Miley Cyrus - Okay rolemodel or not?

January 16, 2011 2:38pm CST
She's broken the Disney shackles and children everywhere still look up to her, but from the innocent days of Hannah Montanna we see a more adult progression with her song's and music videos starting from "Can't be Tamed" to "Who Owns My Heart". My question to you, is, are you fine with youth still idolizing her as she changes? Do you hate her? Love her?
4 people like this
10 responses
• United States
16 Jan 11
Nah, I now consider her along the lines of Lindsey Lohan and Britney Spears (
1 person likes this
@stanley777 (9402)
• Philippines
17 Jan 11
Not really... I don't think she is a good role model to children now. Before maybe, yes in her Hannah Montana days, but now she just acts like a rebel and a bit of a flirt. It's because she is making those provocative music videos and also the pictures in the net..
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
Sadly she is not because of all the controversies she is involved with and there are things she did that is not appropriate for age. I think she will be of legal age in a year so i have a feeling she will do something no so wholesome.
• United States
26 Aug 11
you know, i think its one thing looking up to someone and too look her as a role model in everything that she does. Yeah she's broken her image as the good, innocent disney girl.. but that was when she was young. She's growing up,. thats whats life about. she should be able to express herself the way she wants to, not the way she's suppose to like how everyone says.its the parents responsibility to raise their child not the celebrity.
• United States
16 Feb 11
dont going to lie., i've watched her disney shows.lol was funny tooO.., but umm you know i think before she was a better role model then right now, because i think shes 18 now?. but you know she's just doing what teenagers are doing these days. well i guess 18 would consider them adults but still same thing.... you know i think she has changed, but isnt that how its suppose to be.?. she was a role model when she was younger.. but what, does she have to be a role model forever?.. its good for younger kids to look up at there idols but shes not there mother,,. as for the adult progression., shes growing up, its normal. but whats not normal is that kids are following what she's doing, if your a mother you wouldnt let that happen, cause your rasiing that child not her.. then they put the blame on miley, just cause the kids follow her on what her actions are.. thats messes up in my opinion.
• Philippines
16 Feb 11
I've never liked Miley Cyrus herself from the start but I do like some of her songs. They do have something to tell the youth who looks up to her. I just think that she grew up too soon. I just wish she had some kind of a transition before she went all out with Can't Be Tamed. If I was one of her kid fans, I would be shocked about the sudden transformation but despite that, I would think that it's okay to be like that since the one that I look up to does it. I would even think it's cool. If Miley makes her kid fans think like that, she's not a role model. Sad but true.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
16 Jan 11
not so much anymore. maybe she used to be but she looks a little questionable these days.
@_sketch_ (5742)
• United States
19 Jan 11
I have never thought she was a good role model. I wouldn't want my hypothetical children to look up to her, that's for sure. I would rather my kids look up to someone who thinks.
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
16 Jan 11
When Miley cyrus first burst on the scene, i thought that she was a great role model for kids. she seemed to have it all together. With her sudden rocket to came came a few changes. I think she could still be a good role model as long as she keeps her priorities what they should be.
• Philippines
17 Jan 11
I'm sorry for those Miley Cyrus fans but I hate her!!! For me she starting to become too wild.What's happening with her!! It's like a 360 degree personality change. I hope she won't get worse as it is because many little girls would be quite heartbroken and dissappointed with their so called idol.