vasectomy: yes or no?

Philippines
January 10, 2010 2:38am CST
My friend is about to give birth to her fourth child. Her told her they should stop with the fourth child. The wife agreed but to her surprise her husband said he would undergo vasectomy. She was surprise to hear this because most men would rather suggest to their wives to do ligation instead or other means of birth control but rare contemplated of vasectomy. Vasectomy can never be reverse when it is done. The man's tube which releases seminal fluid responsible for creating new life will be forever closed. So,what is your opinion about this guys? Are you ok with the thought of cutting that tube? How about you, gals, would you recommend this to your partner? Thank you in advance.:-)
12 responses
@angelsmummy (1696)
10 Jan 10
My partner had it done not long ago and he said it was fine, he was swollen and bruised for a few days but that was it. A vasectomy can be reveresed by the way thought I would let you know that.
1 person likes this
11 Jan 10
They just fuse the tubes back together. It doesnt mean it will work but theres a good chance of it working.
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
Thannk you,Angelsmummy for sharing your husband's experience regarding this topic.:-) I admire your husband for doing that. If it can be reversed, then, my friend's Ob was wrong. Can you share with us how this operation can be reverse? Thanks again.:-)
• Boston, Massachusetts
10 Jan 10
Hi Eureka, I admire her husband for this decision. he loves her wife so much to submit himself for a vasectomy. i worked in an organization that advocates for reproductive health and family planning. vasectomy is easier than bilateral tubal ligation. it can be done even in a non-sterile room. it is a simple procedure where the vas deferens is cut and tied. there is a specialized instrument to be used to do the said procedure. it's now called no scalpel vasectomy or NSV. after the procedure the man can go home. he only needs a band aid for the small wound. the procedure lasts for only 10 to 15 minutes.
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
Thank you , Msfrancisco for that very detailed information. :-) Since I have no idea how this operation is done , also the ligation thing, and you seem an authority to this kind of stuff then, I must tell my friend to let her husband do it if he really do have decided about it. Our friend, Angelsmom here commented that vascomy can be reversed, is it true? Thank you again and have a great day.:-)
• Boston, Massachusetts
11 Jan 10
yes it can be reversed. it will be a tedious one--a micro surgery. there's no guarantee if it will still work after the said procedure. vasectomy is considered a permanent method. so, if you decide to have it, then that's it!
@lindiebiz (1006)
• Canada
10 Jan 10
Hi, your friends husband really has guts. I would not advice him to do that but he may need to have kids in the future, I am not saying anything bad would happen to him and I hope not but no one knows tommorrow. There are a lot of birth control options and your friend can look into them that is good for her
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
Hi, Lindibiez.:-) Nice to see you here again. Thanks.:-) They already have four kids and for a family of six and earning just enogh (for now) it is quite a big number already. The husband wants to be sure there'll be no more babies coming their way again. Unless, they get separated and finds a new wife, then it is going to be a problem, indeed, if he let his tube cut. Yup there are also other alternatives but they are not 100% safe .
@honey023 (57)
• Philippines
10 Jan 10
Hi eurekafemme, for my own opinion, why not if they will agree of cutting the tube then why not do it. Since they have decided to stop bearing a child then I suggested to do the operation.
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
I agree with you, Honey.:) If it is no big deal in the part of the husband to be cut, then, why not? Only, it is quite a little absurd since most mean think that being unable to propagate again is a big lose to their manhood. If ever, this husband will push through with this operation, then, I say, I do admire him for that.:-)
@izak1399 (103)
• New Zealand
10 Jan 10
It makes me want to cross my legs so no scissors weedle their way in there. I would be uncomfortable with that. The same goes for the gal piece. I don't know what we would do instead. Anything but cutting us up anyways. Ha ha.
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
Hi, Izak. Thank you being the first one to comment in this discussion.:-) Truly no one wants to have any operation under a normal circumstances. But, I guess the couple wants to have a permanent solution to child birth control since pills and other means are not 100% sure. Ligation can be done right after the baby is born, in case of the wife. But, I'm not sure if the husband will soon to be ready to cut his tube.LOL
• United States
10 Jan 10
i agree with it. i think its very fair because women go through 9 months of carrying the child then we give birth. why should we have to sacrifice our bodies once again? hopefully my husband will agree with a vasectomy because lol.
@agv0419 (3022)
• Philippines
11 Jan 10
I don't know why other men here in the Philippines don't want this procedure even if it the operation is less than an hour. The recovery is very fast compare to tubal ligation for women. Vasectomy is only a minor injury and men should inform about these if they are really want control the no. of there children.
@cokyjazz (429)
• Australia
10 Jan 10
My husband had one after i had our third child.We had decided long before that that 3 was the maximum.His little operation took maybe an hour with a local injection and he walked out of there and drove home.If i had my tubes done,i would have been fully sedated,opened up and had a longer recovery.To me,having 3 children was hard enough on my body so why should i put it through more.There are different ways of getting it done and some ways can be reversed but we opted for the cut,where a piece was removed so it can't join back..no chance of any more pregnancies!
@dpk262006 (58675)
• Delhi, India
11 Jan 10
Hi eureka! It is a difficult question to answer. I think if your friend's husband wants to go for vasectomy, there is nothing wrong in it, even if it is irreversible. I think it is between a couple to decide who wants to go for permanent birth control method. I can understand your point that many would prefer that their wife should go for Tubectomy operation. What is your opinion on this issue? Deepak
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
8 Feb 10
i told it once to my wife, that after giving birth to our third child, i would go for vasectomy. but even my wife doesn't want to do it, she rather go for ligation and now she is. we both know that vasectomy has some sort of disadvantages. one for sure, the strength of a man will never be the same after operation. i also know one friend of mine, who had regrets after her husband undergone vasectomy operation. he was a carpenter and as we all know, it is something that needs more strength. but now, he can only do lighter works. my friend had said that husband does not even have enough force to fetch a pail of water. so, i will not go force vasectomy. i work for my family and i only work for them. how will my family be if i cannot work well.
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
10 Jan 10
A vasectomy is easier for men to recover from than a woman, plus it is less expensive. Here it is done in the doctors office so no need for the expense of a hospital. I understand what you are saying, closing the tube means the end of giving life, but the husband and wife both agreed that they were done having children. Honestly, I think it is a smart choice because raising children isn't always easy. I have a large family myself (my choice) and had a huge garden to support them too. I think people have to look at the economics of the choices they make.
• United States
11 Jan 10
I think that is one of those things that is up to each couple to decide on their own... it was nice of him to volunteer for that though...a lot of guys wouldn't bother... if they already have all the kids they want then i'm all for them doing it...but if i was married and my husband had any doubts at all i wouldn't expect him to do anything to his body that he didn't want to...and i wouldn't do anything to mine that i wasn't comfortable with either.
• Philippines
10 Jan 10
i am on the positive side so it's a yes... well, when couples here in Philippines decided to stop having kids it is always the woman who must have the ligation. Isn't it a bit unfair for us ladies? Now I don't want to sound like a stereo typist here... But maybe it is the best decision of that guy to have vasectomy instead of the woman having ligation... Let us admit it, Guys are ego men. So if your husband say he would rather have vasectomy than you having ligation, THEN GIRL... how lucky can you get?