Deaf or Blind?

United States
August 2, 2010 3:56pm CST
Ok so you may know about this age old question. If you had a choice, would you give up your sight and keep your hearing or keep your vision and give up your hearing. My choice would be to lose my vision. If I lost my hearing, I would no longer hear music or the sound of loved one's voices. Come to think of it, sound is a very emotion-grabbing sense and is very powerful indeed. What would you prefer to lose?
5 responses
2 Aug 10
I'd rather lose my hearing than my sight because at least with deafness I can cope a bit by learning sign language and getting used to lip reading. Sight is really important for me because I think it's the most important thing we need to survive, I am more likely to survive with my sight although it helps to have all senses. I want to know where I am and where I'm going I don't want to bang into things in the way even with a stick I think it must be a scary thing to walk without seeing anything. Also I think deaf people are more independent whereas blind people need to be with someone for most the time.
• United States
3 Aug 10
you raise a very interesting point!
• United States
2 Aug 10
Hi, It would have to be my hearing.. I have a deaf child, born deaf. Watching him prosper and doing daily everyday activities is no more or less for me. He was able to have a cochlear implant surgercily implanted. He has the best of both worlds, if he wants to hear things, he puts on the implant, if not it goes off. His vision is the tops. He can see like a cat at night. I wish I could see like that. Without vision your not able to have the freedom in driving. Good question by the way! :-)
• United States
2 Aug 10
thank you that is very interesting. My boyfriend actually has a similar problem. He is completely deaf in one ear and has to wear a hearing aid. Funny how knowing people that have hearing issues aids our decision in what senses we really want to use.
@Suke002 (311)
• United States
2 Aug 10
I think I would rather be deaf. I would love to hear my loved one's voices and music. But I want to be able to see colors and see my loved ones and I'm an artist, I want to be able to see my work and be able to create art side by side with my boyfriend. So yeah, I would rather lose my hearing, even though either loss are equally great.
• India
3 Aug 10
L would prefer to lose my hearing than my sight because I need sight to look this beautiful world,human being and especially I want to know were I am staying and going.Its impossible for me to survive without eyes sight,I cant walk without eyes even using sticks also.
• United States
3 Aug 10
Hands down, I would prefer to lose my hearing. I cannot imagine not being able to see the beautiful things around me. I think you can assimilate better in out society with hearing loss rather than vision, too.