Is it Rght to Defend Yourself?

@debrakcarey (19887)
United States
March 28, 2012 6:24am CST
I'm asking this from the Christian perspective. Is it permissable to defend yourself if you feel you life is in danger? Should you defend someone who is vulnerable and weak from violence? What is your take on this?
4 people like this
12 responses
@lifes97 (884)
• United Arab Emirates
28 Mar 12
hi, i think the that is a good, to do that, welcome to a nice sites that will make you know many people and at the same time you spend some time and earn also, so all in all, nice site, you will find a variety of topics here sure it will interest you some of it i mean as it tastes suits many people due to many people here from around the world and have a good time talking here and have good earning also, have a good day
1 person likes this
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Yes, myLot is a great place. You'll earn more by responding on topic lifes97. But thank you for responding anyway.
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Of course you should defend yourself when you think your life is in danger. You want to live right? And you should also defend someone from violence if you think it is the right thing to do. Hope this helps. :)
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
29 Mar 12
Thanks August, welcome to mylot.
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
28 Mar 12
You say from a "Christian perspective"? As in one of many mis-translated verses, "turn the other cheek?" If so, then the answer my friend is YES WE DO!!! This verse, like so many that have been twisted and believed by most Christians, was taught not so we can become a doormat. Y'shua was talking about how the people have went overboard in the "eye for an eye" verse. The punishment was no longer fitting the crime, so that is why Y'shua said to "turn the other cheek" He meant that the punishment should fit the crime.
• United States
29 Mar 12
You're welcome and as I reread this from this morning, I am glad you didn't take it the wrong way, but I hate it when a Christian thinks a certain way that is not right, and yet they think it is because the translation of a verse is incorrect. Plus, one has to look at the writing of the whole Bible in a Hebrew mind-set. Using our western mind-set, we don't understand the how and why's of what G♥d is really saying.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Thank you. That is what I was looking for.
1 person likes this
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
hhmmm i believe yes, we do have right to defends ourselves if we find ourselves and our love ones in danger..sometimes it is instinct that we have. If i see someone who needs some defending, i do defend them out of instinct often..
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
i tend to be that way debra, my husband would even complain that i do that too much i get myself in trouble!
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
29 Mar 12
I hope I never need defending but if I did I would want someone as nice as you to come to my defense.
@2004cqui (2812)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Joan of Ark-that's all I will say about her. You know the story. Our body is to be a temple, therefore protecting it is essential. Jesus said, "What so ever you do for the least of our/your brothers, you do unto me.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
I understand, but some will tell you Jesus forbid us defending ourselves when he said to turn the other cheek, and the meek inherit the earth. What about those teachings? I'm not disagreeing, just asking to further the discussion.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
I agree, keep it civil. I am not suggesting that the Bible contradicts itself. I am looking for an answer to when it is appropriate to defend yourself, and when we must submit to persecution with love.
@2004cqui (2812)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Gotchya-when people start talking about the bible and conflict of words within and keep the discussion civil normally they come to the conclusion to agree to disagree! The bible is full of metaphors. It is 100% subjective. I believe turn the other cheek means if you believe in something and people are telling you are wrong violently either in words or actions that you should stay the course and ignore what they say. Getting stoned, crucified, beaten and otherwise should be stopped. He stopped people from stoning by saying "He who is without sin, shall cast the first stone. They all stopped.
@Cherish14 (2693)
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
yes i definitely would defend myself if i was in danger or someone i love is in danger. that is a normal defense mechanism and a human being's instinct to protect themselves. if someone's life is in danger, i don't think they will just let the person kill them without trying to protect themselves or by struggling or fight back. when i was younger, i was physically and emotionally abused but i never fought back. i would just cover up myself so i don't get hit in the head. i have so much hate in those people who did that to me, i just can't let it go in my heart.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Cherish, I've been there as well. Forgive them as a favor to yourself. The abuser still goes on abusing you, by stealing your peace of mind if you do not forgive. Notice, I did not say forget. But to help yourself move on, to find peace, forgive. God bless you. I am thinking of you today.
@Cherish14 (2693)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
awww i just felt like crying while reading your response. you actually are right and have a point. it is also hard for me to move on because i can't afford to get a place of my own so i can already move out. i just want to be away from everyone. i am trying to forgive and move on but it is not the right time yet. i hope i get there soon. thank you my friend debra. God Bless you too
@axlrate7 (1398)
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
I think there's nothing wrong in defending yourself, protecting yourself and others from violence is a good thing to do (But don't defend in violence). But please remember to pray for those people that did some violence to you or to others. Remember that God told us to love our enemy, and praying for them is a good way of showing our love for them.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
You did fine expressing yourself axlrate7. And forgiveness is good for the one doing the forgiveness, pray for them. Good for you!
@axlrate7 (1398)
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
I have some mistakes above, what I mean there was don't do an action that also will result you in violence. "(Don't defend using also violence)", there are lot of good ways to defend your self and others that will make them see the light in you. I'm sorry for my wrong writing above...
@tonyllenium (6252)
• Italy
29 Mar 12
yes probably it is right to defend yourself if your life is in danger so may be in some occasions is better just quit the situation in itself so may be from this point of view is focused some situations in the bible but i think that in general it would be normal for humans or other creatures trying to survive even in difficult situations and so defend teir lives!!
@shylade (3132)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
well, i will given the situation but i will not be violent. we hav ethe right to speak up when you think you are right.
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
If that is the case "life's in danger" yes, we must and should protect our lives. Human instinct is to protect the weak ones, either our loved ones or a stranger. I don't see anything wrong protecting one's life from any violence.It's not killing, or a murder-it's an instinct.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
I agree it is; but there are those who's instinct to protect life is gone, null, void.
@Polgara (31)
• Germany
28 Mar 12
As a Christian and devoted believer, I can tell you that it is alright to defend yourself when you are in danger of being abused and/or killed. Christians should once and for all understand one important fact about God: He had said: Work six days, and rest on the seventh. That means that we have to work or to do something first, if we want God to help us. For example, if you have an exam at your school, and learn nothing, how can you expect from God to help you pass the exam? Should God do that exam instead of you, or study instead of you? You have to study before the exam, and then can you expect God´s help, to help you remain concentrated and to do your best there. Without our previous work it is ridiculos and unthankful to ask anything from God. Same goes for self-defense. If you don´t protect yourself, how can you then expect from God to protect you? Do you want Him to make a miracle every time you need something? It doesn´t work that way. Protect yourself, stay out of trouble whenever you can, run away, or at least try to run away and protect yourself. Only then will God do something to add to your effort and to help you. It doesn´t mean that you should kill someone who´s attacking you, but if you have absolutely no choice, if you cannot run away, then you have to do it, and God is great enough to forgive you, if you in your soul feel bad about what you´ve done. And about protecting others... It is even more important for a Christian to protect and defend those who cannot do it for themselves. What do you think, what is better, in God´s eyes? For you to defend a child who is abused, or to do nothing to help the kid? When you know that a child is abused, and do nothing to help, it is the same as you have done the abuse yourself. People don´t sin only when they do something, they can sin also when doing nothing, when they should and must do something.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Welcome to myLot! And you are very wise. I agree, we cannot expect a miracle every time we need something! Thank you for your wise response.
• Canada
28 Mar 12
I feel it is right to defend yourself. Why would anyone just want to lay there while they get beat, raped or whatever... Lol. Also standing up for someone who can't defend themselves is also a good thing. I seen people push around thise wheelchair bound or emotionally abusing someone because they couldn't do a certain thing, and couldn't stand up for themselves. I tend to stick up for the weaker people, and ward off the bullies.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Mar 12
Me too. I've been the victim of a violent crime. I will 'stand my ground' anyday.
• Kuwait
28 Mar 12
Offcourse i wont sit there closing eyes when there is danger . I cant expose myself to danger as if God has not given me wisdom to defend myself . As we pray we should watch. The knowledge and wisdom God gives should be put in practise . Physical things should be delt with physically while spiritual things spiritually. To me it is not wrong.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
29 Mar 12
Welcome Myienddob, and you too, are very wise with your response.