Family/Sibling Rivalry or a falling out?

@bmuchler (441)
United States
August 17, 2009 9:01pm CST
I have an older sister and a younger brother. I love my sister dearly and call her a couple of times a week and send her e-mails. She doesn't live too far from me. My brother on the other hand, well I'm just not sure what to say. My brother and I were close at one time. Things fell apart when he got involved with his current girlfriend. They have been together for a few years and have a daughter. Things becasem worse after my father passed away a year and a half ago. He does not speak to anyone in our family. Cousins, Aunts, Uncles, nobody. Not since the funeral. I have tried and tried to make contact with him. I have sent holiday cards and pictures of my kids. All have been returned marked refused. Before my husband and I were married my brother lived with us for awhile when he was getting divorced and after the divorce. I think it was about 6 months. We didn't take any money from him, like food or rent, or for utilities. He lived with free of charge to get our love and support and to help him get on his feet again. He does not allow my mom to see his daughter. To be honest only a few of us, including mom only saw the baby once or twice when she wa first born. After all this and not speaking to anyone for over a year. He came to mom and asked her to cosign a loan for him. Um Hello! Obviously she said no. My sister and I knew the day that he was going to talk to mom. So we went to her house. We were surprised he showed up. I confronted him on a lot of issues. Not to make any excusses, but he seemed very controlled. Empty eyes, no emotion. Am I wrong to keep trying to get in touch with him? Is it possible that someone can be that controlled by their partner/spouse/boyfriend/girlfriend? Has anyone had any experiences like this? How did you handle it?
2 responses
@eLsMarie (4477)
• New Zealand
19 Aug 09
i don't have any problems with my family but i can surely help with this kind of situation.. bmuchler, your intention is very good however you're teaching your brother to become more numb because you're trying everything in order to bring him back. it's plain too obvious that he's already abusing your goodness. whatever changes that your brother has been showing to all of you now, his wife/girlfriend is the one who influenced him to become like that. leave him alone, i'm sure he'll woke up one day and find himself regretful for letting himself be controlled negatively by her girlfriend...
@bmuchler (441)
• United States
19 Aug 09
I must be a glutten for rejection. I sent him a birthday card and it was returned. The envelope was marked refused, return to sender. The writing was his girlfriends. I know her writing because she is my ex best friend from many years ago. I wonder if he even knows I sent him one.
@mrbranan (1012)
• United States
18 Aug 09
I have never been that controlled nor do I know anyone who has. How can anyone allow them selves to be that controlled. I have a son and would hope that this would never happen. I can't see my child only wanting to talk to me when he needs something. My mother and I live in the same town and although we don't live in the same house we have coffee together every morning. When she gets up she calls me and while I work we talk and drink coffee. I would never be with someone who didn't want me to talk to my family. I have heard it said when you marry someone you don't marry their family but you do because their family is part of their lives just as you are.