Are mental disorders actually disease?

United States
May 25, 2011 12:11pm CST
Most the people I have talked to see mental illness in a lesser light than they do diabetes,cancer, even aids. I decided to do a little research and see for myself. They have many of the same characteristics. Most forms are genetic most can be easily managed with medications. What do you think? Besides aids, the patient had no choice but to be mentally ill. Had about as much of a choice in the matter as a diabetic does. Alot of mentally ill patients are treated with prejudice when actually they have no choice in the matter. What do you think? How could we recognize the ones close to us that are struggling? Can we see a pattern of behavior in them that dictates they may have a mental illness?
1 person likes this
7 responses
@RamRes (1723)
• Argentina
29 May 11
They are diseases like every other in the world. The fact that it has different symptoms and effects don't make them less important or harmful to the patient or his environment. Mental diseases have also the same specification of symptoms, causes, and possible treatments, just like every other illness. Also, the OMS has an ample catalog of all mental illnesses, just marked as..... illnesses. One NEVER makes a choice for being ill or not being ill. It's something that happens without one noticing or knowing the initial factor, mental or physical. Also it's important to be fully aware that mental or not, a disease is just as harmful that has to be treated in some way or another, and some people judging if it's not even a disease just makes the life even harder for the patient.
@RamRes (1723)
• Argentina
29 May 11
Of course there is a lot. And not only prejudice, but also many are totally unknown, by most part of the society and some doctors too, so they fail to be diagnosed early and end being most problematic than they have to, due to incorrect treatment or no treatment at all.
• United States
30 May 11
well , do you think there is a way we can screen for this though? Like maybe MMPI in high school or something like general testing. We test for TB and other stuff like that. What do you think?
• United States
29 May 11
Do you think there is alot of prejudice towards the mentally ill?
@bdance22 (86)
• Philippines
25 May 11
This is going to be a hard one. In my opinion its not a disease. Behavior is something that people acquire due to the pressures of the environment around an individual. Its true that some people might pass on a genetic trait that will make a person have more inclination of having the disorder but its still the behavior of the person that will dictate their mental health. It will be hard for regular people like us to identify if a person has symptoms of mental disorder because simple things that might look odd for Us are already major factors that a learn doctor might consider as something contributing to a persons mental health. just my two cents
@Mickie30 (2626)
25 May 11
You are an ignorant person that has no idea. If only you would experience mental illness and have it yourself. What goes around comes around and one day you will get yours.
• United States
26 May 11
First, mickie , thanks for responding , but everyone has the right to their opinion. If they are mentally ill and it is a behavioral disorder, then wouldn't their behavior be affected. So there fore, if there behavior pattern is being affected by something genetic, they should have control??? But wait!! Plus we don't know who is having problems or not? This path of thinking is why people claim crazy when they do not wanna go to jail. In today's society of email and TV, and texting no wonder. You wanna know if someone is having mental issues just talk to them. Can they hold a job? do they get emotional easy? do they tend to talk to people who is not there? Just pay attention, know the signs, and you will be able to observe that part. Now i am sorry though a schizophrenic has no choice but to be schizophrenic.
@Mickie30 (2626)
25 May 11
I have Schizoid Affective Disorder and it is something that I have not chosen, nor would I choose it. I hate the prejudice people give when you tell them. My children are what makes my life so special. I also love my husband who has been there for me through thick and thin. It's not a behaviour like someone said. That hurts actually. I have to take strong medication every day and if I do not take it then I cannot be a good mum to my kids. My kids need me to be well and with my medication I only have a few problems. My husband and my mum knows when I am not feeling well because I start to experience mood swings and am more stressed. I get more sensitive and moody. I see things that are not there and hear voices. I had a troubled past and was abused as a young child. I was bullied and very sensitive to others. I have faced a lot of prejudice over my illness. I do not work and my husband cares for me so we have faced prejudice over that. People think we should work, but I cannot cope well with stress and we have 2 kids. I know people will judge me for having kids, but I give them all the love I can and more.
• United States
26 May 11
have you found groups or people you can talk to about this??? Are the medications helping??? Do you fell sometimes like your okay and do not need the medication? Has your medications had to go up alot since you started them. Do you feel like they have found the right combination?
@maximax8 (31053)
• United Kingdom
25 May 11
I believe most people see mental illness in a lesser light that they do a serious medical illness like cancer. Aids and cancer and the worst sort of illnesses. No person can get rid of HIV which causes Aids. However treatment can be given to some cancer patients and make them much better. A mentally ill person didn't choose to have that disability. I feel sorry for diabetic people and that illness must be quite scary. It is a shame when a mentally ill person is treated with prejudice. Many forms of mental illness are genetic because certain disorders run down the family line. I have seen the highs and the lows from a person that has bipolar disorder. That was the person's pattern of behavior.
• United States
26 May 11
Exactly what i was looking for. This is exactly what i am talking about. More money goes into aids research and cancer research than anything else. But look at the crazy stuff that goes on in the world . Notice how there are alot of people going "postal"??/ Colombine, and many many more examples of this stuff is popping up on a daily basis. Now you mention bipolar disorder, which is common in people, and yet you never hear about it. What do you think can be done to help this situation?
@mrgpk63 (444)
• United States
26 May 11
Yes they are a Disease and be Treated by a Psychiatrist. Who has to go to Medical School to become an M.D. It is in the Brain and Depression maybe caused by Chemical Imbalance. You can have many other Disorders that can be Controlled by Medication. You just Notice a Change in Mood and Behavior. You may not Share Normal Views on Life Compared to other Normal People. You may not have a Steady Job or Social Life. You can feel Physically Sick to from many Mental Illnesses to.
• United States
26 May 11
Ha! Excellent point. The mental disorders do affect the body. Just like a disease. Great point! Also chemical imbalance means the actual physical nature of the brain has been altered by it. That's sounds like disease to me! I seen alot of interesting points in this discussion, for both sides but this is on the money. What if the person has gotten good at hiding his symptoms? What other ways can you tell?
• Philippines
26 May 11
For me, Mental illness is not a disease because it doesn't meet the established scientific criterion for disease, namely, a derangement n the structure or function of cells, tissue, and organs. MEntal illness can neither be detected nor diagnosed by examining cells, tissues or organs. Instead, they are identified by certain behaviors, and what concerns others is not the theoretical question of what countsas a disease, but the practical problems posed by these behaviors.
• Israel
29 Mar 12
You are misinformed. The brain and brain wave patterns are different in many mentally ill people. You can't examine the brain of a living person, but autopsies of deceased persons clearly shows that the brain is different. Some illnesses sow up in cat scans. The brain fires differently than it should.
• United States
26 May 11
If a mental disorder is genetic, it is in your DNA. if it causes an abnormalty, is it not a corruption of the brain cells and pattern waves in the brain. There , by your definition, be the same?
@2004cqui (2812)
• United States
29 Feb 12
Only the person who may have a mental illness and a psychiatrist will know for sure. Lay people can only be kind, understanding and patient, or get out of the way.