Mashed Potatoes

United States
April 2, 2009 9:43pm CST
Do you like instant? or from scratch? Any secret ingredients to make "the best" mashed potatoes? Easter is right around the corner. Hubby says from scratch. I say whateverI have time & clean pans for! *lol*
2 people like this
11 responses
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
3 Apr 09
i can't stand instant potatoes. they have to be from scratch. hang in there hubby, lol.
• United States
5 Apr 09
I'm not always the fondest of them either. But like another person said when you have hungry kids that want to eat "now!" it'll due...
• United States
6 Apr 09
That you do and fast before they fill up before dinner is ready *sigh* I can't have dinner ready by 3:45pm!
1 person likes this
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
5 Apr 09
if the kids like them that's great. u gotta' feed them hungry kids. lol
• United States
3 Apr 09
Coming from a good German background I have to say potatoes from scratch. It does not take that long and most men love their potatoes. You can get instant potatoes anywhere but it is a treat to have them from scratch. That's what a holiday is all about. If you peel the potatoes ahead of time and cover them with cold water, you won't have to scurry around at the last minute to get them going. Just pour off the water before cooking and replace with fresh water. You can even do this the night before your dinner. I like to add a few peeled and cut up parsnips to the potatoes while they cook and then mash them all together when the parsnips are tender. It adds sweetness to the potatoes and no one knows they are in the potatoes (don't tell). After everything is cooked. I add butter, sour cream, and cream cheese to taste. You can make a huge batch of potatoes and watch them disappear faster than a rabbit in a hat. I know this sounds like cholesterol heaven but it's the holidays. Oh, I like to use a hand potato masher instead of a traditional potato masher or electric mixer. It does a wonderful job in just a few seconds. It is not like the mashers that most people use. My mother had one and I had to go out and get one when I set up my own household 30 years ago. It is also great for doing any kind of sauces and gravy-NO LUMPS. Here is a picture of the one I use. I do not know how you can purchase one but you will get the idea from seeing the picture. http://www.cutco.com/products/product.jsp?itemGroup=1160 You may think I am a little silly for all this detail but it is well worth it when every man in the neighborhood and family compliment you on your potatoes.
• United States
5 Apr 09
I'm from a German background too, but I'm afraid most of the recipies passed on with her. Though I'm hoping when my uncle (who has her house & whatever is left of her belongings) passes that I'll find her recipies in that house of packrat. Now that I have kids I want to share some of those things from our heritage ya know?!?! My mom never cooked anything German sooo I don't remember much other than some of the great stews my Grandma made when I was a kid. I use and have 2 of those mashers ;) The metal ones work the best the plastic ones... not so good. I saw on a show parsnips are just like carrots in a way. I've used couliflour in mine before. Gotta sneak in those veggies some how! Thanks for your post and your tips.
• United States
6 Apr 09
Thanks so much! I'll have to look to see if my library has it... Do you have any suggestions on holiday tradition sites ect? I've been looking like a mad woman for something. The only things we do are the Pickle in the Christmas tree & St. Nicks'.
• United States
6 Apr 09
I only have a few recipes from when I grew up. My sisters and I had to search the internet and then try to figure out what came closest to what we grew up on. My grandma made some of the best German dishes but we never did see the recipes. Here is the name of a book that I found at the German Showcase at Disney World's Epcot Center that is almost exactly like grandma's cooking. I had a lady who lived in Germany until she was around 35 years old look at the book and she wanted her daughter to get her a copy immediately. She said it was the best book she's ever seen for German recipes and I agree with her. I have not been disappointed with this at all. The name of the book is "The German Cookbook, A Complete Guide to Mastering Authentic German Cooking" by Mimi Sheraton. I have sticky notes marking pages all over this book! I have the updated 1993 copy that is larger than the original. Here is the web page on the higher ratings on the book from Amazon.com http://www.amazon.com/German-Cookbook-Complete-Mastering-Authentic/product-reviews/0394401387/ref=cm_cr_pr_viewpnt_sr_5?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=0&filterBy=addFiveStar If your library has a copy you may want to give it a try before purchasing. I have also seen it in the local bookstores. I love the German Hamburger on page 152, Tomato and Onion Salad on page 306, Hot Potato Salad with Bacon on page 320. The book is 523 pages long and there are about 150 pages just dedicated to all different meats (can't understand the ladies problem with the worst review on the web site). I would love to try some of the dessert recipes sometime. Happy Easter and MyLotting!
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
3 Apr 09
I prefer them from scratch, but I will sometimes cheat and use the boxed instant ones. My kids really don't care one way or the other, so for a quick side with dinner I will do instant.
• United States
5 Apr 09
Yes you are even making me hungry, steak and mashed potatoes... YUM! When will dinner be done?
• United States
7 Apr 09
I usually have pork or chicken with my mashed potatoes along with stovetop stuffing and a vegetable. There is nothing better then dipping your potatoes into your stovetop and getting a big 'ol bite of it!!! Yum!! I only had chips for dinner tonight. It's on for tomorrow!!! Steak and baked potatoes!
@valpopa (154)
• Italy
3 Apr 09
maybe the most important part of making mashed potatoes is the stake that goes with it. Am I the only person who thinks this or am I getting hungry talking about this?
@xhaylea (361)
3 Apr 09
I like mashed potatoes from scratch, even though its much more hard work, i prefer the taste from scratch, and you can make it the right texture for you, and it simply tastes gorgeous unlike instant ones.
• United States
5 Apr 09
You are right instant definatly leaves something to be desired in the texture, flavor, and smell department.
@steph7us (25)
• United States
3 Apr 09
I love mashed potatoes...never from the box always from scratch. Here is an awesome recipe that I created. My family requests it every holiday no matter what we are having. 4-5 mdm russet potatoes, washed 4-5 red potatoes, washed Cut potatoes into small chunks with peeling (more vitamins), remove peel if desired. Boil aobut 15 minutes or until tender in large pot with about a tsp of salt and a couple of dashes of chopped parsley. Drain, mix with the following ingredients. Couple tablespoons of sour cream 4 slices of velveeta cheese Half 8oz pkg of cream cheese tbsp garlic powder tsp onion salt butter You can adjust these ingredients to your liking, mine are different every time. That is the beauty of making something up, you can make it your own and it never exactly the same each time. You can also make this recipe the night before, cover and place in refrigerator. Sit out the next day for about 30 minutes, place in oven until heated through about 30 - 45 minutes at 400 degrees. I tell you these potatoes are the best ever because they are so creamy. Another option is that you can steam some cauliflower and add to the mixture for added vitamins. Your family will never know what you slipped in on them!! Let me know if you try it!! I am cooking them on Sunday!!! salt and pepper to taste
@valpopa (154)
• Italy
3 Apr 09
steph7 NOW THAT IS A RECIPE FOR MASHED POTATOES LADIES AND GENTS!!!!
• United States
5 Apr 09
Doesn't that sound thick and delicious!?!?!
@valpopa (154)
• Italy
3 Apr 09
Buy those potato flakes //that's how they are called right?? and add water intstead of milk to them. I once followed the instructions on the box and they indicated milk and no water...well I added the milk and they did not really smelled like mashed potatoes, they smelled like milk... Maybe adding a bit of butter in the water prepared potato flakes will make them quite yummy you can't tell the difference between the flakes and the real thing
• United States
5 Apr 09
You are supposed to add milk and butter to it atleast according to the directions I've read.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
6 Apr 09
I only used instant potatoes once and never again as I just plain didn't care for the "aftertaste" they seem to have. So I stick to making homemade. I have a whole bunch of different ways of fixing mashed potatoes. One is while the potatoes are boiling I add a clove of garlic..then mashed and blend together ...gives a nice garlicky taste to them. Another is while I'm mashing them over on the flame and adding the butter and milk I also add and let melt a slice (or two) of American Cheese, or even grated Cheddar Cheese....can also add some chives to the potatoes
@Shar19 (8231)
• United States
5 Apr 09
I like both. If I have time then I prefer the home made mashed potatoes. Instant does come in very handy at times. I know some people put in sour cream with their potatoes right before they mash them. I haven't tried it yet.
@bubbletush (1332)
• Philippines
3 Apr 09
Mashed potatoes from scratch tastes better for me but involves lots of work though. But most of the time, I make mashed potatoes from scratch. I just do a simple ingredient of potatoes, milk and butter.
@luvmysons (497)
• United States
3 Apr 09
There is nothing like something made from scratch but i do like instant mashed.. They are good when you just dont have the time.. As far as making from scratch I use red potatoes and leave the skin on them quarter them and boil them. Mash and I add butter sourcream,roasted garlic and alittle milk.. They come out awsome
• United States
6 Aug 10
I like mashed potatoes from scratch =]