Your take on the flu shots and other immunizations please...

United States
October 16, 2009 6:51pm CST
In the US, we are encouraged to get our infants their first immunizations when they are a few months old, and these continue until all the available ones have been received. They protect against polio, diptheria, mumps, chicken pox, whooping cough, tetanus, and many dangerous diseases. Now we are all encouraged to get the H1N1 flu immunization. Some parents/people, myself included, think these shots are a good thing, but others think the shots are too dangerous and would rather take their chances with diseases or the flu, including making those decisions for their children. Some have died of immunizations, in rare cases. My siblings and I were given the available shots when young, and so were my own children, and now my grandchildren. I think they save lives almost every time. The ones that for a rare reason get sick or die...well the diseases kill, too, and in far larger numbers, but that is my own opinion and decision. What about you? Do you feel immunizations are a good idea? Why or why not? Do you get them for yourself or your children? Thank you. Karen
3 people like this
11 responses
• United States
17 Oct 09
This is a difficult debate. In the short term, the immunizations may prevent some diseases (they are never 100% effective) which is good, obviously I do not want diseases. However, they decrease your bodies immunity overall and also prevent you from developing an immunity to the disease on your own that you can pass on to your children. Instead you pass on a weaker immune system. So in the long run we have to keep getting more and more immunizations as our immunity continues to decrease with each generation. I choose not to vaccinate personally. But that is a personal decision that I make for myself and I understand why someone would choose to vaccinate.
2 people like this
• India
30 Nov 09
Hello my friend PeacefulWmn9 Ji, I personnally feel, the topic has been given moe publicity.In my case, I was given basic things against Chicken/small-pox, cholera/ATT. I also think,more injection are given the Natural resiivity in any bodywill automatically reduce, as it will be taken over by that injection. People , as they become old will have mre problem. I also feel, for cold and cough,for first three days there should not be treament. Let body automatically fight out against nature and settle, instead we are makingependent of these injection. Then why at all body should resist. Take only basics, bare neessary. May God bless You and have a great time.
1 person likes this
• India
1 Dec 09
Hello my friend PeacefulWmn9 Ji, AS my hubby ha sbeen in service in Defence, he was vey regular in complete immunizaion programme as and when due. He kept me and our children up-dated. But in between, if required ATT injection used to be taken during injury. In your case, yiou have to act as per Dr's advise to have additionalresistivity against those illness to fight back. But,day is not long when interested parties like researchers, bussiness people would waste no time to convince to take different injection and we will get habituated with this. So take basics only. May God bless You and have a great time.
• United States
30 Nov 09
Hello to you, friend. I agree that basics and necessities are best. For me, I have asthma, so my dr. has recommended that a pnemonia shot each 8 years and the flu shot every year ARE basic, as I am at high risk of complications from those illnesses. Thank you for your insights :) Karen
1 person likes this
@biman_s (1060)
• India
17 Oct 09
I have got immunization shots when I was a kid. My parents also got it too. In our country small children are encouraged by doctors and also family members to get these shots as they really prevent bad disease from happening. These are very necessary and must be taken by everyone to avoid fatal diseases from affecting you.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Biman. Like my family, yours must have been fortunate not to have had some of the things go wrong mentioned above. I do feel, that over all, the vaccines are life savers. I hope you're having a great weekend and appreciate you responding here. Karen
• Boston, Massachusetts
17 Oct 09
Immunization is really a must especially among the babies. This is part of the advocacy on Maternal and Child Health program that's why in our country immunization/vaccination is encouraged to prevent diseases and ailments not only among the babies but all ages. My mom told me that i had a complete immunization when i was a kid. With the so many vaccine coming out now to prevent us from flu, AH1N1, Cervical Cancer and a lot more... i never had one. I don't know what it's not really appealing to me. I am so health conscious but more on my diet and exercise not so much on vaccines/immunizations and other medicines. For my sons, me and my husband decided not complete the immunization for them when we learned about a mercury content in the vaccine that has to do with autism. It was a study/theory but not yet proven but we still opted not to continue having a complete/full range of the vaccines. My 2 sons are both diagnosed with autism. The eldest had more vaccines received compared to my youngest son and my youngest is in the mildest spectrum of autism than my eldest son. The youngest was already in the mainstream program but the my eldest son is still the Special Education program. This maybe coincidence but we still consider the relation of vaccine to autism.
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Msfrancisco. The babies, yes, for few of them have bad reactions, but many die or get permanently disabled from preventable disease. I do feel for those who also get sick from the vaccinations, though. It surely is important to make a decision based on one's own experiences and best judgment. I am sorry to know of the autism suffered by your youngest children. I have heard of the studies, and science is never perfected. I can understand your concern, and yes, autism has grown at alarming rates, and there must be a reason. (sigh) It's too bad science was not a more exact art. My best of all wishes to you your beautiful family. Karen
• Boston, Massachusetts
18 Oct 09
thanks karen! autism is a developmental disorder and lots of studies are on line to really determine it's cause. so for now early intervention if perfect for kids with autism plus appropriate therapies.
1 person likes this
@jenlex79 (256)
• United States
17 Oct 09
Well, in my opinion, I don't agree with all vaccinations. Our bodies build up natural immunities to things, but if we get vaccines we can't build an immunity to it. I will never get the flu shot. My daughter's doctor asked if I wanted to get it for her and I turned it down. He told me that he agrees with my decision. I think flu shots do more harm than good. I know a lot of people who caught the flu several times after recieving the flu shot. Of course, this is my opinion though.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Jenlex. I agree to an extent, but this can be achieved through less use of anti-bacterial soaps, etc., good diet, and simpler things such as common colds, rather than risking "killer" or crippling diseases. But I do respect each person's right to choose and I thank you for expressing your opinion here. (I know other parents who feel as you do.) Best wishes, Karen
@ptty55 (45)
• Canada
18 Oct 09
I am afraid to allow my kids to take the H1N1 shot. It seems to be rushed onto the market, without properly testing it for side effects. I am a little concerned that is just a government placebo, to keep the masses less excitable if this flu reaches epidemic proportions. I doubt that this vaccine will prevent anyone from contracting this new flu strain. It is mutating at a rapid pace, and unless the vaccine maker keeps up with the mutations, the vaccine will be useless.
1 person likes this
@ptty55 (45)
• Canada
21 Oct 09
Hi PeacefulWmn...my concern comes when I read about the rapid mutations of H1N1. No single vaccine can address an on-going mutating virus. At this moment, in Canada, we have a Turkey farm in quarantine. They have determined that the turkeys are infected with H1N1, transmitted by a farmworker. Human to bird transmission poses a new possibility of mutation, apart from human to human. I am in shock, but there is no culling of the flock being planned by our Government. If even one of those infected birds escapes, or interacts with another animal or bird...well, you see where my concerns are going. The vaccine is a placebo. I would never tell anyone else not to take the vaccine, I just feel that the possible complications from an unvetted new vaccine, are scarier than the disease it may, or may not prevent. I just wish there was more information available to the general public. We know only what our governments and WHO allow us to know. I find it curious that most vaccines, upon their discovery, took years of testing before being given to the public. I am not suspicious by nature, but when the need for a quick vaccine appears, and then suddenly in under a year, there is a vaccine available, my radar goes up. Have a great day and thanks for your response.
1 person likes this
@manong05 (5027)
• Philippines
17 Oct 09
I am for immunization. Our recorded history is full of stories of pandemics that nearly decimated populations. Spanish influenza, cholera, bubonic plaques and a lot more. Scientists have developed vaccines and were succesful in putting this dreaded diseases under control. They may not have completely eradicated them as new strains are coming out since they mutate. However, the effects will be unimaginable had it not been for the discovery of these vaccines. It we are against them because of incidents of failure or side effects in some individuals we are exposing ourselves to a much greater danger and risk. enjoy life!
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Manong. This is also my line of thinking. The vaccines do a whole lot more good than harm, whereas the diseases they prevent were devastating and deadly to many! Science is good when it discovers ways to cure or eliminate disease. Thank you for your viewpoint. Karen
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
17 Oct 09
MY sons had all the immunization shots & i'm sure i did to way back when.my grandson has had them to. Last year was the first time i had ever taken the flu shot. When i was working all the time i just never took the time to go get one. I haven't had one this year but am sure i need to go get one. I have one friend that would not take one for anything because when her mother took it , it made her sick. I guess u just have to make up your own mind whether u do or u don't.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Jo...hope you're well today :) Yes, it is an individual choice, and those who do not get vaccines have their reasons. My family and I are fortunate that we've had no problems related to them, as they DO save many lives. Take care! Karen
@dlr297 (5409)
• United States
17 Oct 09
I do not think that all immunizations are good and i do not feel that they are all necessary. and if they harm one person they are not good. and people should not be made to get them if they do not wish to get them. Why should the Government decide what is good for us, when we are adults we should be able to make our own decisions for ourselves and for our own children. I feel that my immune system is in good working condition, and if i come into contact with a germ, or virus i will be able to fight it off naturally. Look at all the prescription medicines that are approved. that are killing hundreds of thousands of people. or causing a number of other problems. but they still tell you that they are safe. It is not that rare that immunizations make people sick, or even kill them. It happens all the time.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Dlr. Yes, a fine-tuned immune system is crucial to health and well-being. I think children are vulnerable to many things since their systems are not yet fully developed. It makes them a "target," so to speak. Some have had unfortunate tradgedies relating to vaccines, and many more related to the diseases that vaccines prevent. It's a fine line trying to decide which way to go, since we're all unique and science is fallible. Hopefully, one day it will be more clear cut. Best wishes to you. Karen
@agv0419 (3022)
• Philippines
17 Oct 09
Yes immunization is important I'm envy your country because all vaccination are given free children and adult. Unlike here in our country vaccinations is not all for free. It is important to prevent diseases and avoid the outbreak of an illness.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hi Agv. Not all are free here, either...only for those whose income is very low, but thank God for that, as they need the help! The H1N1 vaccine WILL, however, be free to all Americans. You take care and have a lovely "rest of the weekend." Karen
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
17 Oct 09
dear karen, for children, it is their line of defense from diseases so i am sure that it is wise to have immunization administered on our children. thank you for this post. cheers. ann
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 09
Hello Ann. I have always felt the same way. My family has always opted for the immunizations with no ill effects. My heart goes out to the few who've been less fortunate, though. But, yes, we get our shots, and they save many lives. Karen