Our kids are too fat to fight?

@laglen (19759)
United States
April 20, 2010 8:03am CST
WASHINGTON (AP) — A group of retired military officers says high-calorie school lunches are threatening national security. A study by the group Mission: Readiness finds that school lunches are making American kids so fat that fewer of them can meet the military's physical fitness standards. That, in turn, is putting recruitment in jeopardy. A report from the group, being released Tuesday, says that 27 percent of Americans ages 17 to 24 are too overweight to join the military. One of the officers, retired Navy Rear Admiral James Barnett Jr., says many young Americans are simply too fat to fight. The officers are pushing for passage of a wide-ranging nutrition bill that aims to make the nation's school lunches healthier. http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/04/20/school-lunches-national-security-threat/ I think our diets havent gotten fattier, I think the kids have gotten lazier. There is no physical activity anymore. What do you think? Should be just give them all cheese sandwiches?
2 people like this
10 responses
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
20 Apr 10
I agree, food is NOT the problem. Our school systems are teaching kids to sit on their butts all day. Daily gym class is a thing of the past in most schools. Would you believe there are some schools in Florida where kids take gym ONLINE? I have eaten fatty foods, including no shortage of fast foods, my whole life. Throughout that I've actually been underweight most of my life and never been overweight. If you get an appropriate amount of physical activity, you'll be in decent shape regardless of fatty foods. When I was in college I was literally having McDonald's for breakfast every morning. I also exercised 3-5 times a week and played football every Sunday. Laziness is making our kids fat, not the food.
2 people like this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
20 Apr 10
some schools in Florida where kids take gym ONLINE wtf??? seriously? how the hell does that work? I require my daughter to take a sport every year. She is a very healthy weight and due to choices I gave her when she was younger, she now eats fruit for sweet snacks and never drinks soda. She is very active and very healthy. Limited time inside and on video games. We do not watch tv. I still cant get past the online gym class.....
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
you nailed it! I think kids should be getting exercise all day at school. Not only for fitness, but it calms them down, gets the energy out and then they can focus again. I have a nephew who is ten. when he comes over, I keep him busy, he resists for about the first half hour, he would rather watch tv, but after that he is a great kid!
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
21 Apr 10
Dude, it baffles me too. I mean, I couldn't make this crap up if I tried. The kids email their teacher to tell them they exercised each day. It's pathetic. A lot of children's problems come down to parenting, but when schools are literally making kids sit on their butts all day, with no recess or gym time, that's just outside the parent's control. http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/02/education/02gym.html
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Apr 10
LMAO, OK I know this is serious but come on. For one thing school lunches haven't changed a whole lot since I was in school, changes yes. I do not know when mozzarella sticks became a meal that is true when it comes to being worse but I think a large part of it is society not the schools. The schools are just a place for parents to blame their own downfalls on someone else. The thing about two income families is they are more likely to eat take out and other fatty foods that are pre-prepared and bought. To this add the fact that most kids have triple the amount of school work to do at home, sit and play video games or go online, and are lacking in motivation to do physical anything combines to make Americans fat. Many kids do not even have basic chores to do that keep them active such as shoveling snow, raking leaves, mowing lawns. Their parents hire people to do it. As for the school I think a bigger issue is the lack of physical education. I have been out of school not even 15 years, we had gym everyday. The local high school students are on a 6 day rotation and have gym once during each cycle. That means that they have gym less then once a week!
2 people like this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
20 Apr 10
Very good points. I agree I dont think most families feed the kids any better.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
22 Apr 10
I watched Jamie Oliver Food Revolution (for America) and I feel that the food that the children have at school sort of contributes to their weight problem. If they are only offered fries, chips, lots of carbs, and lots of fatty food like hot dogs, bacon, etc. of course, they are going to get fat. I have seen pictures of young people on Tv, and they are the same weight I took 30 years to attain (I started to gain at 30, by 60 I was almost 250 lb. and have now gotten down to 195 lb. and it took me about 5 years to get there.) I also think that much of the problem is not just sitting around and watching Tv or playing video games, it is because much of the meat is from feed lots, instead of cattle and poultry that are allowed to roam free. In the feed lots, they are fed antibiotics, etc. and since in this time when the economy is not that good, people look for the cheapest. Therefore often the choice is either be even a partial meat eater and get fat *unless you are lucky enough to afford organic or free range meat) or become a vegetarian.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
22 Apr 10
I agree that diet is also a factor, but I would really love to get our kids moving!
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
25 Apr 10
They are fat because they are not expected to do anything any more. They play video games, watch tv, no recess in some schools, the list goes on...
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
23 Apr 10
It would help. I wonder why in the States, many of the kids are still fat. Up here, in winter where it gets to minus 40 below, there is an excuse, but down there, unless one lives close to the Canadian border, it is not that cold.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Apr 10
they should send them to the schools i went to.the food looked more like a hazmat risk than national security. sounds more to me like they're more concerned about having cannon fodder than the kids' health.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
22 Apr 10
It usually boils down to politics
@grammasnook (1871)
• United States
21 Apr 10
Well school lunches do add to the obesity issue of some children. Low income people live off of pasta, noodles and such why because then they can afford to feed their children during the whole week. Some are lucky and can grow fresh veggies and fruits year round but in the grocery stores it is very expensive when on a really tight budget. We call our children lazy and yes they may be somewhat lazy, but it is all about society, the outside world has gotten so dangerous for many of our youth. How many children have been shot by a drive by? How many children have been abducted. I think as parents we tend to over protect our children and not let them out of our site. "and why wouldn't we?" Libraries are closing all over the place left and right. Now if your child went to the library to study they would not have access to the refridge. Children eat out of bordom. My son has gym has to pass a physical test running a mile and such but the thing is he has it 2xs a week for 20 minutes each. The sad part is that physical activity not only helps with weight it helps the mind! I would think that they would be smart and have a period daily for gym and then have 10 minute stretching classes once a day to help the brain to REBOOT. My son which is nine years old and in the fourth grade goes to school mon and friday from 9 til 3 and tues wed and thurs from 9 to 5, he comes home with homework everynight. This week is Spring vacation and can you believe they sent him home with a big project and math homework to do over the week. I will be making a call on Monday about this. He has worked on his project for hours so far telling me he has to get top grade and it has to be perfect. They want a 5 page report "typed" Along with a memory box and a poster. My son is 9 for crying out loud! As for the military guidelines saying what they say, my daughter at the age of 20 tried to get into the military, she was 10 lbs overweight she weighed 135 lbs. and they denied her so is it really obesity for them or just no fat at all. After all once she went to basic training that 10 lbs would have disappeared. they are blowing it way out of porportion. The recruiting officer sent her home with some body cleansing stuff and the hollywood diet.. I was like hell NO. That is rediculous to put that crap into your system.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
You make some good points and it sounds like you are a very involved parent. If more were like that, there wouldn't be the problems we have now. Wat to stick up for your kids too! That is very refreshing to see.
@TTCCWW (579)
• United States
21 Apr 10
I just recently realized how bad the diet of our schools were. It is despicable that our schools think that pizza is a breakfast food and that a french fry is a serving of vegetables. No wonder we have the most expensive health care in the world and a 50% high school dropout rate. Physical exercize is important but filling your face with fat 24/7 is a lifetime recipe for really bad health problems. This is not collage and these are developing minds and bodies that should not be taking in that much fat first thing in the morning. Astounding that our schools professionals are so poorly educated. There is not a nutritionalist in the nation that would recoment this kind of diets for a growing child.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
your right, but they are trying to offer a certain amount of nutrients at a small cost that all of the kids will eat. I am not defending this, just saying...
@naka75 (795)
• Singapore
21 Apr 10
In Singapore, young men who are overweight or obese when entering the Army have to undergo several months of special conditioning training that helps them to lose weight and prepare them for the normal military training. The culprit to the cause of overweight in this case I believe, is not the school lunches, but simply because the youngsters' love and indulgence in fast foods and lack of adequate knowledge on proper nutrition and keeping themselves healthy and fit. They would meet friends after school in fast food restaurants to discuss their school projects, and it is considered going with the times and fashionable to hang out in fast food restaurants.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
so true Naka, obviously this is a problem everywhere.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
21 Apr 10
I don't believe the problem is school lunches either. It's a combination of many things that are causing our children to become overweight including, as has already been mentioned, the reduction of physical education in many school's academic curriculum, the general reduction in the activity level of most children thanks to the popularity of video games and the internet and the change in family dynamics, with two working parents being the norm which effects their diets at home. In addition, many schools now have vending machines on campus that sell snacks and sodas. I don't believe that these problems can be legislated away.
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
lol good point. But I really do not think that they should take away all of the junk food, I would rather see more choices. As parents, we can make this happen
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
I agree, I think it is up to the parents, yep I went there, to teach their kids to eat healthy.
• United States
21 Apr 10
But at the same time spalladino they can have a fruit juice machine and offer veggies and fruits in machines. I know my daughter which is 18 years graduating this year complains all the time that by the time she gets to lunch the choices are slim pickings. She loves to have a grilled chicken salad with a fruit and it just is not there. The first lunch has all the choices and the second lunch basically gets what is left over. So she will settle for a "snack" just to keep her going for the rest of the day. Simple fact is if they take out the fries and offer raw carrots and brocoli with a low fat dip kids will eat it. Just so they dont have hunger pains. Morning they serve breakfast, I think they offer the kids like a 2oz drink of juice along with a sugar cereal. Now take the sugar cereal add special k, cheerios, kix a 2oz drink and an apple or orange? They will eat what is available when given a choice of sugar sugar and sugar then they will only have sugar.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Apr 10
Anyone else see this as an excuse for the government to step in and tell americans what they can eat? After all it is a matter of "national security" now according to them. I agree school lunches are not real healthy. I agree kids do not get enough exercise. But it is not a "government issue" is a personal issue. Parents need to make sure their kids are eating junk all day and playing video games with all their free time. Get them outside to play. As as I said...this is not a "government issue". It is a issue for the american people to solve for themselves.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
i agree and yes I do see that. I would like for them to stay out of our parenting.
@k15682 (300)
• United States
21 Apr 10
I might agree with this if I didn't have 2 boys just get out of basic training for the Army. With the new kinder gentler Army it wouldn't matter if the troops were perfect condition body builders.
1 person likes this
@laglen (19759)
• United States
21 Apr 10
lol and isnt that what boot camp is for?