Is Ellen Degeneres a good judge on American Idol?

February 25, 2010 11:59am CST
Oh well, She has been on the programme for a few weeks, not sure but she is doing pretty well I think - Simon likes her very much and well everyone seems to like her and so do the audience as she has not received any bad press yet or anything like that - she is a bit quite though and a bit annoying at some points but so was Kara at the beginning and it took her some time to settle in. What do you think? Is she a good judge?
3 responses
@lisa0502 (1726)
• Canada
26 Feb 10
I would have to say that I am not a huge fan of Ellen. I am not quite sure why they even have her on this show. Yes granted she has not had any bad press and I am not sure that she ever will. But I just do not get why she is there. She is not really in the music buisness. I do not think that she really has much informative input to put forward.
@lelin1123 (15635)
• Puerto Rico
25 Feb 10
I may be bias because I love Ellen, but I think she is doing a better job then I thought she would.I don't understand how some people think she is ignoring. I think she is so funny and maybe it has to do with people and their lack of having a sense of humor. Some people find different things funny where others don't. She always makes me laugh that is why I love watching her talk show. I know I will have an hour with a smile on my face and belly laughing happening.
• United States
25 Feb 10
I think she is a good judge. She can also be pretty funny. I think a lot of people will like her on the show. Some people just have to give her time they will get use to her. I think she will be great on American Idol. She does great on her own show and she has been funny on there. She is new to American Idol and she will relax and fit right in I think.