Was it ever love if it didn't last?

United States
January 24, 2011 11:10pm CST
I've battled with this question for a while and have my own thoughts on it... but what about yours? Do you think it's possible to HAVE loved someone, but don't now? Or was it ever really "true" love, if it isn't forever? Can you stop loving a person once you've decided to start?
3 responses
@katcarneo (1433)
• Philippines
25 Jan 11
I had this discussion with a friend who insisted that I haven't loved yet since, supposedly, love never fails. I have had only few but long relationships in my life. How can one say those relationships that lasted a minimum of three years were not true? Sure it's great when we hang on to the idea that true love is endless, but just because love has ceased and a relationship has ended, that doesn't make it any less real. I actually get annoyed when people give me definitions of what love's supposed to be. What I do is enjoy the moment of my loving someone and not try to define it.
• United States
28 Jan 11
I agree. It wouldn't have lasted three years if there hadn't been at least some kind of strong love involved. I've never had a long relationship, and am actually in my first "real" relationship at the moment, so unfortunately I can't even really answer my own question from the personal level that I would like to be able to answer if from. I guess that's why I asked the question in the first place- to get the opinions of other people that actually have something to say on the subject.
• Philippines
25 Jan 11
hi there. yes. there must have been a reason why your love for that person ceased, and that could come to variety of reasons. both partners might have worked hard for their love's sake but there might have been strong factors that just kept on moving around them that did not make their relationship work no matter how hard they tried to fight for it. most people tend to just give up, because it's an option for them. i do not believe that when you loved someone deeply before, and ended your relationship with him/her because of that reasonable factors, you cannot love him/her anymore in the future. you can still love that person despite of what you have had together in the past time. it's best not to put it to waste. you can love that person as a friend. On the other hand, if the relationship did not end properly (like for example due to some inconsiderable reason, 3rd party, cheating, abuse, etc.), people may tend to hold on to their grudges and could turn love to hatred. that's possible, it greatly depends on the situation. see you around!
• United States
26 Jan 11
That makes sense. I think if it ended badly then that strong emotion can turn another way... I completely agree. I feel for those people that I've loved, and it ended badly, I now hate... but for the ones that I loved but just ended peacefully, there's still an emotional attachment. Though, this still begs the question of whether or not I can call this love, I guess. Thanks for your response!
@franne32 (694)
• Philippines
25 Jan 11
It's not the true romantic love you longed for if it did not last forever. It is still love but not the kind that's meant to last. I can stop loving a person if something happened between us that made our relationship unbearable.
• United States
28 Jan 11
Yeah, that's generally how I tend to look at it. I feel like, unless you've been with someone for a very long time, few people have anything to compare loves to because if they've broken up with people they can't really say that they've had that lasting love.