If you were Bella, who would you choose, Edward or Jacob?

October 4, 2009 7:23am CST
You know, New Moon is to be shown on Nov.20th in America, so the question I ask is the hottest for fans around the world. In Twilight, Edward was charming, handsome and single-minded. For all girls, he was absolutly their Mr.Right. However, Jacob just impressed us as a friend who has remembered Bella since childhood. I guess not many girls had feeling for him. But now, in New Moon, Jacob cares Bella carefully after she broke her heart. He can do everything for Bella. This is also the most attracting thing for girls. If Edward is a prince, Jacob is a guardian. So which one do you prefer?
1 person likes this
5 responses
@dpauli (407)
• Indonesia
4 Oct 09
I would prefer Edward.. yeah.. go for Edward. Girls are always dreaming for prince charming, so when there is a chance that a prince charming loves you, so why would choose someone else?
4 Oct 09
sometimes you will feel unreal when a price like Edward loves you. If he leaves you, your hope means to be shattered, then you may feel more hurtful than a guy not like a price leaves you, I think.
@youless (111475)
• Guangzhou, China
26 Oct 09
I watched Twilight but I haven't watched New Moon yet. I even haven't read New Moon. The main actor in Twilight is just Edward. So I think I will choose Eward because I have no more idea about Jacob. Maybe I will change my mind after watching New Moon?:) In Twilight, Edward protects Bella, too. Such as the car accident, the gangs etc. It is safe to be with him. I love China
@lelin1123 (15595)
• Puerto Rico
5 Oct 09
I would have to pick Edward the prince. I didn't think I was going to like the movie but it was so good and yes Edward would be the one I pick with no reservations.
4 Oct 09
Definitely Edward. He's dreamy. I like guys who are chrming, mysterious, takes in-charge but still melts when he is with the girl he loves.
• United States
24 Oct 09
I'm stuck on that one. I like how Jacob is always there for Bella and he never leaves her even after she chooses Edward. But then I like the sense of prince charming in Edward. I think Edward is awesome in his own way and then so is Jacob. If I was forced to choose one, I think I would choose Jacob though.