Any solutions for growing number of squatters?
By Resy King
@resy21curapika (2151)
Pasay, Philippines
April 29, 2012 7:46am CST
I felt bad about what happened in Paranaque between illegal settlers or "squatters" and demolition team. Tension between the two parties and it gets worse it became remorseful. One killed and most of them injured.
In the news it gets normal but not for me. I'm getting alarmed as most of the population can't handle these sitautions properly anymore. Now they're protesting what happened and it's going to be a violation to their human rights.
Proper communication, better education or home resettlements; do you have anything in mind for a solution to the growing number of nomads; or homeless and illegal settlers? Let me know here in this discussion.
1 person likes this
9 responses
@irene66 (1669)
• Philippines
29 Apr 12
Squaters are really a menace in our country.
But it seems the government cannot iradicate them because of poverty.
As if they are a part of our society.
If poverty is solved, squaters might be reduced to a number which is negligible.
However, with the situation of the country, they will always be there.
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
30 Apr 12
How can we solve poverty? We can have the government work with this hand on hand, right? Do you have any suggestions so far?
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
So you mean better education and mind-setting will fix this? In a good way, since you've mentioned you have been in China before; how do they deal with their country's progress? Do they also have housing projects or lower housing loans? Do they have a improved education system?
How does it works for this situation?
@irene66 (1669)
• Philippines
1 May 12
To me, one way to solve poverty is to be self relient.
People should try their very best to support themselves and others as well and not to rely on the dole out of the government alone.
This reminds me when I was in China years ago.
Chinese in general do not think of themselves alone but always include to make their country progressive.
Filipinos are the opposite.
They think of how they become rich but forget about the plight of their country and other people.
As a result, poor remains poor and rich becomes richer.
In short if filipinos change this attitude, life will be greatly improved I believe.



@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
29 Apr 12
We did. They end up beating them up. Should that be called violence and against the human rights?
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
Good for them! Unlike here which is most of the places are urbanized already. For me it's nice to camp in the woods and bring your things in there, laptop and such.
Like trailer vans! That's also nice.
@johndur (3052)
• Pasig, Philippines
30 Apr 12
most of the squatters came from the province trying their luck in the city...the only solution to lessen the growing number of squatters is to develop provinces and make them more income generating regions and give work for the locals of the province...that way they will not go to the city just to get a job and earn a decent living...dont relocate them too much spoiling them will not solve the problem...because they will just accept the relocation and then sell it and go back to the city to squat again...


@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
So they're what we called "professional squatter". Is there such a community like that? What are the possible solution fir this? Should the government give them oney or use education for controlling them?
1 person likes this

@neildc (17238)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
30 Apr 12
i can't see any clear solution for illegal settlers other than providing them better livelihood and more jobs, as in regular and stable money earning jobs in the provinces. if the government could not provide them better living conditions in the provinces, people will always come to the city to seek chance for jobs.
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
We keep on changing presidents and most of them are promising this during elections. Is this has something to do with the Government? They should adrees this matter promptly otherwise it will be worse as you think that there's no solution for it yet.
@louievill (28846)
• Philippines
30 Apr 12
Squatting is an off shoot of over population, poverty and lack of discipline. It also mirrors the imbalance of earning opportunities in the provinces so people flock to big cities. It also show cases the lack of political will of leaders and authorities to stop them even before the sprout and mushroom
, in fact some government officials tolerate and pamper them because these are where the large but mostly ignorant and uneducated votes come from, so they steer it to their favor in order to stay in power, very sad fact in our country but very true

, in fact some government officials tolerate and pamper them because these are where the large but mostly ignorant and uneducated votes come from, so they steer it to their favor in order to stay in power, very sad fact in our country but very true
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
Everyone should take part in fixing the issue. It should be a pointing- faults game. All are feel sad and aggrevated about it but if we don't see for more solutions right now; It could get worse and this is a never-ending cycle of demolitions. lol
@yahnee (1243)
• Philippines
29 Apr 12
The only way to control the growth of the squatter colonies in the city is for the government to stop tolerating them in building their shanties in government and private properties. However with the moratorium issued by the DILG to put a temporary stop to the demolitions scheduled, they are encouraging the squatters. Why is human rights so biased between the poor and the rich, the squatters and the police? Are only the poor deserving of what we call as human rights? What if you are the property owner and you get deprived of your property because some squatters decided to build houses on your land, don't you have any human rights then? If the police get hurt in a rumble, don't they get the same human rights if the culprit is poor? Why then do we have to pay rent when we can just build a shanty in any vacant lot? Many people are also poor but they pay rent. Have you not noticed that these squatters being coddled by the government for being poor are not actually poor? They have jobs, they can build concrete houses, they have complete appliances in the squatters area. Being a squatter certainly has its benefits, don't you think so?

@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
In Manila, there were once a place being developed by Pres. Fidel Ramos under NHA (National Housing Authority) and it was called Katuparan Compound in Vitas. They could have provide a shelter like this first before shooing away the squatters. This gives less tension in demolitions.
So is should be the government to blame for this? I also think that citizens like us also are responsible for this. Working hard for a decent living in a house which you own will lessen the number of squatters. And what ever happened to our nation's education? Should education play a vital role in informing everyone about the importance of having their own houses and working hard for it in the first place?
How about other countries that has a good education standars? Less squatters.
@jeanneyvonne (5500)
• Philippines
29 Apr 12
Being a squatter means you are always right because you are part of the Masa. There seems to be another set of rules for people like the squatters. It's not the law that is written or even taught at law school.

@neildc (17238)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
30 Apr 12
i can't see any clear solution for illegal settlers other than providing them better livelihood and more jobs, as in regular and stable money earning jobs in the provinces. if the government could not provide them better living conditions in the provinces, people will always come to the city to seek chance for jobs.
@jeanneyvonne (5500)
• Philippines
29 Apr 12
Ther eis no singel way to imrpove tehse conditions. There are manyf actors and sometimes, it's all complicated. But I think we can blame it on palying teh 'vicitm card', the stubborness of some people and the poltiics involved.
In my personal opinion, squatters also play the 'victim card'. they are poor and they don't have much, so why society or the police picking up on the? Why is the rich are the ones favored? They have human rights also but majority of the times they reject what is offered to them because it is an inconvenience to them. What about otehr people who are inconvenient by them?
I get that they don't have much but it doesn't mean that they can bend the law for their purposes. they know what they are doing is wrong...so why d o it? They know the consequences and yet they are the eons who very brave in breaking the law...oITP.
Another main thing is the politics. local candidates are very dependent on their votes so they turn a blind eye to what they are doing. When they can't do anything more and the demolition is already there, they won;t take sides. Typical politico to use people and hide when the favor has been granted.
i tihnk that is no single solution - there should be many solutions but it all boils down to people. If thy can't accept reality, there's no point i giving them their demands.
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
1 May 12
So you mean we shouldn't act nothing towards this? It could get happen to your friends. Or worse; if something unexpected happens, anyone can tunr out to force themselves selling their proerties and live in squatters; if renting may not be a good choice as well.
From the way I'm seeing this it is not also their choice or liking to live here. Although possibly it is also their choice but if there's a better solution, then they'll definitely grab it. Would you mind checking of other solutions for this?
Of not; that's okay. I greatly appreciate your feedback. Happy mylotting about your possible solutions ahead ^_^-)
@resy21curapika (2151)
• Pasay, Philippines
29 Apr 12
Usually one of the reasons here is the provincial peeps are selling their lands and making way for more opportunities in the cities. But in reality if the government or private sectors can't handle this number of immigrants; they'll end up in dumpsites making homes and such.
I cannot believe it. But this is reality. It bites; and eventually hurts.








