Disagreements -- good or bad?

United States
September 24, 2009 9:20pm CST
Hello all. While it is human nature to disagree with those we know from time to time, do you think disagreeing with loved ones a lot is a good thing or a bad? In your experience, what seems to cause more disagreements than any other thing? Thank you for your input. Karen
6 people like this
21 responses
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
29 Sep 09
Disagreements are an inevitable reality of life and have nothing to do with the relationship to another person with whom we disagree. We are, each of us, uniquely individual in our thoughts, hopes, dreams, feelings, needs, desires, etc. No two people are ever going to agree on every single thing which is why maturity dictates we learn to agree to disagree.
1 person likes this
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
29 Sep 09
Remember my mentionting "maturity"? Although I get the feeling you were referring to something specifif and possibly recent...
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Oct 09
...not recently, but rather something I've learned with time!
• United States
29 Sep 09
Hi Canellita. Disagreements ARE inevitable; vicious arguments and disrespect are not. And that is when a disagreement goes from being a form of communicating our uniqueness, which is positive, to something that is not at all positive. Thank you for stating your opinion, and have a nice day. Karen
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
26 Sep 09
Hello my friend In my experience if you are someone that has a mind of your own you will disagree with alot of people, I have this problem alot, even when I was younger, my mom is from the old school and tries to have us do things that worked for her years ago,I try to tell her times have changed people don't do these things anymore so we disagree all the time lol, she said I talk too much but thats o.k I have my own mind so say what you will but if I don't agree trust and believe I will let you know, Thank you my friend.
1 person likes this
• United States
29 Sep 09
Hm, actually, I think you'd be a wonderful poet! I love writing it...helps me figure things out or think aloud in a short format, which forces me to "narrow" things down to a less overwhelming point :D hugs, karen
• United States
26 Sep 09
Ah yes, the age-old rivalry between parent and child? Yup, people with a mind of their own and the courage to allow it to "speak" are often apt to feel free to disagree. LOL, I made a rhyme! Thank you for the input, Kitty. Hope you're having a good weekend! xoxo Karen
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
26 Sep 09
Hello my friend This is true you are so funny, I tend to sound like a poet late at night I say wow, I am a poet and I didn't know it Thanks my friend, too funny
1 person likes this
@Ithink (9980)
• United States
26 Sep 09
Well I think in a way it is human nature and that some disagreements can even be beneficial for relationships. However to much leads to anger, fighting ect., and that isnt good. I do think that the longer you are with someone and the better that you get to know them the less you tend to argue or disagree. I think some of the most agreements are over money. We used to argue all the time about money and bills. Then It got to where I realized we are doing all that we can to pay them and my hubby works hard, so as long as I do my best that is all I can do.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Sep 09
Hello to you. Yes, it is in our nature as human beings to see things differently and disagree at times. When done so with respect for one another, that can lead to positive things. When done with a mean spirit or on a daily basis? That leads to destruction. Money...ugh! It is the source of many arguments, from what I've read and experienced. Thank you for expressing your point of view. Karen
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
25 Sep 09
I think disagreeing w/family can cause alot of problems but i think the truth needs to come out when it needs to. I don't think hiding problems under the rug to keep someone from getting upset is thew solution to the problem.There are times when something needs to be said.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
You're a very wise woman, my friend. Yes, hiding a thing under the rug only makes for a constant thing to trip one up. Some things DO need to be said, even if they cause a row. Other smaller matters...those can just be let go. Balance is good! Thank you for the input, Jo. Karen
• United States
25 Sep 09
My mother always said that disagreements are a healthy sign of any kind of relationship! I truly believe her! We all can't have a one track mind! Life would be dull! Have a nice day PeacefulWmn and a nice weekend!
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Good evening :) I believe, as your mom said, that disagreements held respectfully truly are a healthy thing in a relationship. And you are right...no two of us think exactly alike and are bound at times to disagree. I believe respect is key to any relationship, even when two people disagree...or when a whole group is not of the same mind. Thank you for responding, and have a nice weekend. Karen
@tvb2009 (237)
• Singapore
25 Sep 09
Disagreements are common. That's because nobody will generate the exact same idea as you at one point of time. Thus, disagreement comes by. However, it is good for generating a win-win solution because ideas are discussed and improved. Just try not to make disagreements into quarrels.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Tvb. Yes, disagreements are very common and as you say, no two people will be thinking or feeling exactly alike at any given time. I also agree that it's good to keep our mutual opinions in a win/win condition. Too often, an argument escalates into a nasty dispute and all involved are bound to lose and bitterness results. Nothing is resolved. Thank you for your insights...very helpful! Karen
@tvb2009 (237)
• Singapore
25 Sep 09
You are very welcome... All the best to you.
1 person likes this
@hotsummer (13835)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
disagreement has never been good thing. it cause friction and of course lots and lots of fight actually. it has not done me at all. not one thing.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Summer. I think that "fighting" in a nasty disrespectful way serves only to hurt another. When we disagree with someone and feel the need to discuss it, when we are willing to see the other's point of view with courtesy and respect, then a disagreement can further understanding and be a healthy thing. I'm sorry that your experiences have been negative where this is concerned. Do have a nice weekend and thank you for responding here. Karen
@calyxus (825)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
I believe disagreements are healthy for those who takes it as constructive as it can be. However, for those who can't take it positively, it's more likely to be a pain in the neck. So, before you disagree on something to someone, weigh it first if the person is up for it or not. You might save both of you from unpleasant situations. Up for it, calyxus
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi Calyxus. I also think that respectful discussion of disagreements can be a healthy and constructive way to address issues and reach satisfactory conclusions for all parties concerned. Yes, we really benefit by trying to weigh all sides and see things from the perspective of the other person before discussing a matter. Thank you for you wise ideas on this topic. Karen
@dmrone (746)
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi! I think to much disagreeing is a bad thing. In my family the one thing that causes the most disagreements are my siblings thinking i need to pick sides between our parents. Our parents got a divorce 22 years ago, and to this day i have not nor will i choose a side. It has caused some really big disagreements between us, but in the end sometimes it works out and we go on. Sometimes it doesn't work out that way, but i never worry to much about it.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi Dmrone. You're right, too much disagreeing indicates that a relationship is in trouble and not a healthy place to be. Most children do not wish to choose sides in their parents disputes...nor should they be expected to, whether small or full grown. I am glad that in the end, most things have worked out for you. Have a happy day. Karen
@Tantrums (945)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
Most disagreements are caused by misunderstandings. That is, you disagree with someone not because you have a different opinion, but because you misunderstand the opinion of your friend. The first thing to keep in mind is that misunderstandings are unavoidable. The bad news is misunderstandings can become quarrels. The good news is that with awareness, you can change misunderstandings to understanding and acceptance, which will deepen your friendships. Why is misunderstanding inevitable? Well, it's got to do with the nature of casual communication. Let's say I'm among a circle of friends and wish to share an idea, and it's my turn to speak. The idea is completely clear in my mind, but to explain it in great detail is somewhat laborious. Besides, if my explanation is too long-winded, I'm apt to be cut off by a friend who is eager to jump into the discussion. So, to make my task less laborious and reduce the likelihood of being cut off in mid-sentence, what do I do? I abbreviate, shorten, and clip my ideas to get them out faster and easier. However, by reducing the details of my point, I unwittingly introduce vagueness and ambiguity. This lack of clarity leads to confusion and misunderstanding.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi there :) Yes, misunderstandings do lead to many disagreements, and we each like to have our point acknowledged with respect. Like you, I think sticking to the main point can shorten many disagreements, as can being clear on exactly what it is we're trying to say. Thank you for sharing your insights, which make a great deal of sense. Karen
@artistry (4152)
• United States
25 Sep 09
.....Hi PeacefulWmn9, Your name is great, disagreements between relatives happen in all different circumstances. Husbands and wives have disagreements over things related to the marriage, the house the children if there are any. Relatives disagree over parents or living arrangements or money if one wants to borrow from the other. Friends could disagree over something as simple as where each of them want to go to eat. But as people have said in the past, you probably should not start a conversation about religion or politics unless you want to release the most strident responses that some people can muster. It is great when people are able to respect the fact that other people can have a different opinion than they do and the world will not end. :o) Take it easy.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Thank you :) For sure, almost anything can be a source of disagreement, including the things you've mentioned. And right again...I've also heard the advice never to discuss religion or politics if you wish to avoid a conflict! People have very adament personal views about both. Nope, the world does not end just because we disagree about things. You're very wise :) Thank you for sharing your views and have a beautiful weekend. Karen
@riyasbass (118)
• India
25 Sep 09
According to me disagreement is the key to express our views..it is a unique ability of humans....But disagreeing too much to our best friends ,shows that you are a failure in choosing the correct friend rather than its bad...The agreement or unity itself is the major symbol of friendship and understanding......................
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Riyabass. True, disagreements by themselves are nothing bad....unless they become routine and heated and serve no good purpose. I do not like it when some people off-handedly and immediately disagree with everything another says or thinks. It is as though they thrive on contention, and that is a thing to steer away from! Thank you for your input. You make a lot of sense. Karen
@erbyjen (15)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
I think disagreements in the family is normal and it has a good and bad effect. It's good when the communication between the members are good and they can accept their mistakes and learn from them. It's bad when no one wants or no one is humble enough to accept the mistake. One of the common disagreements I have encountered is budgeting family's money. I hope this helps.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi Erbyjen. You're right, disagreements are totally normal, and depending, can be either good or bad. I've learned to steer clear of the destructive ones and only participate when a solution or better understanding is the end goal. And money, oh yeah, that one is very common. We each have some pretty strong ideas on how it should be used. Thank you for your input, and have a great day. Karen
• India
25 Sep 09
Nice question disagreement good or bad. But let me tell you that it depends upon los of things. Its depend upon the situation. Human disagree only if they are in a situation which doesn't allow them or force them to disagree. Suppose you want your one of the friend to help you for something but he has to go to pick up his/her parents from Airport. Such situation can cause disagreement whether you are loved one or not. In my experience disagreement is always neutral thing. Neither good nor bad. Anything which a person never wants to do or never wants to be happen cause them more disagreement. Moreover in this world 2 equal and opposite things always exist for example ghost and angel, evil and God, Hell and Heaven. Similarly agree and disagree.
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Cyber. You've given me a very new and interesting way to look at disagreements...and perhaps you're right. Perhaps they are neither good nor bad, but simple opposite and neutral. Thank you for the insight! Karen
@dpk262006 (58675)
• Delhi, India
25 Sep 09
Hi Karen! I think when our ‘ego’ clashes with the other fellow, be it our partner, colleague or a friend, our minds tells us to ‘disagree’ with the other fellow. I think before giving our verdict about disagreeing with an issue, we should think from all angles and we should ponder rationally to see what is in the overall interest of the ‘given situation’. Keeping aside our ‘ego’, we should agree with others and should not think that by agreeing, we have surrendered to the other fellow.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Deepak. It does make sense to look at the other person's viewpoint and factor in all angles of a matter with which we do not agree before addressing it. If it is a small thing of little consequence, and yes, if ego is left out of it, some things are better let go in the interest of maintaining peace. It is the biggest and most important things that I tend not to let go by the wayside. When addressed with the forethought you mentioned and from a humble and respectful heart, the disagreements can usally be peacefully resolved. And then sometimes, we just "agree to disagree." LOL Karen
@mensab (4200)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
there is a merit in having disagreements. in this way, one can learn and know more of the person/partner. a relationship is not always a cloud-nine feeling. there will be arguments and disagreements. these are able to show the values and thoughts of one's partner. after disagreeing, partners may feel closer because they are able to unload and settle their differences if the disagreements end in good terms. still, i like disagreements from time to time to challenge the familiarity and comfort of the relationship.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Mensab. You're right. We'll never agreee with a partner, friend, or anyone, for that matter, 100% of the time. Discussion over those things where we disagree doesn't have to turn into a hurtful battle. In that sense, I do not think any disagreement is a negative thing, but rather how it is addressed that can be good or bad. Like you, I do not enjoy disagreements, and not all of them are even worth mentioning to the other person, but only those things that matter the most. Thank you for sharing your opinions here, and have a nice day. Karen
@peace001 (726)
• China
25 Sep 09
hi,Karen.in my opinion that disagreeing with loved ones is a good things.everyone has a different views at the same thing.then we can share our opinions and discuss it if it is necessary.we will understand each other better.so why not share our ideas to the one you loved.have a good day!
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Peace. I also think that if we disagree in a respectful matter to bring about positive changes or express our personal preferences, it is a positive thing that does lead to understanding and a better relationship. It is when disagreements turn ugly and disrespectful or become a daily occurance that they lose that positive aspect. Thank you for voicing your opinion. Karen
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
25 Sep 09
it is never good to have disagreements but it is the one way you can exert your point if your decision is not honored. what causes it? i guess its pride. happy mylotting. ann
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello Ann. I know many of us aren't comfortable with disagreements, but sometimes it is necessary or healthy to speak out to someone with whom we disagree. This can be done, hopefully, with mutual respect. I'm not sure if it is pride that enters into most disagreements. Sometimes it is a matter of mere personal preferences, or involves standing up for one's rights. I hope you're enjoying your day. Karen
@jb78000 (15139)
25 Sep 09
i think on the whole it's a good thing. i've noticed that some people can be easily influenced and take up the views of people they are close to. disagreements tend to indicate that they are thinking for themselves. however it can go too far the other way... will come back when i actually have a proper opinion on this...[dense and arrogant british rabbit hops off]
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hello rabbit woman :) I agree (she said, tongue in cheek) that disagreements are not only inevitable, but a lot of good can actually come from them. It does indeed indicate that people are thinking for themselves and not merely willing to follow all the lemmings on over the cliff. The time they become unproductive is when they turn into a contest of wills or involve ye auld mud slinging and personality assassinations. I look forward to your return lol. Karen
@webearn99 (1742)
• India
25 Sep 09
As you say disagreement once in a while is normal. Disagreeing a lot may be a cry for help. The person who does that is trying to draw attention as he or she may be feeling lonely. A righteous approach to an issue can also trigger a disagreeing bout.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Sep 09
Hi Webearn. Non-stop arguments can surely be a cry for help, as when it becomes a constant thing between two people, it is not a healthy thing. Yes, some people who feel neglected do tend to be contentious on purpose to gain attention. Trouble with that is, the attention gained is seldom positive! Thank you for sharing your opinions and insights. Karen