If you had a choice from Twilight Series who would you choose Edward or Jacob???

United States
December 3, 2009 12:32pm CST
If you were Bella in Twilight would you go with the mysterious pale Vampire, Edward or the dark skinned family friend werewolf, Jacob? It would be a hard choice between the two but I think I would have to go with Jacob. Even though he is short tempered, he is very protective of her and tries not to let anything happen to her. So, who would you go with if you had the choice?
2 people like this
8 responses
@youless (104666)
• Guangzhou, China
4 Dec 09
I will choose Edward. I choose him not because he is handsome. I think he treats Bella very well. He protects her and his family is so nice to Bella. He is a perfect boy. Jacob is not so ideal. He gives Bella more freedom and it is free will. Whereas sometimes when Bella is wrong, he still supports, such as the motorcycle issue. I don't think it is good. I need my love tell or even argue with me when I am wrong. I love China
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Dec 09
If I had a choice. I would totally go for Edward. Yes, what he did in New Moon was a little more harsh than what needed to happen. But he did out of love for Bella. As Edward has said before "Bella is his life" So to be without her for eternity would diffidently mess with the ole vampy mind. I mean come on he already lived a somewhat nonexistent life before he met Bella. Just think what he probably would have went through if something did happen to her. To have someone to love you that intensely, that deeply, well that makes even me speechless.
• Philippines
9 Dec 09
Actually I cried when I read this part in the book wherein Edward needs to go and leave Bella for her own sake.
@swn_chik (266)
• India
30 Jul 10
Well I'll go for Edward because I think he is perfect for Bella and they make a good match.
• United States
17 Feb 10
i would pick edward cullen. there's no doubt about it.
@maria1081 (1252)
• Philippines
18 Dec 09
Honestly speaking I would choose Jacob for his looks and friendship. But for the sacrifice for the sake of love I would choose Edward.
• China
5 Dec 09
definitely,I'll choose Edward.Edward and bella just can't be apart.besides robert pattinson is totally gorgeous?
@greysfreak (1385)
• United States
4 Dec 09
I would definitely go with Edward, because I see Jacob as the protective, sweet best friend type. I see Edward as the protective, passionate one, and I think in the end the passionate part is what gets a lot of people. Jacob is the safer choice, in some ways, except for his temper, but most the time the safer choice is not what people are drawn to, they like a challenge and just connect to people differently. I tend to be a lot like Bella in the way I think about the things that happen, so I guess that's why I'd have to say I would choose Edward, but Jacob would be the best friend that you love like a brother, and maybe even have a time when you think you should go with them because they are safe, they are so sweet, but in the end it is just not the same feelings.
@maezee (41737)
• United States
3 Dec 09
I'm not really a fan of Twilight (which I should point out) but from all I've heard about Jacob's character...I would say him. I think Edward is a little over-rated to be honest with you! And the "love at first sight" thing is a little over-rated, too, and unrealistic for that matter. Plus Jacob's way cuter!