The difference between Baking Soda and Baking Powder
By pepai123456
@pepai123456 (879)
Philippines
October 31, 2011 6:28am CST
Ever wonder whats the difference of the two?
Hesitant to use the other for substituting?
Scared your recipe might get ruin if you use the one mistakenly?
well fret no more I'm going to explain the difference of the two and their reactions in a recipe.
baking soda and baking powder has the same effect in a baked good they leaven and makes the baked goods more delicious.
Baking soda is Sodium Bicarbonate(NaHCO3)and it is an alkaline.Recipes that calls for baking soda usually has an acidic ingredient in it for the baking sodas reaction to occur.So its very important to have an acid ingredient if you want to substitute baking powder for baking soda.To know if you baking soda is still effective mix 1 tsp of baking soda to 1/4 cup of vinegar if it bubbles vigorously then its still okay.
Baking Powder on the other hand is actually Sodium Bicarbonate with an Acid(usually cream of tartar)and a filler(cornstarch. Baking Powder is either Single Acting or Double. Single Acting this are baking powder that uses cream of tartar as an acid, the reaction is fast because the cream of tartar is a low temperature acid,after the dry ingredients are moistened it needs to be baked immediately.Double Acting works in two phases, it release small amount of gas when mixed and it continues to release more when baked in the oven.Acids that are used in Double acting are sodium aluminum sulfate or sodium aluminum phosphate and are both high temperature acids.To know know if your baking powder is still in tip top shape just add 1 tsp of baking powder to a cup of boiling water it should bubble vigorously if its still good.
Happy baking =)
1 person likes this
8 responses
@ravinskye (8237)
• United States
31 Oct 11
Wow, thanks for the information! I knew there was a difference and you couldn't really substitute one for the other, but I never really knew what the difference was. I also didn't know how to check if the baking powder was still good. I don't use mine very often so it probably isn't always good when I go to use it.
1 person likes this
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
31 Oct 11
actually you can substitute if you don't have any baking powder you can use the baking soda you just need 1 tsp Baking soda,1 tsp cream of tartar, and 2 tsp cornstarch you can get 1 tbsp of home made baking powder.
But if you don't have any cream of tartar you can still use other tricks like using buttermilk, vinegar, brown sugar this ingredients are acidic and will kick the baking sodas leaving power.Red Velvet cakes use baking soda and vinegar to create the leavening to the cake.
Enjoy baking =)
@humaira12 (149)
• Indonesia
1 Nov 11
yupz, pake cream butter supaya lebih manis, emang disini pada suka manis ya?


@mspitot (3824)
• Philippines
8 Nov 11
Yes, Dutch-processed cocoa is more palatable. Though, pure regular cocoa is more nutritious cause alkalized cocoa's acids and other nutrients are reduced or removed. In some supermarkets, alkalized cocoa costs like regular cocoa but in Quiapo, alkalized cocoa is far cheaper than regular cocoa.
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
7 Nov 11
Thanks for the information friend =)...
We sometimes forget cocoa also behaves differently with different leavener.
I used the Hershey because its cheaper hahaha dutch here is P120 while Hershey is P100 hehe...But i heard the dutch cocoa has a milder/mellow chocolate flavor right?
Ill try it this Christmas =).

@MaryLynn321 (2680)
• United States
31 Oct 11
Another interesting topic. Which is good to know.
Happy Baking

@MaryLynn321 (2680)
• United States
2 Nov 11
I never heard that about baking powder. One just never knows about things completely unless we learn them or take the time to look them up.
Thank you again.
Hugs
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
1 Nov 11
thanks i started this discussion because i have heard some misconceptions about baking powder. I read somewhere that baking powder has yeast on it and its just so funny to read Lol
happy Baking =)

@marguicha (230350)
• Chile
31 Oct 11
I use the one I have at hand and have no problem. But when I make cakes I also use a kind of flour that has some baking powder. Anyway, I put some of mine
. Your explanation is interesting, but I´m afraid that I will forget it, just like I forget the recipes. I just add a cup of this, a bit of that and a pinch of yet another ingredient. The amount of eggs I use for a cake or an omelette depends absolutly on how many I have in the fridge and when will I buy some again.
Take care!
. Your explanation is interesting, but I´m afraid that I will forget it, just like I forget the recipes. I just add a cup of this, a bit of that and a pinch of yet another ingredient. The amount of eggs I use for a cake or an omelette depends absolutly on how many I have in the fridge and when will I buy some again.
Take care!

@marguicha (230350)
• Chile
2 Nov 11
I understood your explanations, but I don´t use recipes of any kind when I cook. I check what I have at hand and I start doing what I can with it. Normally it´s quite tasty
.
I think I haven´t browsed a cook book besides the Joy (just to inspire me) since I have the internet at hand. I mostly see recipes at internet to see the presentation of different foods though.
.
I think I haven´t browsed a cook book besides the Joy (just to inspire me) since I have the internet at hand. I mostly see recipes at internet to see the presentation of different foods though.
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
1 Nov 11
I understand its quite long to understand hehe... I just really like to be scientific when it gets to baking especially after reading Paula Figoni "How Baking Works" I became addicted to baking science.

@annavi23 (6633)
• Philippines
1 Nov 11
oh,this is great,means we can substitute baking soda to baking powder and vice versa,is that right?
back in highschool days we used to bake cakes at our culinary class.i liked baking but i never got the chance to bake cake of my own cause we don't have oven or we don't have budget for baking cakes.too bad isn't it?

@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
3 Nov 11
I understand sometimes baking needs a lil budget especially buying the equipments...
happy baking =)!
@kareemadivina (1230)
• Philippines
31 Oct 11
This post is really informative.Thanks for the information.I learned that 1 component of baking powder is baking soda but I don't know about these acid and alkali things and how to test it's efficacy.I also use to add cream of tartar even if I'm already using baking powder.Now, I understand that it won't be necessary.Just for clarification,can we use baking soda mix with cream of tartar if baking powder is not available?What would be the ratio?
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
1 Nov 11
sure if you mix 1 tsp of baking soda with 1 tsp of cream of tartar and 2 tsp of cornstarch for the moisture absorbing component then you get 1 tbsp of homemade baking powder or the so called Single acting baking powder.
enjoy baking =)
@pepai123456 (879)
• Philippines
1 Nov 11
Glad that i helped =)
though im just a simple home baker who likes to bake and learn from experience your brother probably know this already since his a baker hehe...
Happy baking =)!






