Who do you think should be blame for the hostage taking in Manila yesterday?

Philippines
August 24, 2010 3:14am CST
A hostage-taking in Manila, Philippines in which a former policeman held 15 Chinese tourists on a bus who are supposed to leave the country last night.., 9 of them died including the gun man.. It took half of the entire day to negotiate but still the police failed.., should we blame the hostage taker himself.., for taking the lives of innocent people just because he demanded to be reinstated with benefits to his previous post at the Manila Police District from which he had been dismissed from for extortion in 2009? Or should we blame the lousy response of the Manila police to respond on the hostage taker's demands?
1 person likes this
4 responses
@1hopefulman (45123)
• Canada
24 Aug 10
First, we should blame the insane gunman. No excuses! He had a problem, the Chinese tourists had nothing to do with his problem. They were not involved in anyway. Second, why didn't the police, promise him anything to get the hostages released? How they handled things looks stupid to say the least. The hostages who were innocent should have been the priority. To all police involved, you are a discredit to your profession. Third, whoever made the decisions needs to answer in an open inquiry. This is just too sad a situation. I weep with those who weep. This is a black mark on the police involved. Innocent people should be saved at all costs. Madmen can appear anywhere anytime and no one can do anything about that. But it does seem from the news reports that the police need to come up with some good answers as to why they let it escalate to this degree.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
25 Aug 10
Yes.., I agree with you.., and I am disappointed with how the police handled the situation and failed.., failed because a lot of live were lost.., a lot of innocent lives.., They could have done better and save more lives if they have just given the hostage taker false promises to what he was after in the first place just to have all the hostages released.., =(
@Qaeyious (2357)
• United States
24 Aug 10
I wonder how many people in the United States will put the blame on Obama, since they seem to think he causes all the evil the world. I still cannot get the concept of getting a job of law enforcement back by taking hostages. Isn't it a crime to do that? Would he really have kept the job with something like that in his recent past? He was only dismissed for extortion, and not convicted? I don't know about how the Philippines law works, so I'm not sure how blame would be given. Or is being fired from your job such a hardship that it is a punishment? Was there some kind of hearing where evidence could be presented to prove he was guilty? Sorry, I have more questions than answers at this time.
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
Yes I heard there was a hearing.., It was part of the process and resulted to his extortion.., But what he demanded was to be placed back into his position and his retirement benefits must not be taken away from him.., and he wanted to teach the government a lesson too..
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
well the media also has some fault in it and of course the police also.
• Philippines
24 Aug 10
the president of course. who keeps smiling through out the interview. that's sad really. and then his cops. they should get fired from such a failed operation.