What do you do when other children don't listen to you?

United States
April 26, 2010 12:13pm CST
My son's school allows the parents to go have lunch with their children. I took my son and two friends out to the courtyard because it was such a beautiful day. Not even 10 minutes into lunch-they started running around and I warned them that someone could get hurt. Well that someone wound up being my son who fell and scraped his knee pretty bad...so I told the other two boys to go into the cafeteria and they refused saying they were allowed to stay outside..I said not without adult supervision..and I didn't want to get into trouble so I got the cafeteria aide to get them to go in..I wished I could've handled it myself though but I didn't know what to say. I thought of mylot and how wise most of you mylotters are...So, hence my new discussion ..What do you do when other people's children refuse to listen to you?
3 people like this
7 responses
@SViswan (12051)
• India
27 Apr 10
In this situation, you've now learnt a lesson - you will not want to take your son's friends to have lunch. I think you did the right thing. You have not mentioned the age of the children. Are they old enough to understand if you are firm and speak about consequences? If so, you could have a talk with them after taking care of your son (in a firm way showing them that this was exactly what you were worried of). But seeing the way they reacted to your asking them to go into the cafeteria, I don't think they are the kind who would wait and listen you out. Usually when other people's children refuse to listen to me (this happens usually in social settings and at the apartment complex we stay at), I speak to the parents. I also make it clear that I have spoken to the children and they refuse to listen.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Apr 10
Correct you are! It's the last time I take anyone else's children out in the courtyard to eat lunch..from now on-it's just going to be my son and me. These are kindergardners-all 5 and 6.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
28 Apr 10
Ok, that's an age where they DO understand if you are firm with them. But since you do not know the parents of these kids, you might want to have a word with the teacher to let him/her know that the kids refused to listen to you....not as a complaint but as something that needs to be done to help them learn that they need to listen if they do not want to cause harm to anyone.
1 person likes this
@hollowheart (1572)
• India
26 Apr 10
Dear Rachelle. I can understand what u must have gone through. Hows ur son now? Hope the bruise is healing up fast. Dont worry, he will be fine and running very soon. I know how it feels to see ur own child bleeding and with tears in the eye. Ya its indeed very difficult when others children dont listen to u, because u cant treat the same way as ur own child. But i guess the best way would be to give them a lot of love and care to make them realise their mistakes. At the same time a child is a child and children are meant to be a bit naughty. They r cute that way. But then ya they should listen to elders.
• United States
26 Apr 10
Thanks for the kind response-as always My son is fine..he didn't even cry. I think I'm going to avoid taking other children out to lunch with me in the future...that way I can control mine better
1 person likes this
• India
27 Apr 10
I must say that he is a real brave child. He is just like u...brave, smart and sweet. Ya thats right. Why take responsibilities of others children unless really required. But all i would say is life is full of experiences and thats what we should learn. U learnt a new one. I learnt from u. U r just the most wonderful friend i can have.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
27 Apr 10
I can see why you would feel uncomfortable in dealing with other peoples kid's that don't mind. I don't have much tolerance for that. It's tough with other peoples kid's. If the kids are disrespecting you, then odds are the parents will be right on you if you try to discipline them. When they first started acting out I would have warned them that they would have to go inside if they did not mind. If they continued, we would have gone in. If they refused, I'd have given them a choice of going in peacefully with me or me getting the principal to come and get them. I would have then headed toward the school and I bet they would have followed once they realized you were serious. If not, they get what they deserve.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Apr 10
I did just that and they just sat back down and ignored me...It made me furious!You are right though-I don't think those boys took me seriously. I honestly don't know how to get other people's children to listen to me. My son learned a valuable lesson though-that running when I say no is not an option..he has the scraped knee to remind him of that.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
26 Apr 10
Hi, RachelleNH. Well with me, I will say to them that I may need to talk to their parents. Or I may say nicely to them that it is the right thing to do to follow instructions. I would say it very nicely. I think that you did the right thing by contacting the cafeteria aide, so that way she could lead them into the cafeteria. I don't like dealing with someone else child, because they can go back and tell their parents a bold faced lie about something that I did not do. And I don't want that to happen at all.
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Apr 10
Yeah these boys are quite unruly and my son gets crazy when he's with them. I didn't want to leave them outside so I had to enlist help.
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
Children are always like that. It's really hard to make them stop from what they want to so. As much as possible, we keep on warning them. If they really don't listen, we help them face the consequences of their actions, then they will realize why we are prohibiting them.I always pray for my children for the guidance of the Lord because we parents are not enough to guide them always. We are not always on their side. We also dhow obedience to others so that we give example to our children.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Apr 10
It's true..I try to guide my son the best I can. He usually listens but when he got to running with these boys and I said something-he fell...I told him that is the punishment for not listening. I'm only thinking of his well-being. But after he fell-those two boys refused to go back inside so that I could take my son to the clinic...that was what upset me-I couldn't get them to listen to me at all.
@Masmasika (1921)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
As much as we want to discipline all children other than our own, it is very hard especially the children of today. But to be a parent, the children should be taken cared of. If they refuse to listen then talk to them and ask them how they feel if other children do not listen to their parents. Perhaps they will think again. or you can point out their mistakes and make them realize that they are wrong if they still refuse to listen then let them see what happens with children who are stubborn.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Apr 10
What gets me is these kids know the school rules and yet they still run and not listen...and they got my son to do just the same..I was really uspet with him-he almost always stops the bad behavior right away. They also know that they're not to be out in the courtyard without a parent or teacher supervising-why they wouldn't go in is beyond me.
• Pamplona, Spain
28 Apr 10
Hiya Rachelle, Even with children of close relatives it´s quite difficult to have the responsibility of taking care of them. I have learned to keep my nose out of that too. I rarely offer if any at all to take on anything like that. I did it once and my "sister in law" went completely hysterical just because I closed the front Door to stop her daughter running after her till she had gone downstairs so I said I would never look after her again and I never did. Why ask me in the first place to look after her if all you are going to do is pick faults all the time was my answer to her and so be it. (This was what I said to my Sister In Law) It is really much more complicated now too I think as People seem to be very reactive over reactive to anything. I never smile at a Baby now like I used to instead I send it loving thoughts and they usually smile at me anyway. Don´t feel bad about it you were only thinking of their safety which makes you a very good and caring person. I know that frustration and I have lived without and very happily without Sister in Laws for a very long time what a relief. At the start I always thought I had to be caring and sharing but they don´t want that anyway. Never mind Rachelle you just care for your own first and the rest can take care of themselves.
• Pamplona, Spain
28 Apr 10
Hiya Rachelle, All the yelling in the World will not make them listen that´s right. I can´t yell at anyone else´s Children either so leave it up to the Teachers don´t worry about it. It´s just that you are concerned about Children and their welfare which is a very good thing too. I have minded my own business for so long that now I am used to it. It was quite hard at the start but now I prefer to keep a long distance from other´s children in the sense of looking after them. This can also happen if you look after grown ups who have been ill too I know because it happened to me again but I quickly resolved the situation defused it came back here and got on with my own life.
• United States
28 Apr 10
Thank you for that...I felt obligated to make sure they went back to where they were supposed to be. I've decided that's it for taking other kids out to the courtyard where there's no teachers..only me and them. I'm easily pushed over by kids like that-I don't know what to do to make them listen...and I'm not the yelling type-besides if they weren't listening before what makes anyone think that yelling will solve it?
1 person likes this