P2P File Sharing: Cheating or Being Resourceful?

United States
July 5, 2009 6:03am CST
I have seen a lot of comments lately concernig p3p file sharing. Programs like utorrent. vuze, and limewire have been among the most talked about. I have read a lot of comments where people think that it is outright stealing to use this type of shareware. Where others feel that there is nothing wrong with it. What are your thoughts on using this type of software to obtain movies, software, etc. without paying for it? For those of you unfamiliar with these programs; they allow you to download software etc., that you would normally have to purchase but someone has already done that and uploaded the file so others can download it. Most of the time the program will include a working serial number or a program that will create a working serial number. I think most people argue that it has already been purchased and that person can do what they want while other people argue that the product's copyright was only mean for a single purchase per use. As long as the uploader shares his file for free without charge is he violating the copyright?
2 responses
@benny128 (3615)
5 Jul 09
hey cable, well its quite a tricky subject and is very subjective to peoples opinions. Personally heres my take on it, p 2 p is illegal it is effectively software piracy, though that said I personally download items using bit-torrents, Though the reason why I do it is if a album comes out from an artist or a new computer game then I will download a hacked copy of the game or album. If the game or album isnt very good it saves me from wasting my money, though if I like the album or game then I go out and buy the original. I can see how it affects the owners or copy right holders but p 2 p is here and I truely believe more people should do what I do and purchase the item in question if they like it. That would also mean that the developers or artists wouldn't be able to get away with creating a few good songs on an album and the rest being average or same as a computer game great marketing poor game if everyone done what I do I think the standards would rise as people wouldnt purchase a inferior game or album they would just delete it after downloading.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Jul 09
Haven't seen you in a while!! Good to see you again Benny. I have to agree with you that although they are basically illegal I have been guilty of using them especially when I am unsure of an expensive software program and they don't have a demo. And of course the songs. I believe a lot of people have been guilty of that.
@dragon54u (31636)
• United States
5 Jul 09
Technically, loaning your dvd or cd to someone at no charge isn't wrong. But when you share it with potentially millions of people that want to take advantage of someone's talent with no intention of paying for the product, I believe it is theft. Sharing with everyone in the world-or at least everyone who has a computer-is quite different from lending a disc to the guy down the street. Think of it this way--you have an ebook that you worked hard to produce. It's a best seller and you're doing well. Suddenly, sales fall off and you find that somehow a few people who have bought your ebook put it on a files haring program and anyone who wants it can have it for free. Pretty soon your income dries up and you have to produce another ebook, but the same thing happens. Now you have no income and you lose everything you've worked so hard for. File sharing is no different from going into a store and stealing a disc. It's the volume of the sharing that's the problem. It negatively impacts sales and robs artists of just compensation for their talents.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Jul 09
Thank you for your response. I am thinking about making an e-book and that makes me think a little more about the p2p thing because I wouldn't want mine copied either. I will be making it to earn money on and copying it would hurt the income I would receive. I have thought about putting mine on dvd and mailing it to help prevent this problem.