What causes domestic violence?

India
December 25, 2010 12:21am CST
There is a state called Bihar, in India, where the number of domestic violence cases have raised to an alarming level. I know that these acts of violence have been committed all over the world. But 65% of the males in this state think domestic violence a legit way to dominate over their spouses. To make the matter worse a majority of those women think that violence to some extent is admissible in households. The news is really very depressing. What causes domestic violence? Husband and wife are meant to be partners, associates and lovers, not enemies. Law has forbidden all such acts of violence, but the statistics clearly shows that a mere law is not enough to protect the right of women in households. Lack of awareness, frustration caused by malfunction of system, lack of care, hidden aggression and orthodox ideas are the few factors causing violence. But I believe there are other hidden agenda to this. Please share your views on this. How indeed, can this heinous crime be prevented?
2 people like this
18 responses
@Baluyadav (3643)
• India
25 Dec 10
hi,Not only in India,you take any part of the world,the reasons are similar,basically. Too much variation in wealth[Richness vs Poverty] among public in a certain area..... Struggle to settle down or struggle to dominate over the others in the society etc.,feelings among people... Geographically backward area [Drought prone area..Forest area..] These are some of the reasons,may be so many according to the local situations.. All the best AND HAVE A NICE TIME.
1 person likes this
• India
5 Jan 11
Domestic Violence - Some cases of domestic violence doesn't even reach the court. Due to the fear of social disgrace many people choose not to reveal the incidents. This only encourages the offender even more.
Yes there are places all over the world where violation of women's rights is an everyday occurrence. There are places where women are abused in public. I recently saw a video where a woman was beaten in public for her alleged infidelity to her husband. But that is a country where democracy has completely collapsed. India advocating Human Rights on important international platforms. We expect more from this country.
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
25 Dec 10
Hello sweetie. The day when men start to realize that women ain't there punching bags anymore? Not likely though. I don't think this will ever stop. Wish those women can beat up the men for once. Then this might end. TATA.
• India
2 Jan 11
Well there are cases where violence comes from the female member of the family. But that doesn't make the relationship any better. Our family needs our support and love. We should also seek refuge in our families at the times of our distress. The relationship should be build on cooperation and understanding. Punching bag is the exact word here. We take out our aggression on our family and it ruins our last hope of getting back to normalcy.
• India
2 Jan 11
Thanks baby. Yes, that I don't understand myself. When I am distressed, I go ask for help from my family. I am what I am because my family has been supportive. But how can someone support an unruly and violent person? At least one has to be humble enough to admit that one's in trouble. Ego shouldn't come between two family members. Asking for help and support isn't humiliating at all. It is, in fact, the bravest thing to do.
@saphrina (31552)
• South Africa
2 Jan 11
Nice pic my sweet pea. Okay, the punching bag i did get, which i decided to test out as well. And no. i didn't hurt him enough though. I cannot understand why men and women take their anger out on their families. Go hit a tree or something then.
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
27 Dec 10
You know friend. There is no specific reasons where that violence coming from. It is in the part of a person or depending on the person educational background. Because most of the people doing so are in no means of education... Maybe the law your referring to is weak and not established to protect the right of women in your country... If the law is clear and enforce without any doubt. it maybe a protection against women violence...because your country is a country which having different culture...
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
13 Jan 11
You right, my friend. If law makers in your country, did not do something to stop that violence or unfair treatment between man and woman... As you said; Your country may regret it in the future. I don't know particularly the constitution in your country if there is a "bills of right". Where protecting human rights of every individuals... Law makers should review those old laws that's not fit to apply to the current situation. Where many young people are open minded and professionals...
• India
4 Jan 11
There is really nothing wrong with the law. But I don't think the enforcers fully understand the gravity of the situation. Or they are of the same opinion as the persons who are committing the violence. The culture in my country has never been like this. But in a few places this culture has been twisted and applied in a way to fulfill the selfish interests of a few. If this violence isn't stopped now, then the nation may regret this in future. If our politicians had been sincere in their cause, they would have done something about it. But, quite unfortunately, the politics in our country is centered around the ballot box.
@manbir84 (134)
• India
26 Dec 10
Yes it is a matter for concern.This kind of mind set where womens are also accept violence as you said are because of illiteracy.People should make their children educate.I mean education is must to balance the society.Thats it nothing else.No other thing is required at that part of the world.
• India
5 Jan 11
I agree. But it seems that our educational system is also severely flawed. Often the most educated person here gets involved in the gravest form of crime. Unless we effectively use education as a medium of imparting ethics, all our attempts will fail.
@manbir84 (134)
• India
6 Jan 11
Then body of young ones requires to make strong political party silently with enough funds in their bag and courage to stand against worst.It is not that difficult neither that easy.But who cares about difficulties if someone want to bring revolution.This can make difference,people like you can make this difference but if you want.
• United States
25 Dec 10
Oh how terrible this rising problem, as it is also risen here in the US. Just my assumption but the person committing the violence against their spouse also came from broken, and abusive homes themselves therefore they are raised with the idea that this is not wrong. Then there are those that simply are abusive by nature, where as life stresses are carried over into violence and the spouse being the one in the forefront at the moment leads them to release and cause so much havoc the way they do. So not right. Some of the women are also from broken and abusive backgrounds where as they too feel that this is the way life should be and while some love their spouses dearly have absolutely no idea on how to live without their partner, and sometimes they feel they can change them or something is wrong with them. Which all boils down, again in my opinion to low self esteem and or confidence. I state my opinions solely based on my past and all the friction I was made to feel. Some like me at some point finally develop the courage to let go, while others perhaps are way too afraid and feel they have no allies from escaping this form of life.
• India
2 Jan 11
Domestic Violence - People should not take their anger out on their families. Families are their to support you when you're distressed. They also depend on your support.
I think it has something to do with culture and education. People don't understand the simple fact that their spouse are meant to assist them in case of difficulties. When a man is having a troubled life, he takes out the anger on his wife and children. Social pressure is a terrible thing and I admit that not all people are strong enough to tolerate it with patience. But at least they can use some common sense here. They can share their problems with their spouses. This is a positive way of dealing with stress and humiliation in workplace. I agree with your theory of abusive background. People who are reared in violence are ten times more likely to demonstrate violent behavior in future.
• India
2 Jan 11
omg! I hope you're not wearing one of those purple lipsticks
• United States
2 Jan 11
Happy New Years to you and is it too late to send my cyber kiss. muaa muaa!
• Philippines
25 Dec 10
Hello, So depressing! The percentage shows that it became a norm to that certain community and it is quiet hard to intervene and impose things there which we think the right way. Domestic violence has many factors and forms. It is not just on the physical level but the worst is on the psychological one. Husbands resulting to beating their wives when crisis felt in the family. Crisis in terms of finances due to unemployment , uncertainty, unsecured job which results to loosing of self confidence especially on the male side. Mostly financial incapacity of the family triggered such buried behavior . The reason behind the aggression of a male which most husband hardly accept what they did is the kind of upbringing they had and the experiences they had in their lives. It manifest unnoticeably when emotionally disturb or bothered. Here in my country we have a very strong law protecting women's right and it is being feared by men and husband.The RA 9262 - Anti-Violence Against Women. Many organization came out in protecting women and children who are suffering from domestic violence for humanitarian purposes and share the meaning and fulfillment of life existence. May the message of the son of God born in a manger instill in our heart. Merry Christmas!!
• India
2 Jan 11
We have laws in here too. But it's use remains limited to the legal advisors and enforcers. There are laws to prevent every violence. But does that prevent violence from taking place? I think we had enough with laws and ordinances. The main issue still remains unreachable. We should start from the root and that is education and awareness. The only effective way of imparting ethics among our citizens is through education. Education alone can be a solution to major social problems. But are we sincere enough to implement that kind of education in our societies? As long as the citizens remains uneducated, some people will find it easier to rule over them. This conflict in interests is preventing the rulers from doing real welfare to the state.
• Philippines
2 Jan 11
Hi, Dissemination of laws and ordinances may help one to do such untoward behavior. For knowing such laws may fear one from doing it. Although formal education includes the learning of government laws but still not enough. Hey! nice picture! Your handsome young man!
• Philippines
2 Jan 11
Hi, Dissemination of laws and ordinances may help one to do such untoward behavior. For knowing such laws may fear one from doing it. Although formal education includes the learning of government laws but still not enough. Hey! nice picture! You're handsome young man!
• United States
25 Dec 10
Well, domestic violence is the result of a lot of things. Even people who have money can be violent people. It has more to do with how you are raised and taught to treat people. I have known many men who were well off and who weren't, both types were abusive, and it all had to do with how they were brought up as children, and what kind of memories they repressed.
• India
4 Jan 11
I completely agree with that. Behavioral conditioning plays a crucial role in all this. Affluence has little to do anything with this. But these people are suffering generation after generation and due to lack of awareness and enlightenment they are clueless about what could be the possible reason for their pain. When the first commit the violence they don't think of anything other than purging his innermost aggression. But then when he realizes what he has done, it gives him a feeling of discomfort and frustration. But he fail to identify the reason once again. So to repress the displeasure he commits more and more violence everyday. This goes on indefinitely.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
28 Dec 10
I actually tend to think that domestic violence is a problem that you could face anywhere in the world. I think that the reason that it occurs is because of the circumstances that people faced when they were children. If people grow up in a household where they experience one parent abusing another parent then they are more likely to carry on that same kind of behavior in their own lives. That said, I don't know that there is really anything that can be done to stop the violence except to have better education.
• India
4 Jan 11
A child who has been subjected to ill-treatment and neglect will develop insensibility and hardened heart in his adulthood. Violence often originates in a similar fashion. When the parents resort to violence in front of their children, the child undergoes a lot of stress. That state of aggression is captured by the child and later in his adulthood there is a high possibility that the child will revert to violence of the same kind. But it doesn't necessarily have to be domestic violence. Disturbed childhood often considered to be a major cause of criminal behavior in late adulthood. Those that have already resorted to violence, can only be stopped by law and awareness. But prevention of its occurrence in future generation can only be ensured by better education.
@megamatt (14292)
• United States
26 Dec 10
There are far too many reasons. The stress of life in general getting to the people the most way. One or more of the people married having grown up in a house that has had domestic violence is another thing as well. I hate to say this, but if someone's parents fought a lot or worse, that is going to have some drastic mental effects on even the most rational minded person and it is just going to lead to bad times all around. Still there are far too many factors and it is just no easy thing to explain.
• India
5 Jan 11
The origin of domestic violence should be traced down in one's behavior. But then the behavior and personality are just the outcome of a bundle of factors. If we single out one of them, we will be unfair to all the others. Sometimes violence is inherited by a child from his parents. Sometimes social pressure plays a vital role. They all sum up to shape this distorted personality trait in adulthood. What's unfortunate is some other person always share the consequences.
@Sanitary (3968)
• Singapore
28 Dec 10
Domestic violence should never be allowed in the first place and women are not there to be beaten up by the man they loved! Woman should stand up for their rights, and they should not suffer in silence. There should be a woman activist in the government sector to protect the rights of women. If not, there's nothing much the government can do when it's all man in there.
• India
4 Jan 11
Women are adequately represented in government here. At least there is this provision. But what can you do when these women themselves put resistance to obeying the law. Most of these women live in rural areas. They neither have proper education or awareness to distinguish right from wrong. There are woman activists, but like you said, there should be more. We need more sincere women to come forward and uphold there right. There are laws to prevent it, but the law enforcing agency may not be active enough. Why should women beg for what is rightful? The only thing that can change the situation for good is better education and better education alone.
1 person likes this
@dibs2010 (132)
• India
25 Dec 10
xactly i dont know about the domestic violation. so sorry for the inconvenience.
• India
4 Jan 11
• India
25 Dec 10
I know a couple of women who are subjected to domestic violence . It is both verbally and physically. But i don't think the root cause is culture , it is indeed a bad upbringing of the male child. In such households the abuser needs to be treated by a good psychiatrist as this is anti social behaviour. We as individuals should try to help the victims of domestic violence.
• India
2 Jan 11
I couldn't agree more. Men need to be educated and aware. What is the use of an education that fails to induce humane feelings in our heart? Women, however need to be aware of their rights as well. You see, this should be a relation of cooperation and affection. Someone may be humiliated in his workplace. But instead of taking out the anger on his spouse, he should seek comfort and assistance in her. Women should also develop knowledge and understanding to be useful in that respect. It seems these societies still have a long way to go.
@greet123 (44)
25 Dec 10
The root of this behaviour lies in people being taught to respect everyone who is elder than them in age. "Whatever elders say, you need to accept and learn and not fight back as that is a mark of disrespect for them.". Uusually in India, parents see to it that husband is older than wife by a few years while marriage.So, wife is always instructed to listen and respect the husband. If husband beats up wife or children, it is said " he is teaching them the right way otherwise they will be spoiled, he is teaching them discipline." Wife also starts believing the same thing and continues the same abusive behaviour with her children. Children also learn it and continue when they start their family. It is hard and will take a lot of awareness and effort to break this abusive cycle. The main problem in this is, the person who is actually illtreating people younger than him is actually using them to let go of his frustration, they are just his dummydolls to let go off his daily stress.
• India
5 Jan 11
You've sited a very important aspect of the issue. However if women start marrying men younger than me violence still remains. Respecting elders is not only appreciated by India but also by most developed countries. But my question is if you don't feel like paying respect why go on acting for years? It is not always the wife who takes up the beatings. The superiority of males is a myth. We seldom analyze it with reasons. The violent behavior, however, is often the outcome of a disturbed childhood, imperfect education and lack of awareness. But have we succeeded in providing ethics through our education? How come the most corrupted bureaucrats are also the most educated?
• United States
30 Dec 10
Well one thing to remember is that anyone male or female can be the aggressor. I for one dont agree or support domestic violence. I have Personally dealt through that, and I have always been the aggresor, unfortunately. Anywho other racial views is , like you said, part of why men in India treat their females like they do. Along with religious views. I don't think that their is a possible way to change the minds of those who are already inttached with those beliefs, unless you preach or confront them about a situation. Even so they will continue if the partner insist on continuing with the relationship. It's kind of like keeping the fire going, you can't burn it out unless you do something about it.
• India
4 Jan 11
Very true. Aggression in human mind is a pretty normal reaction. But different people vent it differently. When one his extremely confused about who is responsible for one's trouble, one starts to take it out on the wrong person. I don't if we can change the persons who already taken it as a legitimate. The only thing that can stop it immediately is the intervention of law enforcers. But we can at least make sure that violent behavior of such kind doesn't become an epidemic in future generations. We should try to impart awareness through education.
@ebuscat (5935)
• Philippines
25 Dec 10
For me if they get unfair of treatment to the customer.
• India
5 Jan 11
• Philippines
25 Dec 10
You are right in saying that our laws seem to be inept in putting a stop to domestic violence against women and children although there are efforts. In part, the problem is cultural since women are expected to stay at home and look after children and do household chores while the husband is considered the breadwinner. Which leads to another cause of domestice violence...dependency of women economically, emotionally, and psychologicall. They don't have income of their own so they depend on the husbands for their most basic needs and that of the children. Women are also hooked on the tradition that since childhood that the role of women is to stick to the husbands no matter what. There are cases where after getting off from a violent marital relationship, they would readily go back when promised of change...although this remains a promise. Sad really. Vomen victims here are educated to the realities of domestic violence and are given psychological care even protection. Small efforts but step nonetheless. Your post show your concern getbiswa. Greetings for the new year.
• India
5 Jan 11
There are a few scientific basis of choosing the right partner for yourself. Having said that, you must have some minimum level of qualification to understand the rules. In rural areas both the parents and their child are completely unaware about these factors. They still make social status, financial stability, caste and creed their basis of judgement. In the process, they overlook certain other factors. While choosing the right person, one should not be overwhelmed by only the conspicuous as that would shift the focus away from minor details. It's the minor details that mainly causes the mismatch and therefore the violence.
@visavis (5934)
• Philippines
25 Dec 10
Actually around the world domestic violence are ramphant and some are isolated. One of cause of such situation couple does not know the real meaning of marriage, family life and true relationship. So that government may put some educational seminar about. see you around
• India
5 Jan 11
You made a very important point here. We need governments to intervene in this matter. Only a prompt judicial system is not enough. We will always have laws to punish offenders. But with effective preventive measure, the number of such cases will significantly reduce. Isn't that what we want? Law deters people from doing wrong things. But in superior environment it's the awareness that makes people choose not to commit crimes. I wish we had such a sensible society.
• United States
25 Dec 10
I believe it also has a lot to do with values and beliefs of a culture. A couple of centuries ago is was 'okay' to 'punish' a wife in Europe and America. The medieval times it was pretty much expected that a man keep his 'wife in line'. Women were treated rarely better than slaves. Times have evolved since then, of course, but there are still some other countries and cultures that belive that the male is the dominant gender and therefore needs to keep control of his household. As for 'fixing it' I think it won't begin to happen until more women in that culture fight against it because they 'believe' that the system is wrong.
• India
2 Jan 11
But in this particular case the women just refused to fight. This is really very strange. The rest of the country has been promoting the empowerment of women, but this state is probably a place outside the country. This state has lowest rate of education. Corruption is still high and there is an absence of sound administration. Surprisingly, this state is the highest provider of minerals to the country. But due to lack of demand the state itself can't consume much of it. I think mere fight is not going to help here. It is the men who needs education and awareness. Our culture or religion don't ask us to disrespect women like that. It's just a peculiar orthodoxy that is ailing the entire society. I am really doubtful about the future of these people.