Rewarding before the task is done?

@Pleiades (846)
United States
September 4, 2010 1:40pm CST
I would like to hear from you on your opinion on this: If you knew of a child that was grounded at home, do you think it's right for that child to participate in a special activity given by an outside adult due to the child's good behaviour at school? At that school, the child gets a behaviour colour for how they did: Blue is excellent, green is good, yellow is not so good, orange is bad and red is very very bad. The agreement between the child and the parent with the babysitter was if the children got five days worth of green marks, he'd be able to go swimming. A week is from Monday to Friday. But their school has early release days on Wednesday. This child had three days so far of good marks and was allowed to go swimming, even though he was grounded during the week for being mouthy, argumentative, lying and forging signatures for the school. Me? I would have had the child prove for one week solid that he can do the required one week and not being grounded. ~Pleiades UPDATE: Turns out the child was allowed to go swimming, but the day after this event, he came home with an orange mark so even if the adults had waited out the full week, he blew it.
1 person likes this
2 responses
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
15 Sep 10
I personally wouldn't have allowed it myself. If I say that the child has to behave for an entire week, then it means they have to behave for an entire week and perhaps the following week when there was an early release of Wednesday I would have taken the child swimming for their good behavior the prior week. This kind of positive reinforcement doesn't work unless you hold to the rules that are set forth in the beginning.
• United States
4 Sep 10
One week is one week-5 days. I wouldn't have let the child get off early. If the evcnt had been planned and the invitation extended and accepted prior to the child being grounded,and the event was for another child, I might have considered it, but not for any other reason.