Is india deserve to get a permanent seat in international security council

@1anurag1 (3576)
India
June 18, 2010 2:28am CST
Is india deserve to get a permanent seat in security counsil Yes I am talking about the world organisation where only 5 countries are on permanent seat and some are on temporary. India is trying to get the permanent seat for long. But only the super powers are holding those seats. I think for a democratic world if there is no representation for more than a billion people how can it be said that this is geniuine. What are your views.
1 person likes this
2 responses
• Philippines
18 Jun 10
Hello anurag, May I know why you want you're country to be permanently part of the UN security council in the permanent seat? just asking because i believe a Nation being on that position is not just a position, it's very very huge responsibility. So, if India becomes part of it permanently, will be government be strong enough to send troops to terrorist affected areas, fight of a country that links to terrorist? you need to see the consequences if such position is given to a country. I admire the country for having one hell of a military, not to mention you made it in terms of space exploration to the moon. but india still has slums and government is also tainted with corruption, but i am not sure if these were the reasons that kept India being in the permanent seat. You better do research, otherwise it's really nothing that important. as long as you're government is protecting your country, that's enough. let the other super powers handle it coz they're full of it.
1 person likes this
@1anurag1 (3576)
• India
20 Jun 10
First thanks for response But I mean for first the representation. No india means there will no representation of nearly 20% population of the world. Can you imagine today any international organisation without the half of the population of the world which include china and India. Second thing, if only money and power is the parameter then I think this is really not good platform to have a permanent seat. Rest as you have describe the terrorism, helping other countries, space exploration etc. yes I agree may be we are lacking behind in tech, but not very far. We are fighting with the terrorism for more time than US, the Kashmir is the main reason, we don’t have only one enemy, there are Al-Qaida , Lashkar, and many more including the neigbouring country. We are putting huge money in development of Afghanistan and after some terrorist attack on our embassies there we are still going on. We affect the economy of our neighbouring country by supporting them and opening our huge market for them. We are not affected by world recession and one of the fastest growing economies today. By PPP we are the world’s fourth largest economies which would cross japan by two decades. We have also sent our probe to moon and even the US has sent its probe by indian rocket to the moon which have found water there. Means simply we are walking steady. Why Obama ask each time to their companies to work and give jobs in his own country to get the tax benefit. Because there is a scarcity as we can provide what Americans can. I am not against your countries policies. This is their duty to think better first for themselves. I just want to say if china can be there, if Russia can be there why all things depend on power now only. I think if this is the parameter only then the country must start working to get more power only in terms of military etc.
• India
18 Jun 10
Definitely India deserves a place in the Security council of the United Nations Organisation. With the enormous potential and the large masses of people being youth aging less than 25 years it would dominate the world for the next 20years. There is no doubt in anyones mind whatsoever that India will be one in the top 5 economies of the world. Now we rank 12 in world economies and GDP of 8% even when the world powers where crippling under recession. With nuclear arsenal and the only the 5 country to send its spacecraft to moon. We have discovered water on moon that too in the first even moon mission from the country which other countries could not achieve till now. We also have plans for a manned space mission. Leader in Software Outsourcing. INDIA SURELY DESERVES MUCH MORE RESPECT THEN WHAT IT IS GETTING. JAI HIND
• Philippines
18 Jun 10
Well, for one India has my respect, they have come along the way that's for sure. but you know, these five prideful members of the UN council are full of it. simply because of they're participation against terrorism and some even invading another country to boot has lost their economic power and going rot into recession. but think twice if India becomes part of it, you might end up like the Powerful nations like in the US, Recession as it's finest. protecting the world cost money, government money (you're tax payers money).