Who among The AI contestants doesn't deserve to be on top 12?

I actually really like Tim. I think he just needs to find the right music. I am shocked he has lasted this long though. I think Andrew needs to go compared to the other guys. The next two off will probably be him and Tim. I know which one will be up there though. Siobhan is leagues above others in my opinion.

hi there! I don't want to mean and all but like you, I don't think Tim Urban deserves to be on the top 12 or even on top 24. It is just, ugghhh.. I don't see him as a singer. Maybe he can try-out to be an actor or a commercial model but leave the singing to people who can actually sing.

Man..the stakes are pretty high right now, so I don't know who might win this time round.. I've no special favorites yet..let's see how it goes as the game gets more intense.

Tim Urban should have never been in the Top 12. I am already tired of his "shocked" look every Ryan says he is safe. Don't know how many of you have watched AI or how long. I have been watching since season 1. Clay Aiken did that every week looked all surprised he wasn't getting eliminated. Tim is the weakest of the boys and if the young man he replaced didn't break the rules we wouldn't be subjected to this torture. Tim needs to go. They haven't had wild card round for sometime now. Alex Lambert will not be back. Liked him he just needs to get more comfortable on stage. He will as he gets older and gets more experience. Has a very nice voice.

I just totally agree with you guys here...I do believe that Tim Urban was not supposed to be in the American Idol top 12 because his vocals are not that impressive. Although he can sing good, it is not better enough to place him in the American Idol top 12 category. I have faith in the talent of Alex Lambert...his voice is very natural and not being pushed as Ellen DeGeneres would say. What Alex lacked is the attitude of being a star...he's too shy and very humble...maybe because he grew up in a very small town. I do want that Alex Lambert be chosen in the Wild Card because he totally deserves to be given a huge chance to redeem his singing career. He is such a talented artist...and with enough guidance from the judges, he could be the one to beat in this competition. THe only thing that Tim has more votes is because he knows how to act and look at the camera...he is charming and he knows how to let those eyes tell what he wanted to say. But unfortunately this is a singing contest and not a screening for a hollywood show. If only they could feel the harmony behing Alex Lambert's singing then the voters of America would know how strong this individual could be and how his talent could improve some more. THe problem with the American Idol voters is they tend to forget that this is actually a singing contest. The contestants must be judged in their singing flair and not only through the physical aspects and how they act in front of a camera. Although it is part of the package to have the right attitude on becoming a star...still it is best that when you are chosen to be an American Idol...you must be able to have the 'wow factor' and most especially you must be able to sing really good.

I like Mike. I also like Crystal Bowersox (I think that is her name)

I love Alex Lambert! And i am really disappointed when he was voted out. Yes, you are right. He is more talented than Tim Urban. I didn't know why Tim was given another chance to be in the top 24. There are others in the audition who are better than him really. Is there a wild card? When is that? I do hope it will be Alex Lambert who will be picked. Loved his voice..

I'm really disappointed like you to see Alex Lambert go. He has a unique voice and humble personality. He is my boyfriend's favorite as well. I totally agree with you that Tim doesn't deserve to be on Top 12, I think even on Top 24. His voice is just average and the range is very limited. Now that Alex is gone, I think I will just root for Siobhan or Lee Dewyze.

I didn't see the elimination episode when Alex Lambert left, but when I heard that it was him I was bummed out! I really liked Alex. And it's funny because I thought the exact thing you said, Tim Urban should have been the one to leave instead of Alex. I forgot about the wild card and I do hope he is brought back! I know Ellen liked him, he's her banana!! lol

totally agree with you

Based on their talent wise, I would say Lily Scott should replace Lacey Brown and Alex Lambert should replace either Tim Urban or Andrew Garcia. But if based on their performance during the Top 16, then I'll say that Lily Scott should have stay and either Paige Miles or Katie Steven should be eliminated, and for the guys, Alex Lambert should be in and either Tim Urban or Andrew Garcia should be out.

Yeah. I agree with you. No offense, but Alex Lambert is deserving of the place in the top 12 than Tim Urban. Why isn't he voted off? I really like Alex. It was shocking to know when he was voted off.