Is age discrimination ever okay?
By mommyboo
@mommyboo (13174)
United States
July 15, 2011 9:12pm CST
In light of the whole 'banning kids from establishments' issue, do you agree that this is potential AGE DISCRIMINATION? Isn't that illegal? I'd like to ask here how people would react if an establishment perhaps decided to ban senior citizens... as a group. What if they banned women? What if they banned men? What if a place decided to ban certain races? As you can see, this could be a big hairy can of poop, couldn't it??
Banning children (regardless of behavior) is the SAME damn thing! If you want to ban something or someone, you need a reason other than AGE. Making assumptions based on someone's age is irrelevant and rude - ie ASSUMING that because someone is five years old they are going to be a holy terror and disrupt people or have a tantrum.
4 people like this
10 responses
@phyrre (2317)
• United States
16 Jul 11
I'm afraid I have to disagree with your point of view. Banning children is completely different from banning based on any other factors. The fact is that children largely misbehave or act undesirably. You can try to argue with it any way you want or look at it however you'd like, but by and large that's what it boils down to. Children are disruptive. If an adult is at a 5 star restaurant and starts being disruptive do you expect them to be escorted out or even banned from the establishment? Of course.
Besides, these places are businesses. People need to face the fact that businesses cater to a niche and I'm sorry but not everyone who goes out to dine wants to listen to your baby scream or your toddler pitch a fit or whatever it may be. I have a little girl and she's the greatest thing in my world but if I get someone to watch her to have a night out with my husband I don't really want to hear someone else's baby screaming while I'm eating either. The places that are banning children are clearly targeting this particular niche, meaning adults. They are not family restaurants. You want a family restaurant, go to one. But where are the people who DON'T want a family restaurant supposed to go?
Do you think it's weird that children aren't allowed in bars? Of course not because the niche they fill is people who are old enough to drink and like to drink. Is that age discrimination? Should we start taking our babies and toddlers into bars with us?
As a parent, I know that there are some places I won't be dining at when we're out with my daughter. We specifically look for family friendly places. Obviously I'm not going to go to a five star restaurant where I know my child will be disruptive and frowned upon if she starts fussing (and face it, as a baby she's quite likely to fuss at some point). What sense does it make to get mad about? I'm just going to go to a restaurant that's more geared towards it. Just like if I wanted books I wouldn't go to a shoe store. If I want a family dining experience I'm going to a place that offers such and I do expect that there will be places where it's just not appropriate to bring your child.
3 people like this

@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
18 Jul 11
YES! And people need to realize this. I've often said these people who feel they are 'better' or 'more important' than children ought to be grateful that they were cared for and allowed to grow up into the uptight stuffy obnoxious adults they are and should really consider how much NOT BETTER and LESS IMPORTANT they are for their views when 30, 40, 50 years ago they may just have been banning themselves.
When I was younger I said I would write a book about all the things I considered unfair to kids - well I never wrote a book but I did still remember some of those things and I incorporate the ones that make sense and have not repeated those errors in raising my daughter lol. I do try to make things fair - doesn't mean EQUAL always - but fair.
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
17 Jul 11
I really don't know about the legalities of it. I do think that estabishments have the right to set certain standards of behavior and even dress codes if that is what they want to do. I agree that in bars that children should be banned but I know that isn't enforced everywhere. In my opinion it is a poor business move at the very least. It just sounds unfriendly. It doesn't even make sense because from what I'm hearing, it is that they are banning kids ages 6 and under. There are older kids that act out just as much as some of the younger ones and as you pointed out, not all kids would act out. Kids need to learn how to act in a public place and it is not easy to teach them these things in a burger king or chucky cheese where yes, it's kid friendly but chock full of kids running about and acting like, well, kids. I think a more fair way to handle it would be to post a sign saying that out of courtesy for the other patrons who are they to enjoy a quiet meal, loud and unruly behavior will not be accepted and the party will be asked to leave. This will cover them for all ages of bad behavior including the adults.
1 person likes this

@sid556 (30953)
• United States
18 Jul 11
I agree. Appelbees and whatnot tend to be more in my price range anyway. Still I remember when my girls were small how very much they loved the occasional "special night out's" we'd have where we'd go to a classier restaraunt. It made them feel all grown up and special. Great memories. They also KNEW that if they acted up that we would leave and it'd be a while before we went again.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
18 Jul 11
Well, it certainly put them into the spotlight via social sites and caused people everywhere to discuss it, just like the issue of whether morbidly obese children should be seized and removed from their parents. Sometimes I really wonder how much dumber people are going to get as time goes on.
I think it is a poor business move too, because while if I choose to go to an upscale place for a date, I may go late to avoid crowds, I'm just not sure about giving my business to a place (no matter how nice the environment and excellent the food) if they frown on children. I am a parent and that kind of disgusts me. I am quite creative at finding ways to avoid encountering screaming brats without giving ultimatums about where children are allowed to be.
It's also true that it's nearly impossible to teach kids about proper manners in a public place when the only place you take them is chuck e cheese and mcdonalds. Practically the whole place is a kids play area and kids are allowed to run around and yell. If they were sitting there quietly just eating, you would think something was wrong with them lol. I generally go to places like Applebees, Chilis, Red Robin, as well as typical fast food places and despite all the people who claim small kids crawl under the table, tear through the restaurant, scream and cry, run into other patrons, grab things off other people's tables - no kids with me have ever done that and I've had kids for quite a few years and we've been out to eat LOTS at a variety of different places. Sometimes they talk a lot and drop things on the floor and squirm and get restless but the person most disturbed would be me since I'm sitting with them. They don't climb over the booth or knock chairs over or even talk to other people unless I see someone I know lol.
I think it would be much more acceptable to issue a warning about behavior which applies to EVERY PATRON, and I would like to see it enforced when an adult has a tantrum. People are SO quick to lampoon children and make a big deal out of a child who is having a bad moment but often overlook adults with deplorable behavior. I think it's time the playing field is leveled.

@p1kef1sh (45681)
•
16 Jul 11
I suppose that this is really a test of appropriateness. You can buy child-free holidays which I think is fair enough as it is clear from the outset what is on offer. I think that cinemas showing adult rated movies should be child free. My view is that why do we want children in places to start with? Most of the child free places that I can think of are not the sorts of venues that children would want to visit anyway. Rather it is their parents that want the convenience of not having to either not visit or find child-minding cover. I imaging that it becomes a law of averages. If in the experience of the owner children are mostly disruptive, then whilst it's hard on those that are not, why should they expose their business to the risk of a loss of revenue caused by others staying away rather than suffer small children. Age discrimination in law is a difficult thing in the US. Federally it doesn't apply under the age of 40! But clearly it applies at much younger ages in individual states. I suspect that nowehere legislates age discrimination in the pre-teen group though.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
17 Jul 11
I agree with you in a way about the movies - and some theaters post signs which state 'children under 6' (or something similar) are not allowed after 9 pm or something like that. I DO actually agree with that - in an adult rated movie, ie R, etc. I really cannot see any reason why an adult or couple would need to see an R rated movie after 9 or 10 pm with small children along. The later showings are also when adults typically go to a movie and want to be child free. I don't typically have any issue with young kids being in the movies (regardless of rating) earlier in the day, but if you think about it, people don't generally have a date night in the middle of the day anyway, it makes little sense to ban them at that time. Plus, the theaters are making money in the form of ticket sales...
Again, I would have little to no problem with the establishment in question (restaurant) stating 'no minors after 7 pm' or 8 pm, or whatever. I just disagree with an all-out all-hours ban.
There are some entertainment places here in the US where teens are not allowed out or there after a certain time without adult supervision, some of those I actually agree with more than young kids, especially if the teens in question have defaced property, snuck in without paying, etc. I think if a parent buys movie tickets for them though and accompanies them inside or at least to the ticket taker, they shouldn't be required to buy a ticket and watch the movie too... just letting the theater know they have no issue with their kid seeing the movie should be enough.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
18 Jul 11
I don't have a problem with not allowing teenagers in bars because of the drinking thing. Of course we only have THAT because we have a 'legal drinking age' of 21 and if that were not the case, there would be no reason to ban teens from bars.
As far as movies and carding people, I took my brother to a movie before a long time ago - and keep in mind my brother is 11 years younger than me. I GOT CARDED WHEN I BOUGHT THE TICKETS. He didn't. I was slightly irritated. I think I was 26...? As such, he IS about a foot taller than me and had a goatee or something - but it still didn't make a heck of a lot of sense. How many people under 18 use a card to buy movie tickets? 

@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
17 Jul 11
You have a very good point here. If there is going to be a ban..it should be based on bahavior and not age. I think they thought they might get out of confrontation to just go ahead and ban them all...but it is illegal to descriminate. I wonder how long this law will last?
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
18 Jul 11
I thought it was illegal too to do this, but a lot of people are claiming that business owners have the right to enforce whatever they want. I will say though that if any places around here put up a rule like that or try to enforce it - EVEN IF I WOULD HAVE NEVER BROUGHT MY CHILD IN YOUR ESTABLISHMENT - I will not shop there, eat there, or otherwise give you one red cent. For me it's the principle of the thing, even if it's not designed to be kid-friendly.
I have been to plenty of nicer places on dates with my husband without any of our kids and had a very enjoyable evening - we generally go out later on dates so the places are not so full and either we don't have to wait at all or it's easier to get reservations. We've sometimes seen families out having dinner and I like seeing families. These days there seems to be a pretty clear cut line between families and non families, and a lot of families are NOT going out together any more, which is sad. I don't know whether it's the expense or whether their kids act up or what. Either way, there are ways to avoid 'crazy hour' in restaurants just like avoiding 'rush hour' on the freeway - just don't go out at the typical times many people have dinner.
@4mymak (1793)
• Malaysia
20 Jul 11
i read that news about a restaurant banning children..
to be honest, i think the restaurant management has their marketing strategy all wrong.. why cant they instead accomodate for children at their place - they could easily be a hit with a bigger market - i know that eateries that would cater for small kidz in my country (play corners, kids menu) will always be full during weekends.. because families + small children would love to eat together...
and yes.. it is ridiculous to ban the children just because of their age group, even the adults do not all have good manners, true? my 7-year old daughter behaves very well in restaurants - or wherever.. , as to compared to some teenagers sometimes.. who sometimes can be pretty rowdy, rude + noisy.. why not ban them ??
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
16 Jul 11
oh mommy boo that sounds awful but have you not been in your favorite cafe and had kids run up to you , grab a spoon and taste your food,or come up and make faces or loud noises when you were just looking to enjoy a nice quiet meal out. Kids a lot of times do misbehave and cause a lot of diners to wish they would just leave. Age discrimination and banning kids who tear up the cafe and irritate and annoy diners are two separate issues. as for senior citizens thats wrong for sure, Unless we are nuts and do disrupt some store I cannot see anything wrong with elderly people but i have been the victim of lax parents who do not train kids to behave in cafes making holy nuisances of themselves. I have never seen a senior citizen and I am one walk over and calmly taste your food or stand and look over the seat next to you and make faces at you. we come to restaurants to enjoy our food not to be besieged by little brats.so yes ban bratty kids and if they have been holy terrors once do not allow them back in your establishment.this should be case by case though.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
17 Jul 11
I feel like I am repeating the same thing till I'm blue in the face - I ABSOLUTELY agree that children who act like brats or are not being controlled by their parents should definitely be asked to leave! HOWEVER. That does NOT mean it is EVER okay to BAN ALL CHILDREN based on the bad behavior of SOME. If some random stranger actually groaned or made a face or acted in a rude manner because I walked by him or her with my daughter, I would want to smack the person... keep in mind we are just WALKING BY. Nothing more. In my opinion, people like THAT shouldn't be allowed to leave their homes lol.
I've been disturbed before by kids that are crying or making noise, but I have never had some kid grab food or silverware or anything off my table. I really try to be understanding of other people with kids because *I* have kids and as such I understand that kids are not perfect lol.
I am totally for any establishment asking disruptive patrons to leave - of ANY age, but I ask that they actually show just cause to ask someone to leave. A restaurant would not just ask someone to leave for no reason, and I feel banning a certain age group fits into the same category - no reason.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
19 Jul 11
I couldn't begin to agree with you more. When I heard the story about banning children from a restaurant I was instantly enraged. Okay, if you don't want children in your establishment, make it a bar instead of a restaurant because everyone knows that children are not allowed in bars. As far as saying that children cannot be in a restaurant is wrong. I've taken my children to restaurants from the time that they were born and they know how to behave in a restaurant. If children never have the opportunity to visit a restaurant then they will never have the opportunity to learn how to behave in a restaurant.
@caterinasmile8 (153)
•
17 Jul 11
This is clearly wrong. Often older people have more experience, more nounce and are more likely to stay in work positions for a duration until reterement age as younger people often want to get a rung on the ladder before moving on. My mum for example has found it very difficult to find work since leaving her lecturing job, and has been doing an accounting course since then but not found any work n the field.






