Debates between student and professor?
By kendedes2011
@kendedes2011 (2712)
Indonesia
December 19, 2010 1:48am CST
One student was in philosophy class who discuss about the existence of Allah. The professor delivered the following logic:
"Are there people in this class who can hear Allah?" No one is talking.
"Are there people in this class that can touch the God Almighty?" No one is talking.
"Are there people in this class who could see God Almighty?" No one is talking
When there is no one who spoke for the third time he concluded, "Thus Allah does not exist."
The students do not like to hear about it and asked for permission to speak. The professor allowed him and then the student will stand up and ask the following questions to classmates.
"Are there people in this class that the professor brain can hear us?" Quiet
"Are there people in this class that can touch the professor brain we?" really quiet
"Are there people in this class who can see the professor brain we?" When there is no person in the class who dared to speak, the student concluded,
"So, based on the logic of our professors, it is true that he has no brains!"dumb students! right?
2 people like this
9 responses
@nakula2009 (2325)
• Indonesia
26 Jan 11
The next time, his father brought back a former minister of Islamic clerics and children who have , named Rev. Muhammad Isa. When Kris was in the room were told that the priest had come, he was nervous. So he ventured to call cpc Insan Mokoginta, whose books and writings VCD debate has become a collection. Mr. Mokoginta told to not be afraid and that Kris brought the Holy Qur'an Arabic text without translation. So conversation ensued between the preacher with Kris and her family. The preacher who claimed to have just one year moved to the Christian religion started stance by citing the Quran translation is spoofed. Kris was a translation that is used to correct the preacher. Then Kris handed the Koran to the preacher to show where the verse is cited. Old pages are turned upside down, the pastor finally said that he had forgotten, because it is no longer read since his move to Christianity ... (maybe?). And once again Kris's father had to stop the discussion for the sake of seeing the preacher was unable to stem the arguments Kris.
@babytaffster (2236)
• Chatsworth, California
20 Dec 10
Based on the students poor use of grammar we can assume that school "doesn't work to good" for him.
@dayangsumbi2010 (1724)
• Indonesia
13 Jan 11
old story about the debate between a believer in God and that no
although the original in the story the professor did not mention the name of God of a particular religion
@gmkk1986 (471)
• India
19 Dec 10
Things will change to mind to mind and about god and religion is sensitive matter. Every one will have their own believes and briefs. As per you question it was a debate and that too between student and professor.
One who experience and one who learning from experiences. No doubt both of them will not win this as its secret for all humans.
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
19 Dec 10
As far as professor's logic is concerned, I am wondering, how could someone speak like that?
People have belief in "God" since the existence of mankind on earth and if the professor HAS his own way of thinking, he just can not prove it with these three non-sense lines.
This professor is very lucky that he is in 21st century, otherwise, we know what happened to Galileo.
If you ask me, the professor was correct to some extent but he couldn't explain his way of thinking to the students.
As the way of thinking has changed from 16th Century to 21st Century, it will change from 21st century to the near future and who knows, then one will not have to give any logic for such things.
We are not aware of the truth and the problem is, we do not even want to understand/accept/know the truth.
More than anything else, I believe in time, it will uncover the truth....possibly our generation will not exist then to understand and accept the truth. 
@RebeccaScarlett (2532)
• Canada
20 Dec 10
This professor's logic was flawed and faulty. No one in that class could see or hear one million dollars, but that doesn't mean that amount of money doesn't exist somewhere. There may not be any student in that class who has ever seen a kangaroo, and they exist. I don't believe God or Allah exists, but the professor's logic was not a legitimate refutation of their existence.
