Plantains (saging na saba) and Sweet Potatoes

plantains - answer to poverty and hunger?
Calgary, Alberta
January 23, 2011 1:54pm CST
I was watching the news replay in the cafeteria and I notice they have a feature about the hunger and poverty in our country. We Filipinos concentrate in one staple...Rice. Unlike Americans with Multiple staple like bread,Potatoes, peas and corn to compliment a dish, We Filipinos wanted rice with everything, as in we even eat hotdogs and burgers in a bed of rice instead of a bun. There is a rice shortage in the Philippines and the price of rice is increasing. The government now is trying to reculture poor families to let go of the rice as a solution to the rice crisis. They want to promote sweet potatoes and Plantains (I'm not calling it a banana because in English language its not a banana, its only a relative of banana ) They think if all poor families have a plantain tree or they planted sweetpotatoes, no one will die in malnutrition and the rice crisis will be solved. In case of families with no backyards, they said that Plantains and sweet potatoes are much cheaper than rice and bread but the nutritional content and health benefits are better. To all Filipinos, Lets say you get to the point that you cant afford to buy rice, can you imagine a life of using Plantains and sweetpotatoes as a staple?
4 people like this
13 responses
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
23 Jan 11
I put saging na saba (plantains) in my pochero. I fry these bananas with brown sugar and stick them in a cue. I mash them with flour as in maruya or roll them in an egg wrapper as in turon. But I don't think I can eat laing or kare-kare in bagoong with plantains. That will take a lot of overhauling the palate.
2 people like this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
23 Jan 11
Point taken!
2 people like this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
can you imagine eating sweet potatoes everyday....
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
I kinda remember "cauli flower rice' its recipe for diebetics who lvoes to eat rice, basically the cauliflower is grated into granules that and it would be placed insdie a pirex class bakewear with a lid. It would be baked in the microwave (no water, no anything) for 5 minutes and it taste exactly with rice but we know Cauli flower is more expensive than rice in our country.... I wodner if we can do that to plantains... We can make french fries and mashed sweet potato out of sweet potato but for sure it will make a person gassy. i also cant imagine my self eating laing or bagoong with plantains. But it may help some hungry and starving families who cant afford rice. I do hope the very poor families will adapt to this because it will fight malnutrition.
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
hello albert, Yes,it is possible. Way back in my childhood days where i grew up. I lived my life for 16 years in Cebu,and mosts of my friends/classmates doesn't eat rice ,instead,they cook grinned corn (some are very fine and some are coarse) same thing how rice was cooked. That is mosts Cebuano's staple food (grinned corn,not rice)some eat plantains and sweet potato. I love grinned corn esp the fine ones,so,during lunch time,i always exchange my rice to grinned corn (to my classmate named Elena)becoz at home we eat rice (my grandfather doesn't like grinned corn since he was used to eat rice,as he is a native of La Union,a place in Northern Luzon where rice is the main product) So,if ever this rice shortage will get worst to worst case,why not eat plantains and sweet potato,it is also much beneficial to health.
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
it taste like rice,but for me it tastes better (maybe becoz i love corn so much ) it taste a bit sweet (recalling my memory)yes,i just loved it and now i missed it. i wonder if i can buy those coarse corn from chicken feeds stalls and cooked like rice (me and my naughty senses again whoaaaa) kidding aside,it looks like those ones...(but the price is also high huh... let me check on that,or maybe i can asks my Cebuano friends about it (coarse corn from chicken feed stalls) well,we Filipinos knows how to adjusts our living (lifestyle) i am sure we can overcome these things.(with big smiles in our face )
2 people like this
@topffer (42156)
• France
24 Jan 11
Hi jaiho : chicken are not eating the same corn than humans. The corn for humans is called here "sweet" corn, because, as you said it is sweet. But you can try to make some popcorn with corns for animals. And be careful : don't eat a genetically modified corn.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
I'm not sure if grated corn is cheaper or more expensive than rice but that is an interesting staple. makes me want to try that Cebuano staple. does it taste like rice? The government seemed to be eager to diversify the Filipino staple since every Filipino have the mindset that rice is the only nourishing staple (It kinda cause diabetes right?) I heard the rise crisis might really get worse and some Filipinos needs to adapt to other staples, Its going to be hard for sure but its for everybody's good.
1 person likes this
@anne25penn (3305)
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
Your discussion reminded me of a documentary featured in the History channel "When Food Runs Out". Here they tackled the possible food shortage because right now people are centered on three basic staples worldwide; that is rice, wheat and corn. What is disturbing is that our country was featured in the near future where farmers are getting violent because the rice is being hoarded. We used to be a country with bountiful rice fields. We never had a problem with crops before. But the problem that I see right now is that there is no farmers, nor fertile land to be planted. I went up north last week, and what used to be a sea of green (rice or corn) are now bulldozed lands being readied for large subdivisions. Land owners who used to grow crops are selling their lands to developers because they get to earn more and just move away. We do have an abundance of sweet potatoes and plantains. When we had a rice shortage two or three years ago, I switched to pasta and oats as a substitute for rice. But that was when we did not have a maid. With the looming rice crisis, I will have to look for other alternative means. But our poor kababayans should also learn to adapt. We are a country blessed with fertile soil for growing crops. People are just not taking advantage of that.
2 people like this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
I know the over population is the reason we suffer with food shortage and running out of rice field is the biggest side effects. because of the need for housing rice fields where turned into residential areas. I think with the small amount of land in out country people should be living in condo units. I'm sure many people dont like the idea of having plantains and sweet potatoes as staple so maybe making flours and breads out of them can make cheap but nutritious breads. If the government can teach the poor families to appreciate these alternatives to rice then we can finally end hunger and malnourished children will be much healthier. They should have learn that rice is not the only staple they can eat.
@jwfarrimond (4473)
23 Jan 11
Reliance on one staple food is never a good thing as the Irish found out in the 19th century. At that time the staple food of the Irish was the potato but the crop became diseased with the potato blight and as a result there was famine resulting in the deaths of thousands and the migration of many more thousands to America and other places. Of course, the Irish blame the English for the bight, but then, they blame us for everything. (shrugs) It's a good idea for your government to try and get people to diversify their staple crop growing but I'm not sure that it'll be successful - people, especially farmers, get pretty set in their ways and are very reluctant to change.
2 people like this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
there is a shortage because most farmers sold their ricefields and ricefields were turned into housing projects and malls. there are only few rice farmers left in a country that relies too much on rice as staple. So yeah the situation here is kinda like the potato shortage of Ireland that you just shared. I do hope it would work. Sweet potatoes and plantains are easy to raise and they were very nutritious, it would really help the poor families who can afford rice.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
I mean cant not can afford rice (why do I always make typos T_T)
1 person likes this
@Opal26 (17679)
• United States
24 Jan 11
Hi Capt! I know you are asking Filipinos this question, but I hope you don't mind your pal Opal sticking her 1/2 cent in! Sweet Potatoes are delicious and happen to be nutricious and I am by no means a person who eats "correctly"! And I also happen to like Plantains too and I believe that they are also quite good for you. And combined with rice they would be quite tasty! The price of food here in the USA has gone totally out of control too. Actually, the price of everything has gone out of control here and it is very difficult to live here. We have alot of homeless and near homeless people. I, myself have my own financial issues, but we all must eat. Try adding the sweet potatoes and plantains mixed with the rice just so that you can stretch the rice a little further.
2 people like this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
Filipinos usually eat this way: We have plain rice and we will pair it with a certain dish, lets say grilled fish or maybe vegetable stir fry, We dont season the rice, we want it to be as neutral as it can be so it can adapt to the this. I think it would be a challenge for poor families to try adapting to Plantains and sweet potatoes, but if the government can teach them how to make them delicious it could be easy. The leaves of sweet potatoes were usually steamed here, Its one of the famous vegetable greens here. I know USA have a more diverse staple compared to Filipinos. We have many delicious dishes but all of them were dependent to simple plain rice or tasty fried rice.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
23 Jan 11
Every now and then I would join a friend or a cousin in their advocacies and live with a community for some time. We eat what they eat and most of the time its sweet potatoes during non-harvest seasons. It's okay, I think they just have a bad reputation and we associate them with poverty and so we turn our noses up at them but they can be quite filling. Some of the people there tell me that the reason I don't mind is that because I know that when I leave the place I can have rice. I think that may true because even though I don't mind eating them, my palate still looks for the taste of rice. But I know that if pushed, I am perfectly willing to eat the substitutes.
2 people like this
• Calgary, Alberta
23 Jan 11
I heard plantains and sweet potatoes can be turned into flour that is cheaper and more healthy bread. i think next to rice, Filipinos were able to to endure with bread, But yeah its hard to live without rice if you are Filipino. We dont feel full and satisfied without the rice. dependence in one staple is said to be one of the main cause of hunger in our country. if people have more choice of staple, there will be less hungry people. Lets say the Mexicans have more staples than us, They have rice,corn, tortilla bread, taco shell and beans. They have more options for staples.
1 person likes this
@SimpleBB (1329)
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
Actually as I observed it, we just got used of eating rice. But once we tried to divert having other carbo sustainance, our system will get used to it. Just like those people who are dieting to have good health benefits, they succeeded in having alternative to rice. Actually, personally, I used to have rice for lunch and dinner, but now that I know I need to be concern with my health, I usually takes quaker oats for dinner and I think I'm getting used to it, for everytime I try to have rice for dinner, I feel that I'm full and could no longer take it. I know for eventually I could attain my target goal of taking rice only during lunch. I'm not saying to totally avoid rice, but there are lots of alternatives that offer better nutrient content than rice.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
25 Jan 11
I think it would be a hard transition but I do hope the very poor families should consider this because its affordable and has more nutrition than rice can offer.I do think Filipinos needs to learn to have alternate staples because if we all rely on rice this shortage and crisis will effect more people.
@topffer (42156)
• France
24 Jan 11
Hello Captain, Your plantains are called plantain bananas in Europe. Plantain is here the common name for some herbaceous plants -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plantago --. Some of them are eatable in sauerkraut or salads : as somebody said in this discussion, a man can eat herbs when he is hungry... We need to have various food for vitamins and minerals. If these two are easily produced in your country, it is good for your agriculture. You can eat cereals only everyday -- rice, sweet corn, or in flours --, but vegetables are not a so good source of calories... Potatoes were introduced in Europe in the XVIIIth C against famine, but it would be an horrible food if you had only them to eat, even if "hunger is the best sauce". I think it is why there is not only one staple food here -- though bread has been one during famine here, but it is a cereal based food --.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
i think the government is suggesting tot he families who cant afford rice to eat plantains and sweetpotatoes instead of rice to replace rice as a partner to their favorite dishes. We dont eat rice alone, yes Filipinos want it plain because we pair it with a dish. I think corn is expensive here. I do hope people who cant afford rice will resort to this.
1 person likes this
@mspitot (3824)
• Philippines
13 Jul 11
I think that is good but i don't think people will embraced that fast cause rice is really delicious (I admit it cause I have gain weight because of rice) to eat and that a meal doesn't seem to be satisfying if it is not a rice meal. Maybe planning the menu for a week with a combination of rice meals and those alternatives that you said will do. Corn has been used as a substitute to rice. They pound corns until they become small but a bit bigger than rice and then cooked the same way like rice.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
28 Jun 12
It had to be introduced to poor families though, they will die of hunger if they kept on relying on rice. Rice is not really delicious, its tasteless and bland, We just get used to it's texture cos our parents forced feed us to eat it when we were kids. New staples can be introduced to the kids of families below poverty line.
@r4v3n_ (178)
• United States
24 Jan 11
Yes you are right about that. They wont be hungry if they will just plant crops in the province. I just don't know why they always wanted to live in the city or in urban areas where they will just stay on the streets asking and begging for money to other people.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
For sure they also need to learn how to be dependent with rice, I remember family who just wait to die because they cant afford rice, I think they might have saved a lot of money if they use sweet potatoes and plantains instead.
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
Oh i learned a new word today, plantain. Of course when worse comes to worse, every one will learn how to eat those mentioned foods. Beggars cannot be choosers , remember? The only thing that deters Filipinos to eat those as staple food is because we still have rice that can be bought. But given the worst scenario, no one would want to be hungry , so they should just be contented with what is available. I am sure of that.
1 person likes this
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Jan 11
Plantain is actually a staple in South America, The Caribbean and Africa. They were able to make a Plantain mash, Plantain bread, fried plantain and steaming plantain as their "rice" to compliment their meals. People below the poverty line can be the ones to benefit first with this breakthrough against hunger,
• Philippines
24 Jan 11
Yeah, this is the problem in our country. This is because of poor management of our agriculture industry and the lack of modernization of our farms. As for me, there is no problem if I eat potato or banana every single day. As long as its edible (and not ampalaya) then it is fine by me.
• Calgary, Alberta
28 Jun 12
indeed, our country is focusing on the wrong stuff.
• Calgary, Alberta
25 Jan 11
I think our country should be focusing in agriculture but damn our government is forcing out country to be industrial, factories, quarry and mining is bad for nature, we have a small country and we should focus in Agriculture because we have the right climate.
• Philippines
25 Jan 11
You are correct Albert. This is a sad fact. Our government have the wrong focus that's why we are suffering food shortage.
1 person likes this
@lokisdad (4226)
• United States
5 Jan 16
Its brutal when things like that happen. Unfortunately there isn't much choice but to adapt. On the bright side it will open up a whole new variety of recipes for the menu.
• Calgary, Alberta
5 Jan 16
Thanks for reviving this thread, It reminds me of my golden days in this place when I am still popular. It has been years since I posted this but sadly this project seemed to be a failure. Filipino families are still dependent to rice.
1 person likes this
@lokisdad (4226)
• United States
5 Jan 16
@CaptAlbertWhisker I just now realized how old this post is. Lol I don't really look at the dates or things like that most times I try to keep my interactions random so that they are fair no favoritism just selecting random users and browsing their post and selecting one randomly. I am sorry to hear that they didn't adapt to the new idea for staple foods in their diet. I am glad to have revived your post I know how they can get buried and forgotten.