Bisaya-Tagalog feud in youtube

The video was really great! I had goosebumps through the whole scene. That commenter was a jealous loser. I am Bisaya and I'm proud of it! That doesn't make me less of a person. I hope that Anastacio realized how unprofessional and irresponsible his comment was.

I have seen the first comment made by Anastacio Cruz to the uploaded video project of HIgh School students. I think it really was not a good comment. It did not sound as constructive at all, but humiliating and discriminating. For High School students to see those comments would be so hurting and degrading. It could affect them. If he was a teacher who made such kind of comment, he could be charged by those students. I find that Anastacio Cruz to be rude and arrogant.

well i have seen the video and i think its really great! yes its great to think that it was made by high school students...so its not bad at all...in fact for me its quite impressive and they should be credited for their efforts... of course because tagalog is not their mother tongue some mistakes will really show especially on pronunciation...but so what? hehehe what is important is the result...anyway, they are still young and still have so much room for improvement... to mr. cruz i think he's being too harsh and insensitive...and yes discriminating...but i hope visayan speaking people will not take it against tagalog speaking people...for not all tagalog are like that man...i think he's a shame for tagalogs! and i think this is not healthy for our country...coz even if we speak of different dialects...still we are all Filipino and we should learn to respect others! well i am a tagalog myself...and living in visayan region... and i hope those kids will not take it too serious but instead take it as a challenge for them...to prove that mr. cruz is very wrong with his comments...

Don't mind him, he's just another Tagalog fanatic who doesn't believe that Visayans or other dialects are part of Filipino Language. that's more of an Comment coming from a foreigner, something he's trying to be more like westener who make very frank criticisms that either hurt or humiliate the person. He had the option to criticize it in a nice way..He's clearly just a looser in Disguise...

the one who made that comment is a crap..!i am not a bisaya, i am a pure waray-waray but he has no right to do that considering that, that video was made by a certainly not professional 15-year old student..and it was not intended for any awards or something, they just felt that since it was the best film in their school, why not upload it to youtube so that many people will see it..he might be a good commentator on a movie but considering what he has done, i don't think he himself can make a movie like that..i sympathize that kid who did the efforts in uploading that video..and that man, he will surely have his karma in time..

ive seen the trailer and all i can say its good for a young high school student to work on that trailer, me myself cant do that. that anastacio will go to hell. those on el fili are my fellow iliganons. im proud of their work. creative and they put all their hard work for it considering for the little time they make this. its a school project so why would anastacio give such bad comments! there are lots of positive feedbacks on youtube.

This could be a case of typical cyber bullying. I think this person could be just another student who is taken by jealousy or someone who is just plain unhappy and wants to get some attention and wants to make others unhappy as well. The video trailer was very good considering that the high school students were given only two weeks to come up with it and to think that they were not professionals and a very 15 year olds is a quite a great achievement.

Hey kyss_smyle! That's really nice of you to go an extra mile to defend the poor 15-old students who made the said video. I think that the person who made a bad comment about the video is just jealous, because he can never be as good as those amateur students. The person's an A-hole.

i truly have seen it already. my God!!! they are truly good in the short trailer they did. i do make movies like this but i was so amazed. in that age, they really do ahve much mor to offer. i am so proud of those kids. though i also have seen the comments of that given person, and i should say i was hurt because i am a Filipino and a Bisaya. i live in mindanao as well and i have been to that place because i go to college in their place. but i dont really care what that person says. whats important is that they did make a very very very great job!!! and i am so proud of them... keep it up guys!!!! jhelai

I'm glad you shared the link. After seeing it, I personally admire whoever made the video. For a youngster like him... he is very much talented. And being a Bisaya myself... I am very proud of this production. Whoever made the comment should be ashame of himself. How dare he judge Bisayas. Even more... how dare he post that comment, not only hurting that student, but all of us who've read it. To this Anastacio J. Cruz... you're a loser!!! I won't be surprised if you can't even make that kind of production at the age of 15.

I am not aware of this but all I can say that good info on here.Have a good day

magandang araw! ikinagagalak kong ipakilala ang aking sarili bilang STAR ng diskusyong ito. Ako si ANASTACIO CRUZ. gayunpaman, ikinalulungkot ko ang MALING pang-unawa ng mga kapwa ko Pilipino lalo na ang mga Bisaya sa aking simple at konstruktibong komento sa isang video na inapload sa youtube.com PUNTO: Ang video ay aking napanood sa pamamagitan ng isang "CHANNEL COMMENT" galing sa mismong uploader ng naturang panoorin. Ganito ang nilalaman ng mensaheng tinutukoy ko;"Try mo ring panoorin yung version namin ng fili. Ito yung trailer..."at ibinigay yung link nung video. PUNTO; dala ng curiousity, binuksan ko ang link sa pag-asang maganda ang nilalaman nito. Sa tono kasi ng mensaheng aking natanggap, tila proud na proud ang uploader na ipangalandakan ang kanyang video. Nang mapanood ko ang video, napansin kong mga baguhan nga lang ang gumawa noon. Hilaw, kulang, at payak ang naturang trailer. Napansin ko rin ang PUNTONG BISAYA sa ilang cast. Hindi ko dinidiskrimina ang mga Bisaya. Hindi ko kailanman tinatanggalan ng karapatan ang mga Bisaya at iba pang Pilipinong gumagamit ng ibang dayalekto. Ang sa akin lang, hindi dapat ipinahalata ng aktor ang kanyang punto sapagkat naging masagwa sa paningin ng mga manonood. Ibig sabihin, ang papel na Simoun halimbawa, ay hindi kailanman maaaring magkaroon ng puntong Bisaya. Hindi ko sinasabing walang Bisaya ang pwedeng gumanap na Simoun. Pwede rin naman. Huwag nga lang ipahalata ang punto sapagkat masagwa, SA AKING SARILING PANANAW. Ang hilaw na produksyon, editing, at iba pang negatibong aspeto na aking pinunto sa unang komentong aking ipinaskil ay bunga ng aking PAGKA-DISMAYA. Ang buong akala ko kasi ay mahusay na mahusay ang naturang trailer matapos itong IPAGMALAKI sa akin ng uploader. Gayunpaman, uulitin kong ang lahat ng tao ay may karapatang magbigay ng kritisismo. Iba-iba nga lang ng paraan. Ang paraan ko marahil ay nakasakit ng damdamin. Subalit, iyon ang aking SARILING PANANAW. Hindi ko hinihingi ang pagsang-ayon ng mga tao sa aking komento. Gayundin, obligasyon ng bawat alagad ng sining na BUKAS-PALAD na TANGGAPIN ang positibo o negatibong KOMENTO na galing sa KANINOMAN. Huwag nating tingnan ang mga PUNA bilang paninira o kung ano pa man. Bagkus, gamitin natin itong tulay upang paghugutan ng kompyansa para mag-improve at lalo pang humusay sa larangang ating ginagawa. Pasintabi rin po sa mga BISAYANG aking nasagasaan. Hindi ko po intensyon na saktan ang inyong damdamin. Marahil, hindi nga lang ninyo nauunawaan ang aking komento. Ibinababa ko po ang aking sarili at HUMIHINGI NG PAUMANHIN sa lahat ng naapektuhan ng aking komento. Magkagayonman, pinaninindigan ko pa ring WALANG MASAMA sa aking ipinahayag. Maraming Salamat at Mabuhay ang Sining Pilipino!

Madandang Araw! Im proud to introduce myself as the star of this discussion, im ANASTACIO CRUZ. Anyway, hayaan ninyong linawin ko ang mga isyung lumikha ng maingay na kontrobersiya sa malayang espasyo ng internet matapos kong ibigay ang isang simple at konstruktibong komento. PUNTO: