chemistry is killing me..

Philippines
October 16, 2011 12:09am CST
hi.. i have this assignment at school. our teacher is asking "is FIRE MATTER? I've been thinking about it I guess for almost a day now and I can't seem find the answer. Matter in my own understanding is it occupies space and has a mass.. right? So if fire matter? respond pls.......
3 people like this
14 responses
@vasumathi (436)
• India
16 Oct 11
Definetly a thinkable question .. I am looking for the answer
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
thanks for the response. I hope you can find the answer. hehe It's just to difficult for me..
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
The question got me thinking, too. It is quite a tricky one. One that makes the brain work somehow. It is good that I still remember the definition of what matter is. I wonder if your teacher is one who knows how to make her students think and use reason at all times. If this is so, she is a very good one.
@boyuancy (1708)
• India
16 Oct 11
WOW!!!! Cheers to your teacher for such an amazing question, have never thought about it. Fire comes from burning matter. My best guess would be: When you heat particles they atoms and molecules get excited. For them to return to their normal state they have to expel energy which they do in the form of Heat and Light which we percieve as 'Fire'. So not Fire is not matter but it is Energy. Whereas the 'flame' that is we see is hot glowing gases. So it is matter. Look up 'Fire' in wikipedia and you'll know what I'm saying. Hope this helps.
1 person likes this
@manleyjoe (1597)
• United States
16 Oct 11
Isn't gas matter? I'm am confused. If it is then fire, which is burning gas would also be Matter.
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
For a thing to fall under the category under matter, just remember that anything that occupies space and has weight is matter. You have also caught me there offguard. Definitely fire occupies space. As for the weight, I am tempted to say yes. I have never encountered any attempt by any person yet regarding trying to determine if fire has weight. Now, let us think about it. There is humidity in fire. There must be weight to it. Therefore, it is safe to conclude that fire is matter.
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
mmm yes you are right about the definition of matter.. thanks for giving me another idea. But there's a difference between mass and weight right? Sometimes people do use this terms interchangeably..
• Australia
16 Oct 11
I would think you could argue that fire is matter, but heat is energy. Lash
1 person likes this
@DoctorDidi (7018)
• India
16 Oct 11
Matter is anything which has a mass and which occupies a space that is has a volume. In this 'image' is not a matter and so fire is also not a matter.
1 person likes this
• China
16 Oct 11
I am sorry I can't understand you.What are you talking about?Could you please explain it clearerly?
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
Our topic at school in our chemistry subject is about matter, and our professor asked us if FIRE is considered as matter.. that's it..
• China
16 Oct 11
Of course not!Fire is a phenomenon.Matter should content elements.
@manleyjoe (1597)
• United States
16 Oct 11
Hmmmm, this is very interesting. Of all these responses you still do not have the answer do you? The good one above is the one that talks of making us think, We, as a society do so very little of this anymore it is good to see that maybe there is hope after all. I have no idea as to your original question but am glad that you were not given the answer so that you will have put the ol brain in gear and use it.
@stealthy (8181)
• United States
16 Oct 11
It can get a little iffy depending on how it is looked at. But fire is usually a chemical reaction between two or more elements, which are matter, such as hydrogen atoms and oxygen atoms to get very basic or some carbon based material like wood that has been heated to a high enough temperature for a reaction to occur with other elements present. So on a very basic level, it seems that it could be considered to be matter since it also leaves another form of matter when it burns out such as ashes and gases released. I'm sure this can be put more elegantly.
@thatgirl13 (7294)
• South Korea
17 Oct 11
Wow a real confusing one. I hope you come back here and tell me the correct answer when you know. I was really lousy in science and hated that subject
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
yes it is indeed a matter. Fire is matter. It is not a solid, not a liquid, but a gas. Fire contains gas molecules. It does occupies space and has a mass. But its mass is not that of a solid object, but a mass of a gas.
@Vrilya (128)
16 Oct 11
You could say that fire is both matter and energy, the atoms in whatever fuel is being burned, react with oxygen and give off energy in the form of heat and light but new molecules (fuel atoms plus oxygen atoms) have been created in order for that to happen, so they must also be floating in the flame as smoke/combustion products.....
@ardoy0731 (7308)
• Philippines
16 Oct 11
That's really a tough one.I also knew that matter is anything that occupy space that has weight and has must. Maybe fire comes from matter i don't know..so hard to find the answer hope you find it soon.Good luck.
• Philippines
17 Oct 11
Hi denisepadin. That is a thought provoking question. Fire is matter. It is a gas. When you heat an object, it produces fire. The fire consumes the object. There is a chemical reaction taking event as the object burns. After the whole object is consumed, fire becomes a smoke and the remaining object becomes ashes.
@Shazooo (296)
• Malaysia
18 Jul 12
Well Im personally not very adept in chemistry...in fact I hate that subject..it's very complicated for me however, I think that fire is a matter because all matter are made up of atom. And I assure you, there is definitely atoms in fire.