Prepaid Electric Billing Scheme

@rsa101 (37966)
Philippines
July 29, 2009 6:45pm CST
This morning I heard that our electric company is planning a Prepaid electric bill scheme. They will start in Malabon City to test whether it is indeed viable to implement it or not. I can see some advantages and disadvantages in using it but I want to know what are the opinion of my fellow Pinoys regarding this matter. Do you think this scheme would be better for us or more problematic to our budget in the future?
3 people like this
9 responses
@sunrisefan (28524)
• Philippines
26 Oct 18
That would lessen their expense for meter readers. Another advantage for the electric company is that they don't have to send a team anymore to cut you off if you have not paid your bill. The connection automatically cuts off when your load is fully consumed.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
26 Oct 18
That is one advantage for the providers. It also lessens the pain of printing the bills and delivering it to the customers. For us consumers we should be given an access to know how much load there is left from our load. There are a few that are under this scheme already but I could not find if it is advantageous for them or not. There is not much of promotion of this scheme yet. Perhaps MERALCO is still studying the impact of this over the postpaid scheme.
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
26 Oct 18
@sunrisefan Yes I think even the loading can be done through texting as well.
1 person likes this
@sunrisefan (28524)
• Philippines
26 Oct 18
@rsa101 I think the advantage is more on the power provider. That does not mean though that the disadvantage is on the consumer. The advantage on the consumer is that he consumes only up to what he can afford. I'm sure the power provider will be making it possible to consumers to know their load balance via text. Technology is always improving.
1 person likes this
@eichs1 (1934)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
There are those who really wanted this implemented. I can't see the reason why they want this to be done. The primary reason this was proposed is to let the consumer's have control their budget/consumption. Can't you that with the post-paid system? They say this will be more economical to some but I really don't think so. How can that be if you are just using the bare necessity? Don't you think this is just being used to allow the entry of a big business in the country? Who will be the supplier of the new meters? Who will be the producer of the cards? And how about tax collection here? Will the government be able to track down the actual sales of electricity through pre-paid metering? If they have the means to monitor, why have they not implemented such with the sales of the telephone companies' (TelCo) SIM and pre-paid cards? And here's another thing. How reliable will be the metering and billing system? Will there be no system loss (just like the case of missing loads in our celphones)?
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
For Postpaid it is really hard to manage consumption since as long as there is electricity flowing in we seem to be less conscious about our usage we only get surprised by the bill when the month ends. But with the prepaid, we will be forced to monitor our consumption or else I would lose loads easily and eventually will be forced to buy load again. On the other hand, you do present some point in there. There are still many questions that need to be answered on this matter. I hope that with the Malabon experiment this issues would be brought to light so that they could address appropriate action on this matter. Although this proposal is only optional but with it we may have a choice which suits our needs on how we can manage our electrical consumption.
@eichs1 (1934)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
That's the logic they are always presenting. And maybe they are right. But just try to do a survey how people use their pre-paid load in their mobile phones. Many are not checking their loads every now and then specially if they just reloaded. They'll just use send sms messages every now and then until - tut!tut! - Your message can not be sent. Please reload again. I am not aware that it was already being tested in Malabon. I thought this is still in the survey to check the public reaction and to see the number of people who might want to try and use the product. But yes, let's still give such thing a try. I do really hope though that our government have the right measures in place to protect the interest of the consumers in this matter.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
Yes that is true even the prepaid can still become a problem especially if the user won't be conscious enough to watch over his/her load. But for those that are conscious about their loads that would not be a problem. In my time when i was using prepaid for my cellphone I never got to the point that I would lose a load I always anticipate when I would lose the load. I was very conscious about it back then. But you are right it is really hard to keep watch on it especially when we're talking about electricity. We got used to the notion that when its connected it will be flowing freely until the month end when we have to face reality how much we've consumed.
@Thoroughrob (11742)
• United States
30 Jul 09
I can see it causing problems for using more than you paid for, and yet they probably would not get stuck with people not paying as easy.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
Yeah I guess our electric company would also like to eliminate those that could not afford. By using the prepaid they are paid before they can utilize electricity.
@agv0419 (3022)
• Philippines
31 Jul 09
It is good news for us so we can be able to know our real electricity consumption without some added taxes. I hope they going to implement it very soon. Meralco is charging us so much even if our consumption is very low. It is a big issues for years it is a good idea now that we have an option so we can switch to prepaid.
@roniroxas (10560)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
for me i would say that it is okaym but i think it would be nice if it is a choice. i mean just like our cellphones. there are people who like it pre-paid and some enjoyed it as post paid. for me i would rather pay after a month use, (the usual) rather than the pre paid. i am a very busy woman and i dont have that much time to check how much the load we have ( if thats how they will call it) and how much we are going to consume. i dont like that i will be running out of electricity in the middle of the night while my children and nephew are sleeping, and i dont want also to be running out with electricity while my children are doing something important on the computer. i know people who lives in area who deos not pay electric bill. i know you are aware of that too, there are some areas in malabon were people just tap electricity and is free of charge. if they will push this pre paid system i think they have to do it first on areas that are not paying but are using electricity. i think it would be a problem if we go for pre paid for it is a problem already on our cellphone loads that sometimes we dont get waht we paid for. magkakadayaan lang thats what i think. just my opinion
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
That is a good point in there. I think Meralco has said that they are not putting the postpaid scheme off since most of their clients are on these scheme already. it would be a big headache for them to switch to a preapid if they would implement this to all of us. I guess you are right about losing connection in the middle of the night because you were out of load already. I think that would be pretty inconvenient for us and we would buy as many prepaid loads so that we can have enough in times we need it. It would still not be cost effective since you will have to buy lots of load to continue to have a continues flow of electricity. Yes, I was also thinking about the "Daya"(Cheat) issue that is running with cellphone companies. Many are complaining of losing prepaid loads not being able to know how their loads are being consumed on their cellphones, I think these could also happen especially on electric rates that is fluctuating every now and then. Electric companies could easily say that the frequent losing of loads could be due to the fluctuating electric rates as an excuse.
@roniroxas (10560)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
i base my response on what happened to me a few weeks back. i lost my broadban connection and the company told me that they are repairing a cabinet of connection and my connection is in that ine cabinet. i am taking care of my nephew and my sister is at japan so we really need the communications so i bought one of this plug in prepaid internet connection that looks like a usb. it was said on the info that 5 pesos per 15 minutes, but 20 minutes has passed a page was not loaded yet. so for me its just wasting time and load. i just hope the electric company will not be as head ache as this pre paid loads we get on other services
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
Yep, I can see there are some flaws with the prepaid system right now. We really need to watch what the results are for the area of Malabon would say about it.
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
31 Jul 09
I am currently using the prepaid cable scheme... and it is quite good because i am not pressured to pay cable bills every month... like if i don't have enough money... i just won't buy any load... but that would mean no tv for me and my daughter... I don't know if i will ever patronize this prepaid electric billing scheme... since electricity is like a vital part of the household... and to lose one in the middle of the night or when we need it the most is too much of a hassle... imagine not having electricity when we need to iron clothes... and it is at night when stores that sell prepaid electricity are already closed... i wouldn't know what to do...
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
31 Jul 09
You do pose a valid concern. What if the load would last only until and the load would be consumed in the middle of the night? That would mean you have to rush to the stores to buy the load. And if that happens n the middle of the night then you have to bear having no power till the next time. I hope the planners of this thing would also think about your concern.
@anniefannie (1737)
• United States
1 Aug 09
they have that system in the town where i moved from i didn't have it i would run out before i would remember to go buy more so i would rather pay like i always let them read my meater and send me a bill
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
1 Aug 09
Yeah if you are not that conscious about your load there is a chance that you might get to loose your load. The thing here is that you should be aware and be responsible for your consumption that is why in prepaid system you are supposed to be watchful of your consumption so that electricity would flow continously in your house.
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
30 Jul 09
I do think that every system has its advantages and disadvantages. Our system in my country is that you have an estimated bill bi monthly than you get an annual bill which is actual and you have to settle the difference. Either you get reimbursed or else pay the balance
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
Wow that is really a different billing system of yours. Very simple for your electric company but could you know your monthly consumption with this system?
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
I think we should at least try to it so we know if this is more effective or not. However, I think it's better if the government will put more pressure on people who steal power. If you look at some squatters area, you will be amazed on how they have obvious illegal connection but not being caught. If only the law is being strictly implemented, then it will be a big help for all of us, prepaid or not. Thanks!
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
That is why I think they are implementing this project on one are at the moment. it will be in Malabon. As to why there? I have no idea at all. I guess you are right about having a stricter law on Illegal connection that is really hard to curb because of lack of stricter law to abide upon. It seems that we are the ones who pay for these thieves that haunt every electric company in existence. They can only cut illegal connection but those who perpetrate the crime is still left on the loose and is not being indicted because there is lack of a better law to prosecute them.
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
i dont think we are up to it. load is not a necessity but electricity is. and you are correct in saying that it is a hassle to check on ur balances. i think this would be more applicable on rented places like apartments and boarding houses since it is the burden of the owner if the renter does not pay.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (37966)
• Philippines
30 Jul 09
Well Meralco has said that they would not enforce that scheme to everybody since all of their customers are on postpaid already. The only concern for me is that the rate of electricity is always fluctuating and if ever there is an adjustment that would mean the value of the load also decreases too. It would be an easy excuse for the electric company to say the load is easily consumed because of the increases in the rates. Unlike in Cellphone or Telephone that offers prepaid, they have a fixed rates so we could somehow estimate if we have consumed it or not, but for the electricity it would be hard to estimate that amount.