CRITICISM: Bane or Blessing?

Philippines
November 23, 2010 9:23pm CST
Is criticism always a bad thing? How can I disagree strongly, express myself clearly, and still retain the respect of those I criticize? Does the critic really have a point that I need to be aware of? I believe that criticism can be a tool for growth. We need not dismiss critics as troublemakers; instead we ought to take time to look at their point of view. More growth is nurtured by open dialogue than in an atmosphere where all criticism is shut off as disloyalty. In fact, unresolved differences of opinion or a persistent failure to listen to another point of view can not only sour relationships but also destroy the atmosphere of trust. How then shall we handle criticism?
5 responses
@lingli_78 (12822)
• Australia
25 Nov 10
it really depends whether the criticism is constructive or destructive... if it is a constructive criticism, then i will accept it with an open heart and even thank the person who criticize me... i will do some self-reflections as well... but if the criticism is destructive, then i will just ignore it as i think it is not worth it to waste my time on such criticism... take care and have a nice day...
• Philippines
26 Nov 10
Thank your critic. I agree with you, Lingli_78. Critics come in all hues: combative, aggressive, frivolous, forceful, personal, rational, illogical, silly, intellectual, etc. Whatever the case may be, your recognition of each as a person, your appreciation of the the time and concern they have shown, and your interest in their point of view would help you build a strong relationship with them. You might even win a a friend! :D
@jennbart (1330)
• Philippines
24 Nov 10
Blessing I must say as a criticism can make you a better person. But then again, its how something has been said, or how you see things being told to you. It still goes down to how it was given to you. A constructive criticism should not tackle only the bad things, they must also suggest stuffs that can make whatever you did, better. Constructive Criticism- Your content is good, but you do not seem confident about what you are saying, I think you should be more confident for you to convince your audience. Bad Criticism- You are fidgeting while you are standing there like an idiot. Do you know what you are talking about? did you really study your piece?
• Philippines
26 Nov 10
So, if we are the criticizer... We have to determine whether our response is constructive or destructive. When we are tensed up with strong feelings, our intentions may be constructive, but our approach and end results may not be. In expressing criticism, choice of words is very important. Some words hurt, while others convey the point with nuances of concern. Any expression of opinion should take into account the weakness and the strength in the opposite point of view. And if we are criticized... We need to identify the source clearly, clarify the issue, keep calm, keep a sense of humor and evaluate. We don't take immediate commitment to change. Thank you,Jennbart.
• India
24 Nov 10
I consider criticism as blessing. In my case wheneve i get a criticism I work towards it and get good results out of it. For instant we may feel bad but after sometime you can always think the positive side of it and be happy. It is a bane for the people who takes it and blessing for the person who utilise the opportunity.
• Philippines
25 Nov 10
Good vibes! We can't allow ourselves to be destroyed. Let's make the choice to take what is harshly stated and use it to help us grow. One failure in one part of our lives does not make the rest of it shambles... :D Thanks, Ganeshprabhuk.
@Bannybanzie (1397)
• Philippines
24 Nov 10
Hi! Well, I think whether criticism would be a bane or blessing absolutely depends on two things. First, who gives it and what is his/her reason, and second, to whom was it given and how/she accepts it. There are people who would criticize you because they want to bring you down. On the other hand, there are people who criticize others because they want him/her realize what else he/she can do to make things better. The person who accepts it is also a great factor as I have said. The way you accept criticism would affect how that criticism would change your life. If you accept is as a piece of good advice and work on it, then good. But if you would only see the negative side of the opinion expressed, bad. I think we should all be careful in giving criticism and accepting it. It may be hard, or may be easy. It may be unacceptable, or just right. But anyways, we should do our best in everything and accept criticism as something for our betterment. Right? :D
• Philippines
25 Nov 10
Hello, Bannybanzie! I so agree with you. If we choose to criticize an action or decision, we should consider some points before we give final shape to our criticism. We have to be sure we have something worth saying. What is really our point? Are we clear about what we wish to say? Or, if we are the recipient of criticism, some ideas may cushion us in our moments of distress. We have to identify the source clearly and clarify the issue, if there is any. Cheers!
• Philippines
24 Nov 10
If anyone criticizes me, I would consider what they say and use their comments to empower myself more. Though, I've come across those who criticizes only to belittle me, I used to cringe away at that, but now I just don't care! I take the criticisms that are no doubt for my growth and just dismiss those that only makes my self confidence shrink...anyway, I can't very well please everyone! Usually those close to you who gives criticism are usually only thinking of your welfare, and they have a point most of the times, but those who doesn't even have an inkling of who and what you are and give you their piece of mind, well, they're not worth your thinking time...Believe in yourself, and you'll find that in the end those friends who are worth keeping will tell you your right...
• Philippines
25 Nov 10
Yes, Marapplestiffy, we should take courage. Hurting is part of growing. It can be painful to admit our weaknesses, especially if when we have made strong efforts to make positive changes. And also, indeed, take advice from those who know us well, those we can trust. With criticisms, we can find confirmation of our strengths as well. :)