Do you second-guess yourself?

doubts in decision-making - Second guessing because of doubts
@bounce58 (17387)
Canada
September 9, 2010 4:24pm CST
Maybe it’s a question of confidence but I often second-guess myself. Not only with the more serious things, but even with the common, trivial things. If you find that you are second-guessing yourself, what do you do? Do you stick with your decision and plough through? Or would you need validation to make yourself at ease with a decision you just made? If so, what sort of validation do you need? A kind word from a friend? A support group you create? Or is this a common thing, and just part of being human, to deal with everyday doubts?
5 people like this
12 responses
@RangaGirl (103)
• Australia
10 Sep 10
I tend to have better success with decisions if I go with my gut reaction, my first thought. If I think things over and over, I seem to discount the original idea. I'll mull things over and go through the scenarios, good and bad in my head. Nine times out of ten, if I choose to go in the opposite direction to my first thought, one of the bad scenarios plays out. Just this week, when something related to work was bothering me, I decided I should keep quiet because something else could happen. Unfortunately, despite knowing what I should do, I played the dilemma out in my head so many times that I changed my mind and spoke up. Sure enough, I worsened the situation for myself and have noone to blame but me that an exact bad scenario that played in my head, came about. As usual, I should have listened to my gut instinct. Generally, I try to listen to my "angels". I truly believe I have angels who guide me. When I don't listen (perhaps they ARE what gives me my first thought) things go wrong. While there are many examples of this, the one that makes my point most simply is, a few years ago, a thought, (my angels) told me to drive a different way to usual. I didn't listen - and my car was rear-ended and written-off. Had I gone the other way, that would not have happened. Now, if something tells me to go a different way, I try to trust that, and usually do. As for validation, I usually trust myself more than others. I may tell others what is happening and ask what they would do, listen to what they say - and then do what I think is best. Someone gave me advice only today but I didn't follow it because I am 99 percent sure it would have made matters worse. The person later asked if I'd done as she suggested and I said no, explaining why. She laughed and called me cynical - but said I was probably right. It doesn't hurt to listen to others' thoughts. It can help us weigh things up but, ultimately, I really think we have to follow our gut. Also, doing it our own way, we only have ourselves to blame if things don't work out. That works for me since I am responsible for my own life and destiny.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
15 Sep 10
Wow! To your story about the angels telling you to drive a different way, and you getting into an accident because you did not listen. You see, I am the same way. I sometimes get gut feels and initial impulses on decisions I have to make. And I could definitely say that 99 out of a hundred, that the gut feel decision is always right (or, maybe I make it right?) But common sense, and being mature and responsible tells us to alway mull things over. And this is where second guessing comes. Thanks for dropping by RangaGirl!
• Australia
16 Sep 10
I'm glad you could identify, bounce. Sorry I am so long-winded in getting my points across. It doesn't hurt to mull things over. Sometimes we end up going with the original thought anyway but at least we have considered all possibilities.
@dream_ozn (1754)
• Singapore
10 Sep 10
Yes, I do second-guess myself as well. Even for small matters, I will keep thinking whether I had made the correct decision. For me, I need a kind of validation to make myself at east. Perhaps a word from a friend or even my boyfriend, he would be the best validation. Is this a common thing? well, for that I am not too sure, but I sure do feel better at least now I know I am not the only one that is worried about such stuff. Everytime I make a decision, I will keep pondering over whether I should have done that or not.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
16 Sep 10
You've brought up one word that I guess we are all looking for when we decide on things -validation! If a kind word was indeed said to serve as validation for our decision, then it would indeed help ease up on the second-guessing. Thanks!
• United States
10 Sep 10
I think it is because I am More Stubborn than a mule that once I make up my mind about things I never change it.Ranging from vowing never to bowl again in 1983 and I never will. To Not having kids , which I decided when I was 7!But with that said I do take my time deciding What to do. I rarely ask advice, I just think about the what ifs. I got better at this after I learned chess. Once I find the correct thing to do fir me , I stick to it. All I can say is sit down, take your time and make the decision You can live with. And Never hesitate to ask someone you trust their opinion.
• United States
12 Sep 10
Tack Bror!
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
14 Sep 10
I knew there was something good about playing chess! You are far in a better place than I Sarah. I've grown to learn that from you here in myLot. And I long to be in a similar place soon. It would take a little time, and a lot f growing pains still, but I'll get there.
1 person likes this
• United States
15 Sep 10
I know you will make it.
@dawnald (85130)
• Shingle Springs, California
9 Sep 10
Usually if I second guess myself and change what I'm doing, I find out that I was right the first time. Sometimes I fix things rather than mess them up though...
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
11 Sep 10
Hi dawn. I've gathered that about you. You've got a tough resolve, specially with the tough decision you've made recently. And I guess the process you're going through right now is your way of fixing things. Again, good luck!
@daliaj (5674)
• India
9 Sep 10
I usually don't do second guessing. It will mess up the whole thing and make me worry about if I have taken the right decision or not. I think a lot before taking an important decision. Once I take the decision, I keep my mind steady and go with the decision whatever happens. I don't think second guessing is a good thing to do with me.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
11 Sep 10
As it should! Decisions should be thought a lot. And ideally there should be no looking back when you've made one. Good on you! Unfortunately, I could not say the same for myself. Thanks!
• United States
10 Sep 10
I rarely second guess myself. However, I do spend a bit of time weighing all sides before making a decision, and yes, I elicit advice from friends and support groups as part of making a lot of decisions. Once I do decide on something, I generally stick with it; takes quite a lot of convincing to change my mind.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
16 Sep 10
But doesn't that take too much time before deciding? I guess when something is really that important, it would merit however long the time for you to decide. And it would help your stance in sticking to it, even if you second guess yourself. Thanks!
@Ramaditya (1227)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 10
In my opinion, second-guessing is normal. That is part of life that brings us to learn which one is right and wrong. Trial and error, that's what makes us learn. As for my case; I seldom feel second-guessing, because I am a careful person when it comes to decision-making. Besides, I also seldom regret what I have done, because what has been done is done.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
13 Sep 10
Great attitude about things done as done. And I see your point of second guessing as just a way to learn in life. If only there were no consequences to the things that we second guess, then it would be nice. Thanks.
@bingskee (5234)
• Philippines
10 Sep 10
yes, i do. a lot of times. and i believe most people do. it helps listening to other people's ideas, especially from friends, or relatives who are experts on the matter. i dont usually share my doubts with strangers.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
15 Sep 10
Sometimes I find the ideas of friends and relatives only help cloud up the decision making process. Especially if their recommendations are contrary to my initial gut feel reaction. Thanks for responding.
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
10 Sep 10
When i am unsure or uncertain I have been guilty of second guessing myself. We all have doubts and fears. We make choices and often wonder did i make the right one.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
15 Sep 10
It's the mastery of those doubts and fears that I wish to learn someday. So that I don't have to second-guess myself all the time if I make a decision that isn't well thought of. Thanks sender621!
@juggerogre (1653)
• Philippines
10 Sep 10
I don't see anything wrong about second guessing ourselves. We experienced that. Even the best leaders out there second-guessed there selves. So its up to you if you want to change your decision. If you are second-guessing your self I'm sure you didn't think of your decision thoroughly. Think about it some more time and then decide if you want to stick with it or not.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
15 Sep 10
you are second-guessing your self I'm sure you didn't think of your decision thoroughly. Great way to put it! I'm sure that any doubts that creep up after a decision has been made only attests to inclomplete evaluation of the situation/decision. Thanks.
• Philippines
10 Sep 10
If you doubt on something, it simply means you have some thoughts that you are not sure with then there's no harm in it. We call it the benefit of the doubt right? Its good to make second-guess, at least you wouldn't regret in the end..
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
17 Sep 10
That's the fear! The reason why I second guess sometimes. That I might regret it in the the end. It takes a bit of learning and getting used to. Thanks jheypee26! And welcome to myLot!
@Joman122 (118)
• Canada
9 Sep 10
I always second guess myself. I had a physics test today and I second guessed myself. After the test, I looked in my book to see if I used the right formula, but I didn't. I didn't get my test back yet, but I think my initial reaction was the right one.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
13 Sep 10
That is the worst kind of second-guessing, when it happens during tests. I hope it wasn't that bad on your physics test. Or at least you could make up for it if the test result isn't that good. Goodluck!