What's The Best Way To Tell A Person...

@rg0205 (2636)
Hong Kong
November 18, 2009 3:10am CST
I was having this discussion with some friends earlier regarding someone we know. It went like this: Kay: Cris smells bad. She needs deodorant. Libby: And soap. Me: Well, if it bothered you that much, why not find a way to tell her? Kay: How? How do you tell a person she smells bad? Libby: That's easy. Just say: "You stink" Then we all started laughing. Long story short, we're still wondering. I thought that the best way would be to bring Cris aside and have a conversation about it but then, of course, there is a risk of offending her. So, how would you tell a person that he/she smells bad?
4 people like this
9 responses
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
18 Nov 09
I once knew a lady that smelled pretty bad. Actually I worked with her. It was hard to be around her and I felt embarrassed for her. For Christmas, I got her a gift basket of different soaps and bath things. It helped for a while but then she slid back into her old ways. I'm not sure that telling someone that they smell will do anything other than possibly offend them. People that do not bathe regularly or use deoderant must know that odds are they are smelly. They just don't seem to care about personal hygene.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
You're right. I feel the same way. Somehow I think you can't tell a person without offending him/her and if they aren't keen on personal hygiene to begin with, it's pointless. What's worse is, sometimes she seems to use perfume without bathing so it makes it a tenfold worse.
1 person likes this
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
Exactly! See, I only met the girl like probably, say, 5 times. Still, it's pretty easy to tell that she's not a very clean person because she had oily hair with dandruff and she smelled. Part from that, her clothes didn't look very clean, too. The smell was part body odor and part perfume. The mix smells really awful and I think it adds to the smell of the body odor. Kay has migraines and one of her triggers is bad smells so I feel sorry for her. She works with the lady and their cubicles in the office are right next to eachother.
• Philippines
19 Nov 09
Hello rg. This happened to one of my friends before. We weren't that close but because of this issue, her group of friends has to do something about it. The group decided to drop a small note in her locker where she read the message. That was a bit humiliating and my friend even cried. I don't know why... But it did solve the problem though. We cannot really avoid hurting someone with this matter since it really is hurtful. Just try to put yourself in her shoes. If you smelled bad or your feet smelled, what or how would you want it to be told by your friends? Then do it. Just notify us if what did you do with it.
• Philippines
20 Nov 09
Thanks for the BR. I never thought my message could help you. Thanks again and i hope you could tell your friend the problem. She'll realize that she has a friend in you and will increase her trust in you.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
Thanks. What a great way of putting it.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (85541)
• United States
18 Nov 09
I've come across this situation before, in high school. My friend had terrible BO. So I mentioned that I smelled something bad. She said she didn't smell it. So I said, I wonder if it is me, and I sniffed my shirt. She did the same thing, and then smelled herself close to her armpit. I saw her expression when she realized it was her. Then I said it must have been my imagination. She agreed with me and I never let on that I knew it was her. The next day and the days after she wore deodorant. We could all tell the difference.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
That's an interesting way of getting through to someone. :-) Thanks
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (85541)
• United States
19 Nov 09
I wanted her to figure it out before somebody rude finally just told her to her face she stunk (which if someone doesn't get the hint, might be the only way to get the message across). This way I let her save face.
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
18 Nov 09
Hi rg, you've got me on this one as I really don't have a clue. I do have a good friend who appears not to have heard of deodrant and one can put the manly sweat smell down to working hard on the boats in the summer, but it does continue into other parts of the year too. I just put up with it as do know he showers and can stand downwind and don't want to hurt his feelings.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
18 Nov 09
Hi Thea! Cris and Kay work together. It's cold here so wearing sweaters and having that distinct armpit smell doesn't go well. I don't think I'm in any position to be the one to tell the girl because we're nto that close. Kay probably has a better chance than I do. Still, I don't think there's a way to mention it without offending her though. Kay gets migraines when she smells something that doesn't quite tickle her fancy so she's sort of tap dancing around telling and not telling.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
18 Nov 09
*not
@happy6162 (3001)
• United States
19 Nov 09
It is hard to tell someone that they stink without hurting their feelings. Maybe you and a few other friends could have some gift giving party and invite this person. Then you could give her some deodorant and someone else could give her some bath soap hopeful this might help. If it does not then you might have to just tell her that she smell bad and should use the gifts that all of you gave her.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
Good suggestion thanks. Well, it all depends on whether or not she'll actually use it because she doesn't seem to bathe everyday.
@giegrace (213)
• Philippines
18 Nov 09
This is one topic that's so difficult to address. But as they say, the truth hurts. Perhaps you can make that person aware through jokes. So it wouldn't hurt that much.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
18 Nov 09
Hmm, personally, I don't feel like I am in the position to tell her because we're not that close. Joking about it may also backfire. Thanks for your comment.
@giegrace (213)
• Philippines
20 Nov 09
Well, if you're not that close to her, then joking about it would only make it worse. Perhaps, it'll be better if you'll be u front with her. The truth hurts.
@viperuz2 (68)
• Philippines
18 Nov 09
if you are a true friend, you would tell him directly even if it will offend him. that's the truth! dont let others tell it to his face. Probably say: "Hey cris, this sounds off but im your friend, i dont want others discover what you have neither laughed at you. What brand of deodorant are you using? You might want to change it." On the other hand, if that person is not your friend, just ask.."What brand of deodorant are you using? Can u try this brand?"
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
18 Nov 09
Thanks for the comment.
• United States
19 Nov 09
I don't think there's an easy way to tell someone that without then getting offended. I think your best bet is to write it on paper and find a way for her to read it without knowing who wrote it. I know, it sounds like such a coward way of doing it, but at least she'll know.. but on the other side, she might get hurt and paranoid at who wrote it.. so even though you won't be hurting her, she'll be hurt more. So, I guess maybe you should just pull her aside and tell her; you can tell her you overheard someone saying she smelled bad, and then trying to find a way to get your opinion in, kind of like "well.. I kind of agree with what they said."
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
19 Nov 09
Thanks. I'll bring this up as a suggestion. Maybe writing would help.
@tony4u (47)
• Nigeria
18 Nov 09
my dear wisdom is profitable to direct,if i were you,i will buy those things that will make her smells good to all,,, and give it to the person this is an indirect way of letting her know what she need in life that she knows not she will love you more, than telling her or another person.