer the child who was sitting in your classroom. With adults, I have been told things about people and not believed the accusations because I have never been subjected to that particular behavior. Sometimes not listening and wanting to see the positive side always has bitten me later. However sometimes it has been better for me since I can honestly say that I have never encountered such behavior and must treat that person accordingly. I cannot just assume that all accusations are correct and in turn behave poorly based on such. I think your way of getting to know someone before making a judgement is the absolute correct course.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Deejean- Thanks so much for the respond. It's nice to meet another teach on here too!! I agree, I've never based my judgements on a student just because another teacher told me something negative. As you say, students can behave one way with one teacher and be complete angels in my room. (And vise versa lol). With adults, I tend to take each friend or person I have on a case by case basis, and I don't pay attention to what another has told me about that person. Sure, I've gotten bitten too, but at least I've given them a chance before just believing rumors. Most of the time, and that would be 99.9 % of the time, the rumors are unfounded and often made up. Namaste-Anora
• United States
9 Mar 09
Hello Anora, I try my best not to even listen to anything negative about another person and all my friends know this. For the most part, my friends respect this and gossip is kept out of my earshot. I dislike the he said/she said games that are played. It is as though we are not evolved enough to have more than "one" friend. The way I see it, is we are all human, all bleed red and all have done something we would hope that nobody finds out. There is so much negativity in the world, the workplace, on television, etc... that I do not think we need it in our own homes. That is just my opinion and one I try to live by. People come to my home and visit and later will tell me just how comfortable they felt there.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Mystic- Thank you for sharing. My husband and I have received the same compliments when people visit. We're both very easy going people and we take people in on their own merit, not the words of others. Namaste-Anora
@fino1982 (55)
• China
9 Mar 09
If my friend tell me something about another person, I will forget it. Bifferent people may have different opinions about the same matter. I will not investgate it ,otherwise it will really bother me.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Fino- At least you ignore it. It would make sense though that if this person is someone you wanted to be friends with that you'd investigate it by either asking them about it or being their friend and finding out for yourself. Thanks for responding. Namaste-Anora
@Ritchelle (3790)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
i may listen, meaning, i'd take it as a reminder just so when the time comes that that person and i come face to face i can have some sort of guard. but of course, i still have to see it to believe it.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Ritchelle- Thanks for responding. I can see perhaps if it were something like "This person beats people up" or something, but not just "This person isn't a nice person". Namaste-Anora
@mimibt (52)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
I am to others for how they are to me. So if someone tells me something about anyone I know or not, I never take it at face value. Although it is hard not to succumb to the "going along" mentality when the person talked about is someone you have an issue with. But all in all I make it a point to gather facts directly and not through others.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Mimi- Thanks for sharing. I agree, we all struggle with "group" thinking, but I think this thread is showing that there are many who are willing to fight the herd mentality and make their own decisions. Blessings-Anora
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
I won't listen or base my impression to someone based to what other people would say about him or her. I would try to know the person first and start from there. Why listen up to someone no matter how close you maybe without making an effort of knowing the person. I hate to judge people based on what I see from the outside. Nice topic.
• United States
9 Mar 09
Thanks for your kind response. Yes, I like to get to know the person first too! I remember this boy in highschool who everyone made fun of and I couldn't understand why. Yet, I couldn't bring myself to listen to them. Turns out he knew everything about Star Trek and could tell you episode numbers too!! That's why they made fun of them, and my thoughts were "Well, you're just jealous because you don't have his volume of knowledge on a cool topic". Thanks for the response. Anora
@elghrasya (501)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
It depends on the situation. If the other friend is very close to me then I think I would investigate it on my own. But if not then I will just ignore it. Or I will just listen to the person who is talking and I will enter the gossip on my left ear then I'll let it pass or out on my right ear. And besides I am not the type of person who minds other business so I will just forget what I hear specially if it is negative, right?
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
I think it's best to never listen to the negative about another person and simply make up your own mind. I mean, sure if the person is a serial killer or what not, perhaps we should take the advise into hand. However, if it is just that this person doesn't like another person and starts spreading malicious gossip I would hope that people would ignore it and make their own decisions.
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
I wish more people could be like you,Anora.I also don't prejudge people based on what others say.i remember having a talk with my daughter about this when she was in preschool.She told me that some classmates were telling her not to be friends with a certain classmate and she was asking me if she should do as they say.I had to explain to her that it's not the right thing to do as this person didn't do anything wrong to her.She followed my advice and they've become good friends. Thanks.Have a great day!
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Thanks for the kind response. That's exactly what I'm getting at. I'm glad your daughter has a mother like you advising her to not believe the rumor mills. Anora
• China
9 Mar 09
I am an adult, not a child, I would not just hate others or take it as facts because my friends say so. Don't take me wrong, it doesn't mean that I don't trust or respect my friend, but people see things from different points of view, my friends' doesn't mean mine. moreover, any people would misjudge. seeing is more convincing than hearing. yet seeing can also mislead you. I never listen to rumors since I've grown up.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Thank you so much for sharing. I think you're right, not listening to a friend doesn't mean we don't respect them, it means we want to have our own mind. Namaste-Anora
• India
9 Mar 09
Yes,ofcourse you have your own identity and your own points of views,but you should also have full faith in your friends too.
1 person likes this
@mizstress (719)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
i tried not to get influenced by what my friends feel about my other friend. i made my own conviction and i say to them its ok if your mad at him/her. if i can patch things between them il try to. but i dont want get in between them so i wont be torn in halves.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Thanks for sharing. Yes, I never want to feel like I'm in the middle either. Namaste-Anora
• India
9 Mar 09
I also do the same thing when it comes in between my friend circle. But when it comes to outsiders,I always go with my friends. This is because I have full faith in my friends.
1 person likes this
@lonmar71 (89)
• Philippines
9 Mar 09
i think it would be unfair to the other person if you immediately believed what your friend is saying about that person. what if your friend didn't get the whole story or has ill feelings about the other person. it's not also good to ask the other person if its true or not unless the other person opened it up to you. gossips tend to destroy a person's reputation and some of those gossips are mere fabrication.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Mar 09
Lon- Spoken so truthfully. And yes, gossip can damage another's reputation in so many ways, and it's just not very nice to do. Namaste-Anora