What is your choice.... the book or the movie?

United States
May 4, 2009 9:14pm CST
Alot of us has read a book and years later they are turned into a movie version of the book. In some cases, the movie may be viewed as better because it really visualizes what the author may have been trying to get across.... however, alot of times we miss alot of the meanings that are in depth written in the book and you really feel as though you are experiencing it when you read a book... I love to read...hence my name here... and I really experience a book more than the movie because as you read it you visualize it in your head your own way... but everyone perceives things differently... so do you prefer the movie or the book?
2 people like this
26 responses
• Philippines
5 May 09
Due to my busy schedule, I prefer to watch movie if I want to catch up with any latest book titles. Since, it will instill in my memory... Afterwards, I will read the book about that movie, in that way, i will read faster and will expand my views. For me, it is easier for me to do that, so it will improve my vocabulary in english.
• United States
7 May 09
I think that is great you do it that way and yes, what a wonderful way to help improve your english... good for you!! thanks for responding.
1 person likes this
@macor07 (52)
• United Arab Emirates
5 May 09
Well my choice is book, i agree with you that some written words that needs explanation are not all visualize in the movie. It's better to read the abook first before you watched the movie.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
yes, it helps to have a little background from the book so that the movie has more meaning to it. thanks for responding.
1 person likes this
@pawan80 (36)
• India
5 May 09
It depend on interest, reading the book is something like gaining knowledge and it is treated as a habit and movies are basically seen for entertainment purpose.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
that is very true!!! I agree, if I read a book it is for myself, but if we rent a movie it is for the family to be entertained...thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@anniefannie (1737)
• United States
5 May 09
if i see the movie before i read the book it is a good movie but if i have read the book than the move is not good because it leaves out so much that the book covers
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
I know, because in the book you know exactly what the characters are thinking, or it will give you a brief past detail that goes along with it and if you are watching the movie, you may not get that info!! thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
• China
5 May 09
In my opinion, I think it depends on what we read or watch the first. If we read the book and then turn to the movie, we usually find that the movie is disapointed. In contrast, if we watch the movie first and then read the book, we often find the book is not as wondeful as the movie.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
oh thats a very good point... I havent read many books that have been turned into movies... but I have read alot of them that I would love to see as a movie, but it would have to be exactly like the book or they would ruin it....LOL thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@betsyhu (207)
• China
5 May 09
It's difficult to tell whether liking reading or movie. you know, some book is more wonderful than movie,but some is in opposition. Sensitive movie or book is better than ones that be done by stunt in computer only. Those arouse our sympathizes is reflected from real life which ,maybe,we can come across. Reading a good book or movie are all set my heart at rest.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
that is true, they both have there own purpose... thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
5 May 09
id rather read a book than the movie..your right, in movies we miss the true meaning of the whole story, sometimes they even add something to spice up the movie but when we read the the story with a book we see the real meaning of the story and what it gives to inspire us rreaders.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
Yes, it is easier to let yourself become part of the book since you get the inside story with reading, vs. watching the movie and not getting that personal information that tells the story. Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
@pree70 (525)
• India
5 May 09
i prefer reading the book and then watching the movie. just recently, i got a chance to re-read the Jack Higgins book 'the eagle has landed'. after that, i inciedently got the same movie and i must tell you that it was a total disapointment. somehow, the characters in my mind were totally different and the fact that much editing had gone to the movie made it very unsatisfactory. a book for me anyday!
1 person likes this
@pree70 (525)
• India
13 May 09
thanks a lot for the 'best response' tag. have a great time at mylot.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
I can only really remember reading one book before I saw the movie and that was many years ago.... "The Outsiders" and the movie was exactly like the book... however I think after I see some movies and then when I am shopping and see the books I am almost tempted to read the book to see the difference. Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
• Philippines
5 May 09
I like reading the book but I guess I can relate more to the movie.I know that someone visualizes the story events but for me,I cant visualize much.Im having a hard time understanding some words and Im lazy to check it out in the dictionary,or in the net. As of now I prefer movies,I also like reading but movies can make me understand well.Maybe I should widen my vocabulary.
• United States
10 May 09
no, you are right...there are those that need the movie to clarify what they dont understand about the books... Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
@Jennlk84 (4206)
• United States
5 May 09
I prefer to read the book first. The reason I prefer this is because I'd rather read the book and get a picture in my mind before actually being "shown" the story. I like to use my imagination and create the characters and setting in my mind. My imagination always comes up with something better than the movie! haha And then I'm often disappointed in the movie.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
I havent read very many books before the movie comes out, as I tend to stick with romance books... and historicals... but I am going to start looking into expanding what I read... thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@cyrus123 (6363)
• United States
5 May 09
I prefer the book, myself. The book tells you more than the movie does. When you read the book before seeing the movie, you know more about what's going on in the movie. It makes the movie more enjoyable, too, I think. There have been times when I saw the movie before I read the book. That was because I didn't get a chance to read the book for one reason or another. I really do like to read, too. I used to own a bookstore, as a matter of fact. Kathy.
• United States
7 May 09
ahhhh!! you are just like me!!! LOL oh that is so cool you use to own a bookstore.. I probably could open a used book store for all the books I have but I dont want to part with my babies!! LOL thanks for responding.
1 person likes this
@cyrus123 (6363)
• United States
5 May 09
When I read the book, I usually pick out a character that coms pretty close to me and I pretend I'm that character in the movie.Kathy.
1 person likes this
@cyrus123 (6363)
• United States
7 May 09
I don't blame you. I don't like to get rid of my used books, either. There are so many good stories I like to read over and over. I'm the same way with my records. I have quite a record collection, too. Kathy.
1 person likes this
@jayrene (2708)
• Philippines
5 May 09
i prefer the book, as i love reading too. for me the book give's more in depth of the story than that of the movie because in the movie, it's like fast paced, because it should only take 1.5 to 2+ hours from beginning to ending. while in the book, the author can really express everything that he/she wants with her story. and when i am reading, i visualize everything what i am reading. i have seen some movies that are adapted from a book, and quite honestly i was not impressed by it compared to what i have read from the book.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
Yes!! the books play out in your head the way you think it should and then when you see it on screen it isnt at all what you invisioned... for me I choose the book too!! Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
@111flylcx (267)
• China
5 May 09
I prefer to books too.When read the books,all the words apear in front of me,there is the moving pictures like a moive in my mind.The moive was direct by myself ,no super star,no super director.It is my moive.
2 people like this
• United States
7 May 09
that is so true, and I agree with that too!! it is your own personal movie when you read a book!! thanks for the response.
1 person likes this
@meisters (23)
• Indonesia
5 May 09
For me I would like to read the book first, because you can imagine about the storyline, the place, character (like face) and many more after that I watch the movie. Some time the storyline in the book is better than storyline in the movie. Just like Eragorn, in fact I just like the story in the book better than in the movie. Well... this is just my opinion.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
meisters.... I choose the book too!! In so many ways they are better than the movies since you get so much information that isnt in the movies. Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
• United States
10 May 09
derlila....for me as well...I feel more connected to the characters when I read the book and envision them for myself that way the story is more alive and my own personal world vs. the movie. Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
• United States
5 May 09
I agree! I havent seen or read Eragon, so I cant speak for that movie/book. Often, though there is so much that is left out of movies so that the movie isnt a whole day long! You are always missing something in the movie that you can get in the book. I also like being able to envision the characters. It makes you feel better connected to them. You can envision them as someone you know or someone you have made up. They seem far more real to you than watching a screen. I love that about a book!
1 person likes this
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
6 May 09
In most cases, I like the movie far better than the book. Because in the movie it is all put together, it doesn't last forever, and it's just a much easier format. But in some cases, such as that of Brave New World I just felt that the movie wasn't really all that good. Same thing with 1984, not a good movie. And in the case of Bridge to Terabithia, which is one of my favorite books, I was really afraid I wasn't going to like that movie. But I can say I liked the book and movie equally well. And it turns out when I read the book on audio later, that the movie was very close to the both since the author's son worked on it. It was truly a masterpiece.
@Ronina (185)
• Philippines
7 May 09
I read the book first though it is long when you read the story its amazing also because i can experience and visualize what the author wanted to tell the reader. In the movie sometimes the highlights in the book was not the one you expect it to be.
@haiershen (1080)
• China
8 May 09
i like reading books and also like looking movies, in my opinion, this is no conflict,if this book is more interest, i am very like to see the movies, if the movies is vivid and i like the author very much, i will see the book according when the chance coming. good movies and best books are all attacted for me.
1 person likes this
@marites31 (267)
• Philippines
5 May 09
i love movies and reading but i prefer movies. it makes ur eyes and ur heart beats faster!! more excitement because of the visuals!!
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
yes much more excitement!!! Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
• Finland
5 May 09
People that say "I like the book better then the movie" have acctually never seen/read movies/books that this would apply to. "A Movie is based on a book" true "But a book is in practice never based on a movie". There are these books but as I see it the people reading these book are BIG fans of the Movie in coustion and I will bet my bottom dollar that these people would think the Movie is better... I can only base this on ONE book and ONE movie i have read/seen... And then my "true" answer to this is the Movie...
1 person likes this
• United States
10 May 09
I can see your point... very well put!! Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!
@Tonton01 (235)
• Philippines
5 May 09
For Accuracy's Sake, I'd choose the book over the movie..though sometimes, I choose the movie for the theatrics. :)
• United States
10 May 09
that makes sense...you have to give credit to the movies that puts things into visual perspective... LOL Happy mylotting!!! and have a great day!!