Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

I kinda liked the newer one better. I heard it was more like the book and I thought it was more funny than the older one.

The new version is ok but I like the old version better.

i hate charlie and the chocolate factory. I watched the old version and it made me sick and puke. It reminded me of being in a messed up dream or watching a circus while having the flu. It bothers me lol.

They are both very good movies and I'm not sure which one I like better. The new one is definitely closer to the book, but that was it's goal as opposed to the older one. Plus, Johnny Depp is one of my favourite actors and delivered an all-star performance as Willy Wonka. I guess I would say the new one. A lot of people complained about the Oompa Loompa songs in the new one, but if you read the book the lyrics are identical, so that's why they are the way they are. But, again, both movies are excellent.

The old one is BETTER, dont care for the new one at all.

OLD VERSION

I like the old version better.

I like the old one better, if it was not for johnny depp I would not like the new one at all.

Old Gene Wilder is so much hotter than Whats his name.HAHA Seriously I do like the old one better

I prefer the older version of Charlie and The Chocolate Factory. It is probably because I love older movies and I grew up with that one, so I may be a bit prejudiced.

old version

I do like both versions though I would have to say that I prefer the older version because I grew up with it. But, the newer version is equally entertaining.

i never seen it.. it is worth seeing?

Old version is better

There's good bits to both, I love Johny Depp dearly as everyone knows and he was very good as Willie Wonka but I like the old style Umpa Lumpas better, can't really remember the old one much - I was too little ha-ha.

I like them both, but I prefer the old one

I never saw the old version.

Id have to stick with the origianl version

The old version.. alot better quality..

I've always likes the older one better, but I can't complain about the new one.:-)