American Idol without Simon Cowell

I agree with you that Simon is the best judge on the show. If he wasn't on I probably would stop watching. The only other judge that I really like is Kara. The other two get on my nerves a bit.

I honetly don't think that American Idol could survive without the presence of Simon Cowell. One of the main reasons I watch that show is to hear his witty and sarcastic comments...he is the only one who tells it like it is on that show..All the other ones, especially the ladies, sugar coat it a bit too much.

I enjoy Simon's comments, but ultimately it's the singers that are the reason I watch the show. So yeah, I'd still watch.

I watched American Idol because of Simon Cowell, i like him everytime he gives his comment. Sometimes its afrading because he really gives bad comment, but i like him, maybe he just give his opinions. I wish Simon will continue doing his job in American Idol till the show is there.

I'd be totally bummed out if Simon Cowell won't be in American Idol. He is the only reason why I watch the program. AI isn't what it is without Simon.

for me American Idol will not me American Idol without Simon Cowell he does everything right iN AI. Simon is the cherry on the top of the ice cream in every week. even though he judge so rubbish, and very harsh!

American Idol is about the singer on the show, but it would not be american idol if simon was to leave. all three judges make american idol what it is along with ryan. if any of them left it would probably survive but would not be all good.