I don't know what it's like to have a close relationship with a sibling
@HeresTheScoop (748)
United States
February 20, 2012 10:34am CST
I grew up with a sister who was 5 yrs older and a brother who was 5 yrs younger than me. I thought that the age was why we didn't have anything in common. My husband's parents had 5 kids within 7 yrs. They are less than 2 yrs apart. My husband is the youngest. My older sister and I have been friends with my husband and his siblings since grade school. They are the kind of family that really sticks up for each other. They have their arguments, but if someone outside of the family says anything bad about one of them, they are all over that person (figuratively speaking).
So my husband and I chose to have our kids close together. We found out that it's not just the age that makes a difference. They are night and day. They got along fine up until they were 6 and 8 yrs old. The oldest was more reserved and the youngest was outgoing. Then the physical fighting started. In highschool our oldest wanted to be a minister and our youngest wanted to be a bartender.
How does this happen that they are sooo different?
I would love to hear about your sibling experience.
7 responses
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
20 Feb 12
It is truly alot more than the age. Their differences will also eventually compliment each other. My dad and his brother were like that. They lead very different lives but still loved each other dearly.
I thought that by having my children further apart that it would effect their relationship, but they are actually alot closer than I realized. While I thought they were distanced from one another, they were developing a relationship on their own all the while. The fighting is just a way of establishing dominance and boundaries I think. Now I never allowed any physical confrontations of any kind but there were times when I had to forbid them from even looking at one another least it cause a terrible argument. They are much like night and day too with a little afternoon thrown in here and there.
I think that your children will end up being closer than you think. I was an only child with half brothers and sisters. We weren't raised in the same households and we are very very very different. At least we were the last time I saw them...long story.
I think that your children will end up being closer than you think. I was an only child with half brothers and sisters. We weren't raised in the same households and we are very very very different. At least we were the last time I saw them...long story. 1 person likes this

@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
21 Feb 12
I don't want you to be repetitive either. I know this has been a long haul for you where your boys are concerned. We want nothing more than our family to be very close. Mine are 23, 18, and 13.
I read where your oldest confronted the youngest about his lifestyle and that is a hard rock to swallow for sure...they really are opposites. Perhaps age and the fact that you are so consistent in your efforts to maintain a relationship, they will eventually find peace with one another.
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
They are 25 and 27 yrs old now. Please read my responses to the other comments. I just don't want to be repetitive. :)
The oldest used to lecture about God and physically hurt the youngest. Mostly when we weren't home. But they didn't tell us till they were out of high school. When they were younger they would physically fight in front of me and I made them stop so I guess they decided to fight when we weren't around.
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
Thank you Jen.
I know that they love each other, they just don't like to be around each other for very long.
It's weird because usually the mom is torn in this situation and is sad that they don't get along. I'm not, that's the weird part. Maybe it's because I have seen them together and I really know that they are opposites. And I respect them as individuals.
@JamesKYTan (1605)
• Malaysia
21 Feb 12
Among siblings age gap plays a good part in fostering a close relationship. One or two years apart among brothers and sisters tend to bring them closer together. This is because they normally play same types of games when younger. This builds bonding and as they grow older the bonging grows even stronger. So if age gap is larger there is no common interests and this brings them further apart. So as newly weds it is good practice for them to plan their children to be closely age-gap of 1 or 2 years apart.
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
Hi JamesKYTan,
:) I'm not sure if you read my responses to the other comments. My boys are only 2 yrs apart and are complete opposites. I do believe that the farther apart in age can be a drawback, but I think it really comes down to personalities.
@soulist (2985)
• United States
20 Feb 12
My brother and I are different but at the same time we have things in common. In high school we fought like cats and dogs because we are a like in so many ways. We are 11 months apart and I agree the age doesn't matter, but to an extend it does because we can relate to each easier now that we are older because we are experiencing some of the same things. We are very close now because we realized we are really the only family we have if my parents pass. We make it a point to spend time together. Like we have brother/sister date nights once a month which is fun we have dinner and go to a movie. Maybe thats an idea.
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
My siblings, their spouses and my husband and myself get together and go out to eat every other month.
My sons, they will not do anything together. They have tried. Their personalities are so different. Sometimes it works with people who are opposites, but not them. Their minds work completely different. The oldest likes structure, has a clean sense of humor, and doesn't drink or smoke. He has just a few friends, who are true and loyal. He doesn't like to be around a lot of people. The youngest doesn't like authority, sarcastic and weird humor, drinks, smokes, loves to go to bars and to be around a lot of people. He has a lot of friends, but they aren't true and loyal, they are backstabbing.
When they are at our home at the same time I make them hug each other for myself. I'm their mom, so they do it. They know it makes me happy.
@chiyosan (30186)
• Philippines
21 Feb 12
ah yeah, different kids different attitude. no two siblings can be alike, even twins aren't. I can say that i am not close with my brothers too. I wish i was, really but never happened and they kinda have their own lives and which is hard for me to try to squeeze into. oh well i would just love to have my own kids who would be close to each other, helping each other out.
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
I don't know, maybe it's like that saying "the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence" I would like to have had a closer bond with my siblings and wish my boys had a close bond. But it is what it is.
@ersmommy1 (12587)
• United States
20 Feb 12
My kids are 5 years apart. The oldest is 8. The younger one is 3. And for right now they get along great. I am hoping this will always be the case. I am closer to my sister than my brother. He lives in a different state, and we don't speak that often.
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
Do you have Girls? Boys? Both?
My mom told me that my older sister used to love to help me when I was an infant to about 4 yrs old. I don't remember. I just remember being in her way when she had friends over.
@juggal0Xx420 (509)
• United States
20 Feb 12
a lot are just different i guess me and my little brother get along just fine we're like best friends to be exact we hangout everywhere together and hardly ever argue, yes sometimes while we are walking around we get called gay cause i have long hair and he used to till he cut his hair but we'd argue with the people calling us names and usually scared them off but like i said i guess we're all just different
1 person likes this
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
That's funny, because my youngest is gay. They just have such extremely different personalities.
The oldest has tourette syndrome so he was made fun of a lot in school. The youngest would defend and stick up for him. But then there was a pride issue where the oldest felt he wanted to defend himself and I think embarrassed to have the younger one defend him.
@ShyBear88 (59342)
• Sterling, Virginia
20 Feb 12
It has nothing to do with how close or how far the ages are between children. Personalities between kids are going to always be different from the moment they are conceived. Either there personalities are going to get alone or not. I have two other brothers they are 1 and half a part and they hate each other. They can't stand to be in the same room. There is 7 years between me and my oldest brother and then there is 5 years between me and my second oldest brother. Me and my brother that is 5 years a part we get alone great. We have every similar personalities. We are both every quite, shy but man we have hot tempers. My brother that is 7 years older then me we don't get alone at all. His personality is the type of person that you really can't get along with too well. He gets angry right way he hides his emotions. He is pretty much a bipolar person. He is every aggressive. I'm in the middle half of the time personality wise between my two person. We fight with each other like all siblings do. But we don't let anyone outside of our family hurt us or bring us down. My brothers are like any other big brothers protect there little sister no matter what. To a certain extent I would do the same for them. I want them to be happy and have the best for them.
My kids are going to be almost 2 years apart. I have a 1 year old and I have another baby on the way. I hope they get alone with each other. But if they don't over time as they get bigger even if there personalities aren't the same they will kind of be there for each other when they need it. You as a parent have to find away to kind of try to blend there personalities in a way that they can work together and if they need each other the other person is always there.

@ShyBear88 (59342)
• Sterling, Virginia
27 Feb 12
I think I'm sure if it happens to all siblings that they tend to grow closer they get older in there adult years. So just never get alone at all but being a hard helps them be strong and better siblings and others do well with there personalities being close. A study shows that kids born a year to two years a part do tend to be closer together not only emotional but for some reason educationally. But I had two brothers born a year a part like my daughter and her soon to be new sibling. My brothers well where like night and day for the most part there was common ground which I think helped in the end make them better brothers to each other. Sports helped a lot with that.
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
I think I have managed to do that - found a way to make them softer towards each other anyway. I think the physical contact helps when I ask them to hug in front of me. They can tolerate each other for awhile. They are 25 and 27 yrs old now.








