What Do You Think About Breedism?

Portugal
June 4, 2009 3:25am CST
Yesterday i saw a commercial that made think a bit about the issue... I´ll leave the link here for your judgement...and then, let us start the debate... (just write "wrong meeting" on youtube - i can paste the link here) My opinion is: breedism radicates on the idea that not all dogs are equal, instead, there are some (breed, pedigree, etc) that are...shall we say "superior", than others... I think this is dangerous and make people simply discriminate non pedigree dogs...that discrimination happens, for example, when instead of getting an abandoned dog in a kennel you pay hundred of bucks for a "superior" dog... What´s your opinion?
4 responses
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
4 Jun 09
I think it's stupid. Most of those purebreds have genetic defects because of all the inbreeding used to create them. Most vets could probably list you the problems from each type by breed. Greyhounds have a high # of bone cancer, cockier spaniels often have digestive problems & so on & so forth. Why would you knowingly encourage these problems?
2 people like this
• Portugal
4 Jun 09
Hum..nice insight..i confess i didn´t knew about that, uath...that´s really not normal at all.. As i said, and i agree with you, if we like dogs, we like DOGS..not only the suposably "superior" ones. I suppose it is as ridiculous as wanting to adopt only blonded, blue eyes kids..what is the message that we´re passing through? Hurray pureblood lines? Hum...superior race? Hum...where did i saw that kind of speech before?... Thanks for your comment, uath..very useful.. ;) Peace
• United States
5 Jun 09
Many of the purebreeds also have personality disorders. This is largely becuase of what they are bread for (hunters and guard dogs may be a little feircer) Chow's and Pits are known for having some unfriendly moments.
• Portugal
5 Jun 09
Hum..yes, i agree, Troublegum, but that´s a totally diferent issue..All dogs, all cats, all animals have predatory instincts, that´s their nature..even humans have many diferent levels of instincts..what really makes the diference is the way you manage those instincts, which is directly linked with processes of learning, education, socialization, etc.. All animals, rational (humans), and irrationals (dogs, in this case), can be dangerous.. Main issue here: breedism is a way of purifying races, thus, it can be a harmful thing. Second issue here: environment (education, cultural, socialization) makes what you are. Instincts can be curved. Peace
• United States
4 Jun 09
Since most 'purebreeds' have many and varied genetic defects I think breedism is really silly and potentially dangerous.
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
5 Jun 09
Well that's a ditto.... Glad I'm not the only one who knows about this problem.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Jun 09
No problem, I just find it really disturbing. I have a half-lab/half rottweiler mix and she's only now just starting to slow down at 12 years old, she didn't have any of the heart problems or hip issues that both breeds have when their 'purebreed' and only recently started to get ill, cancer in her leg that came on very quickly. I honestly think she'd have had a lot more issues and not have lived as long if she was a 'purebreed' and due to that I would never get one. She's hearty and sweet, the best of both breeds, same as our Pitbull whose also a mix, she's sweet as the day is long but tough, which if she were purebreed I'd be much more concered about having her around small children.
• Portugal
5 Jun 09
I understand what you said about being concerned with a purebreed pit around your children, unbreakable, but I really dont agree with the implications of that judgement... As i said before, it´s a question of education.. It is the owner that shapes the dog´s behaviour, not the basic instinct.. No one, but you, has the right to manage what types of pets should be close to your children, nonetheless, my opinion is: it is not the dog, it´s the owner. Peace
@hairypits (294)
9 Jun 09
I am going to stick my opinion in now which is a little different to those I read before posting (eeeeek - don't shout at me) I have been researching this very subject for my own satisfaction because we are getting 2 puppies in a fortnight. We decided to get kennel club registered puppies from accredited breeders who provide a five generation pedigree with their dogs. All of the dogs throughout the generations have been hip scored and health checked prior to being bred and therefore minimise any risk of passing on hereditory diseases. With cross breeds and dogs not registered with the kennel club, you don't know any history, any potential health problems, and you could have bred all of 2 breeds bad points into one dog. There's a lot more to it than that but we were advised by the kennel club that if you are buying a kc reg dog expect to pay for what you get whereas if you get an unregistered or cross bred dog DON'T PAY MORE THAN WHAT COSTS THE BREEDER HAS INCURRED AS A RESULT OF HAVING THESE PUPS. I think it is actually quite cruel to cross breed dogs. We went ahead and have got two registered pedigree pups. Interesting.
@SusanLee (1920)
• United States
10 Jun 09
lol, no reason for anyone to shout at you. We give a one-year-warranty with our pups, so far no one has asked for the their money back (today I will probably get a call lol) I wish I could really get involved with breeding like with the KC.
@SusanLee (1920)
• United States
9 Jun 09
I am divided on the issue I guess. I don't see a 'Pure Bred' as a superior animal like some people do I suppose. We have four Boston Terriers that we breed on occasion. These days I'm torn about that. I don't want to bring puppies into the world and have them go to someone who is going to dump them in the yard and ignore them, or chain them to a tree. If we have a low price set, then anyone can buy one. If we set it high enough, then I hope anyone who is willing to invest in one of my dogs is going to more than likely really care for it. I will never know though, it's like they're going into foster-care or something, will they be abused? We just sort of stumbled into this situation, it was my husbands doing. imagine his surprise when I had our stud male neutered lol. The poor dog was going nuts trying to get to the females who where all come into heat at different times. He was skin and bones. Bottom line, people will pay for what they want whether it be a high priced breed, or a small adoption fee at the kennel for a mixed breed. Many times, and I know this sounds stupid; I will see strays roaming the highway, heavy with puppies, or milk from recently having puppies. They are looking for something to eat. At times like that I wish God would just reach down and take every dog off the face of the earth, man doesn't deserve the joy, love and companionship of these animals. Then I look into the faces of my dogs, and try not to think about the lost out there.