Are Electric Cars going to be worth it?

India
November 26, 2009 6:33am CST
I just want to know what people are thinking about the new completely electric cars that are starting to come out. Personally I don't think they are all that practical, sure in places like India or anywhere with a warm climate i suppose, but what about cold climate locations. Having an electric heater would suck up all the battery life. Well.. what happens when everyone plugs their cars in at night? Now there is huge demand on our power stations which many still run on coal. how is that any better? Personally i rather see dirty cars getting pulled off the road and replaced with normal cleaner cars, and getting coal burning plants shut down. The electric cars wont replace people's cars if they are big highway drivers, it's going to be a replacement for people who drive short distances in the cities and probably use small efficient cars anyways! To me this is all media making it sound like it's some great thing but in actuallity it's not all that practical and wont even put a dent into our total emissions. What do you think my friend on this subject.
1 person likes this
2 responses
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
26 Nov 09
I'm thinking the same. If we all convert to electricity, what happens when we plug it all the same time? Then there'd be shortage of electricity and they'd need to produce more by burning something up to produce more electricity. In the long-run, we'd still be exhausting some sort of natural resources, right? I'm thinking of something that's really not that exhaustible. Like solar energy. Perhaps it'll be good if those who'd have electric cars, would have solar panels at home which would store up energy in some cells so that when night time comes, they can charge their electric cars from the cells instead of directly getting it from our electricity sources. What do you think?
1 person likes this
@pcunix (210)
• Middleboro, Massachusetts
14 Oct 15
A coal plant is definitely a bad thing, but it is a fixed source where emissions can (at least in theory) be trapped and dealt with. A few million cars spewing poisons is a very different problem. Further, a coal plant can (in theory, again) be replaced by solar, wind or nuclear. That's one replacement, not millions.