vigilantism, right or wrong?

@JodiLynn (1417)
United States
June 3, 2009 8:54am CST
vigilantism is the act of taking the law into your own hands. There is a case unfolding in Philadelphia Pa (USA) about a man who was beaten senseless by a group of angry people. BACK STORY: Jose Carasquillo has had many brushes with the law, including a charge of attempted assault/rape in 1994. Most of his arrests were for drugs, he had just been released from prison a short time ago (6 yr stint). Monday At 8:20 AM, an 11 year old girl drops her little sister off at daycare, then she accosted by Mr Carasquillo, pushed into an alleyway into a small yard, where she is repeatedly beaten, raped and sodomized, and finally left for dead. She did manage to get to the street where she was found bloody and crying by a pedestrian, who called 911. The police are on it (the crime) big time. News channels are showing this man's photo, tip lines are flooded by calls from people who KNOW the perpetrator, including his own family members. Later, Carasquillo is shown on surveillance video walking down the street when some one recognizes him and approaches him. 1 person became 4, then 7, then more, and the mob beats him down and holds him until police units can come scrape him off the sidewalk. No one asked for the reward monies (10 thousand), and this is a very poor section of Philly. The media interviewed many witness's, no one was sorry for Carasquillo, no one was bothered by the vigilantism, in fact, it seemed as though it was condoned by almost all the officials and media. the wheels of justice turn so slowly, have we forgotten the reason to have laws and governance of the laws by Police? raping a child is just about the worst possible thing a person could EVER do, and is NEVER justifiable. Were the vigilantes right or wrong to whoop him good (he's hospitalized presently, so is his victim) for his crime? (my personal opinions have been squelched in order to discuss the issue)
2 people like this
4 responses
@jb78000 (15139)
3 Jun 09
I have to say if it had been my daughter I woud've been so furious and upset it'd have been hard not to join in. this doesn't mean viligantism is right though - it can get out of hand, it can get the wrong person. you have to choose to either have laws or not and if you have them they don't work if they are ignored when you think an occasion demands it
2 people like this
@JodiLynn (1417)
• United States
3 Jun 09
The mob mentality is what I find frightening. I concur, had it been my child I may have acted the same way. by the by, 3 of those who beat him up were family members, HIS FAMILY members! but WHAT IF it hadn't been the right guy?
2 people like this
@mrbluey (36)
• Singapore
3 Jun 09
Usually, extents of injustice are never equal. I'm uncertain about this case. I am never for revenge. However, my personal bias, most probably similar to the public consensus when they beat up the offender, is that the man probably would not have gotten his 'just deserts' for what they felt was atrocious. I agree. Yet, I try constantly to remember that, all the talk of the vengeful sufferings he would sustain in jail, and that of the public subconscious motivation for beating him up, aside; the man was indeed wronged somewhat. Hence? I am against such vigilantism. And certainly against such violent sorts, I am, because of the moral unfair nature of such incidences. Mercy over justice is one of the highest things absent in this world. Sadly, in this matter, it was absent once again. Furthermore, particularly in this matter, 'justice' probably was stretched to meet the consensus of the huge majority - even the police. So.. I am somewhat unhappy about how this matter turned out, but I'm glad its more or less over. Hopefully this has provided a little extra insight.
1 person likes this
@JodiLynn (1417)
• United States
3 Jun 09
It is so hard to apply compassion to an individual such as this. A true "Mercy" would be for this and all pedophiles to die off completely, but I don't think that will ever happen.
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Jun 09
Superman, and the Green Lantern were comic heroes before I was born. I think Batman, too. Think about it. These "heroes" perform vigilante "justice." Yet they keep cranking out the block busters. Any idea why?
@JodiLynn (1417)
• United States
4 Jun 09
you are spot on with that analogy. We WANT to be that super hero who gets the job done, no matter the obstacles. The mob mentality is what blows it, it removes the altruistic reasoning for a super hero.
• United States
4 Jun 09
many of us are getting frustrated with the idea of criminals such as this man being allowed to walk among us and continue to commit horrible crimes. i understand why these people took it upon themselves to do what they did. we need to get tougher on criminals and not set them free. pedophiles and murderers and rapists cannot be cured and should not be allowed to repeat their crimes. there is too much corruption and incompentance in the system and that needs to change. i also think that we should have federal laws so that state to state every crime would be punishable the same way. this child is damaged for life after this horrific crime and this man is not going to be punished enough for it.
@JodiLynn (1417)
• United States
4 Jun 09
If WE, the PEOPLE of the US make the laws, why have we neglected the ones that pertain to violence against children? Why can you murder a baby and receive only a minimum sentence (2 to 4 yrs in most states). Do we not value a child's life as much as an adult? or a cop? or a politician? sadly, it appears that we do not.