Have you seen the video with the so called "time traveler"?
By rappeter13
@rappeter13 (8608)
Romania
October 30, 2010 4:51pm CST
Yesterday I was watching the TV and I stopped at a channel where they were debating about a mysterious fragment from Charlie Chaplin's "The Circus" movie from 1928 seems to be talking at a mobile phone. Many have said that this is a trick, but it seems very genuine. Others said that this is an alien or a time traveler who was caught on tape. And other think that she was using an auditive device, but why would she talk to it, because she certainly does.
What do you think? Can it be real? or it is just a "fixed" video?
Personally I find it very weird, but I don't believe in aliens and time traveling neither.
Here is the video if you haven't seen it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gj3qesTjOE8&feature=related
6 responses
@rosdimy (3926)
• Malaysia
31 Oct 10
It could be possible that the scene was real, but the person was not a time traveller. Consider the following points:
1) Years ago I read about a strange incident that happened in North American continent in the early 20th century. The sky was overcast with low clouds. A man, if I remember it right, was working on his farm. Suddenly he heard voices in the sky. He looked up, and saw two men on a contraption attached to a kind of balloon. They were pedalling hard to move a propeller. Since at that time no such craft existed in the human world, nobody really believed his story.
2) From a religion's viewpoint, at least in Islam, there were already beings created by God long before Adam. Some were given the capability of changing shapes. t would be quite natural for them to be technologically advanced than the present human race.
2.1) There is a local story of a woman who went to Mecca early last century. She went by ship as there was no air flights at that time. A woman befriended her, and they became close friends. On returning to Malaya the woman invited her to visit her village.
On the appointed day she took a train ride. On arriving at her destination she found the other woman was already waiting for her. She was taken to a car which was far more advanced than what was actually available, including fully air-conditioned.
At a time when te air-conditioner was not yet invented, how was she able to describe a car with a cool interior even when the windows were closed? After returning home she realised her friend was a bunian.
2.2) A few religious people in my country believed that Mars was devastated by a global, large scale nuclear war.
@redmaryjane (891)
• United States
31 Oct 10
Wow that's interesting, especially what you stated in 2.2! What religious group is this?

@rappeter13 (8608)
• Romania
31 Oct 10
Do you believe in aliens or time travelers? Because I don't, I find this things impossible to exist.
@spiderlizard22 (3443)
• United States
30 Oct 10
I know the woman is putting her hand by her hear but I don't think she is talking to anyone. I do not think she is using a cell phone. I do not think the woman in the video is a time traveler. In order for time travel to be real you have to reverse all progress in the universe and revert back to its previous forms. That also means that the time traveler either has to split in two where one goes backwards and the other doesn't or where the time traveler goes backwards just as everything else is doing. If everyone expect the time traveler is going backwards it could create a "paradox" If the time travel where you make everything change to look like it was in the past then it wouldn't be going to the past but more of making look like the past.
@rappeter13 (8608)
• Romania
31 Oct 10
I don't believe in aliens nor in time traveling. But I am convinced that the woman, who seems more like a man if we judge the face, is talking, because the lips are moving like a person's who is talking. Maybe this is a professionally doctored video, if I would have the original movie I could tell if it is or not. Any case I think there is an explanation for what is happening there.
@tonyllenium (6251)
• Italy
31 Oct 10
i saw on the net the fact that you refer too..so in my opinion should be a trcik but in any case if it isn't..it would eb cool if it will be a time traveler...but if so which operator chose this man to travel among times?

@rappeter13 (8608)
• Romania
31 Oct 10
You have a great sense of humor, I like it. If it is a trick, than it is a very professional one.
@o0jopak0o (6390)
• Philippines
1 Nov 10
Well I have seen it. If it is really not a fake video, then it is something interesting.
@redmaryjane (891)
• United States
31 Oct 10
I don't think it's a trick. But the world has been mystified about a lot of things in the last few decades, and this adds more mystery. If and when they find out about it, I hope it doesn't disappoint. Not that I hope that it proves time traveling or anything like that. It's a mystery that makes the world more interesting. We can only keep guessing and more me, this is enough :)
@rappeter13 (8608)
• Romania
31 Oct 10
I agree that mystery makes world more interesting, but I think we will find the answer if the fragment is fixed or not in a short time. If it is fixed, then mystery's solved, if it is not fixed, then we have to make deep searches about what that thing could be.




