Recycle okay, but is this taking it to far?

@coffeebreak (17797)
United States
August 17, 2009 10:01am CST
I am frugal, I am economical, I am money saving, I am picking up pennies in the parking lot. I am resourceful and always finding and looking for ways to save money or stretch my dollars the farthest and concerned about the environment and landfills and recycling. However... there is an end to it at some point in time, where it might become an obsession and that might start causing problems... like uncleanliness and such. Here is a new way to make resuable food containers for using in a lunch box... http://searcha.familyfun.go.com/?q=Reusable+Lunch+Containers&x=12&y=17 Is this something you would do? Or do you think this is just taking it all to far?
6 people like this
11 responses
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
18 Aug 09
yup....too far for me. who would do that? heck the containers that you get sandwhich meat in are reuseable...why would anyone go thru all that work ? I agree...way over the top.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I know! I have some from Hillshire Farms... bought the meat in them and they have air tight lids and are perfect 4 serving size for a meal or for freezing.. I have a stack of them and use and wash and use again. ANd since the jug container will eventually be tossed anyway... it still goes to the landfills...just a little while later and in different form! But the rubber containers with air tight lids.. last for years!
• United States
27 Aug 09
This was really a great questions and you got some really awesome responses. I gotten a lot of great ideas on recycle and stretching my dollar further as you said. Thank you great discussion.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
27 Aug 09
Glad it offered some ideas! But I still say it is overboard! A plain old Rubbermaid or similar plastic container has much more longevity before it lands in a landfill, plus it is more useful... it is air tight... food can't fall out, or spoil due to air drying it out and you don't have to worry about the food messing up when the container rolls around in a back pack or lunch box.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
4 Sep 09
That's a good thought, ellaprice76. Start the thinking process for recycling. Many don't bother. Or give the kids an idea to do things like that for fun and recycle too. I would think tho, that this particular item is more work than most would bother with- you'd have to cut the milk jug exactly perfectly, and then it isn't air tight, so things wouldn't stay in place. But if it works for some... Plastic containers with fitting lids is what I do. That milk jug thing only lasts a short while till it gets tossed. But these plastic containers last so much longer! Buy Rubber maid, but as you, I just use the containers from things I buy. I bought Hillshire Farm lunch meat while back that was in a nice size plastic container..I have a stack of them in the cabinet.. they all fit together so a single stack and the lids stand in the top container. I'd say we are doing our part to recycle!
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hi coffeebreak, yes in a way it is overkill. Although I think the message which they are trying to get across is not so much as to recycle old milk cartons but to inspire people on how to be creative, involve your children in creating new things out of old items instead of running to the store and buy something new. If you look around you will find teenagers and adults who have a really hard time in managing their money mainly because the media told them go and buy something new. I also noticed that it is only recently that people starting to appreciated handmade items. Maybe I'm wrong.
@jend80 (2071)
• United Kingdom
17 Aug 09
I think those ideas look great, will save on containers going to landfill - I don't see any problems with them as long as people make sure they've been thoroughly cleaned. Wish I'd known about the milk box one way back when I was having packed lunches at school.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
17 Aug 09
But you still toss it all...eventualy. So you don't buy any baggies... buy some plastic containers that you wash and reuse. They are even air tight and keep food longer. THose you don't toss, at least not for quite some time.
@2timothy (794)
• Philippines
18 Aug 09
The resource person would reuse the recycled lunchbox for a long time because he use Vecro rather than just a simple tape to secure it. I would too at least until the folded flap breaks or tears off.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
But when it breaks or tears you still toss it. But the ones like Rubbermaid.. those last for years! ANd you still wash them both out after each use
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
17 Aug 09
I recycle plastic milk jugs into planters all of the time. In fact here is a picture of one if anyone wants to take a look: http://drann.typepad.com/anns_aerogarden_updates/ Of course the tomato is a lot bigger now! Those jugs can be sanitized by running them through the dishwasher, so I don't think they are unclean, even for the lunchbag substitute. Admittedly when I read your discussion, I cringed a little, just as I do when I see people refilling milk jugs with drinking water at the kiosks--now THAT might be taking a chance--but after reading the article, I decided those lunch carriers are not only clean enough but very cute. Sure, I would do that. One of the "ecology" things that to my mind is going too far is when people don't flush the toilet after each use, and I draw the line at washing off and eating food that has been dropped on the floor. That sort of thing turns my stomach, but hey, people do it. I once saw my stepmother pulled a crust of bread out of the garbage (which had dog poop in it by the way) exclaiming "We don't waste food!" Good thing Pop married her after I had already flown the coop. I could not eat in that house!
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
17 Aug 09
SORRY everyone, that was the wrong link. Here is the correct link for my milk carton planter photo: http://www.drann.us/anns_aerogarden_updates/2009/07/a-new-use-for-milk-jugs.html
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I use water bottles frozen as ice paks in lunch bags or ice chests. I buy a case of the bottle and reuse the bottles, rinsing after each use, and refill with tap water. I'd put a frozen one out in my rabbits hutch for them to lay by to stay cool in the hot summer. I've even taken frozen bottle of water and put them in a large gallon jug of koolaid or tea to keep it cold without the ice melting and diluting it. I use them for about a month then trash them as rinsing can only clean so much...bacteria can build up. With that small a opening spout, I don't see how putting them in the dishwasher will wash them... not much water will get into that little spout opening and still spray up into the whole bottle.
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
18 Aug 09
hi coffeebreal I really think those people are taking it a bit far, milk cartons for sandwiches no way. Paper sacks called brown bagging it can hold plastic boxes with lids made to take heat upable food and sandwiches also. no milk cartons take you very much
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I'm a recycle person too, but me neither will do this! It just isn't practical I don't think. IT isn't air tight and things will dry out or fall apart and have to be reassembled.... yeah... just to over board on this one!
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hi Hatley, I saw one of your discussions yesterday I still need to respond to it. I agree with you but said to coffeebreak I think they are trying just to get a message across and try to inspire people to be creative. Now I need to go and find your discussion I saw yesterday.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
21 Aug 09
I don't think it is going overboard, I think it is creative and resourceful. It also helps children to think twice and maybe three times before throwing anything away.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
27 Aug 09
But the thing is... this container will eventually be thrown away so it still lands in the land fills. If you were to buy a decent Rubbermaid or similar plastic container with an air tight lid, not only will it last a much longer time but being air tight, it will hold food better and safer. I just don't see where the recycle advantage is.
@k1tten (2315)
• United States
18 Aug 09
Those have actually been around for quite a while. I know that I wouldn't want any but it's interesting to see how they've taken containers and turned them into lunch boxes, pencil cases, even purses! I'm sure though cleaning those containers would be easy and easy to disinfect if you did it right.
• United States
18 Aug 09
I get the Family Fun magazine and I actually thought those are really cool. Only thing is I never even have those types of containers nor really the need for them since I do not ever pack lunches.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
That is my favorite magazine. SO many things in there for kids and family!!!
• United States
17 Aug 09
I would consider it, I would try it once in an effort to save the environment but if I didn't like it I would stop. There is definitely is a point where it can reach obsession and I don't think that is necessary. And as a side note, I am always picking up pennies, I'm glad I am not the only one
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I woudl be concerned about the freshness of the food in this container. And since it is going to be tossed after a few times of use anyway... what difference does it make WHEN it is tossed...and in how many pieces. More economical to buy a Rubbermaid and have it for a few years!
@MissAmie (717)
• United States
18 Aug 09
When I first read the description of the sandwich and snack containers I thought it might be taking reusing things a bit far too, but after looking at them, they really look great! I was shocked. I doubt very seriously if I could get a cut up milk jug to look that good, but if i could that would be really cool.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
That'd be the hard part. They have to be cut exactly properly or it won't fit closed right. And since it will eventually be tossed.. what difference does it make when... just buy a few Rubbermaid airtight lid containers and have them for years. But one person mentioned they'd be good for things like crayons, pencils and other kid craft things.. that'd be a good use for them
• Philippines
17 Aug 09
well, my mom actually recycles some stuff, and so as me. sometimes some i turn bottled waters, specially hard ones into my own personal refillable bottled water. and my mom would convert some of the coke plastic bottles into a plant pot, most specially if it's a large distilled water containers. It's quite good because she doesn't need to buy pots when she can recycle one.and we still have plenty more of it. Have great day
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I do that with the water bottles to. I buy a case and take 6 at a time and refill them quite a few times and then toss them, strickly for sanitary reasons. You can't actually "wash" them, just rinse, but after so many times... it just sems to be to be better sanitary wise to eventually toss them. I'd say about a month for 6 bottles is what I do. I have also filled and frozen them for large ice packs in lunch bags or ice chests. That works really great!