why me???

United States
June 20, 2012 4:04pm CST
ok so i have been with my fiance Ryan for like ever now, we are getting married in september of this year. when i was in middle school and transfered to a new school there was this guy we will call him Jay, 3 years older then me and totally gorgous, he was the first person to talk to me. he became my best friend and we were friends for 4 years. i was head over heals in love with him and he always told me he loved me too. he promised me that one day we would be together, someday after i turned 18. we always promised eachother that we would only marry each other. kinda silly now that i look back on it. my father hated him so i would always sneak out of the house to go see him and come up with some crazy excuse to why i was so late getting back to the house (i was alowed 3 15 minute walks a day) anyway me and Jay were inseperable, one of my teachers mr. shack used to tell me not to talk to him but i still did, when Jay asked me out i turned him down because i was afraid of what my dad would do, but we still hung out constantly, we still had plans to be together when i turned 18 and got out of my fathers house i ended up having to move to my moms house 45 minuts away for the summer, he came and saw me at the beggining but his visits got farther and farther apart until he stopped coming. when i moved back to town the first thing i did was sneek out to go see Jay, he had a girlfriend, a girlfriend with 2 kids. i was friends with her younger brother so i knew she was crazy and didnt understand why he would be with her. it broke my little teenage heart. but eventually i met ryan and moved on with my life. i would still see Jay every once in a while, just passing by and he never spoke to me, he always had her with him and she knew about our past and refused to let him come to town alone in fear that he would come over to my house. even though i moved on with my life i dont think i ever really got over him, he still haunts my dreams occasionally, i still see things on the street or hear certin songs and he is the first thing that pops into my head. so when he emailed me i probably shouldnt have read it, when he told me he was in town, i shouldnt have gone down to visit. he finally left his girlfriend, he told me he was sorry he stopped talking to me like he did, that he still thought about me all the time, he played our song and we talked for hours. he went on about how i was the only girl he ever loved and whatnot, and sitting there looking into his eyes just confused me so much, it was just like old times, like we never missed a beat, like he didnt hurt me and hadent just disapeared for years. what i have with ryan is safe, its confertable, i know that he will always be here for me, always do whatever he can to take care of me. what i had with Jay was so full of passon and fun, so spontantious, he still took care of me but i never knew what was around the corner. would he up and leave or would he stay i never knew? the way he looked at me even now, it made my heart skip a beat. ryan knows him, he knows about our past, and the other day when i went down to see him ryan came to pick me up, he saw the way that Jay looked at me and that was all he talked about the rest of the night. he said he could see how badly Jay wanted to be with me, how much love he had in his eyes, he said it looked like he wanted to grab me, bring me inside and keep me from ryan, (which is true he did tell me he wanted to). but ryan hates him, wants to go down and kick his a** even though i told Jay that we had to be just friends for now. jay took it well and understands completely but im so confused. there were so many promises made between us and i still care about him but after he broke my heart all those years ago i dont know. i love Ryan so much and i want to be with him, i just wish i could get Jay out of my head. like i said before what Ryan and i have is safe, almost too safe, there is no spontantious trips or even all that much fun anymore. i understand because he is working two jobs right now but i wish he would make time for me too, when we first got together, when we were spending time together and laughing i almost never thought of jay, the dreams stopped, but now ryan gets up, gos to work, comes home, eats, has a beer and sits infront of the tv paying almost no attention to me, on his days off he just wants to sleep or go off on his own. i have no idea what to think anymore. help????
4 responses
• United States
20 Jun 12
Sounds like you need to talk to Ryan about what is bothering you with the relationship you have with him. You don't want to marry him in Sept and regret it forever. If you are still thinking about Jay and are still in love with him it is not fair to be with Ryan cause all you are going to do is hurt him in the end. If you decide to stay with Ryan sounds like you are going to have to cut off all contact with Jay otherwise that will cause problems in your relationship with Ryan. It is WAY better to be honest with Ryan and make a decision now on who you want to be with before you marry Ryan and possibly make the biggest mistake of your life. In the end follow what your heart says.
• United States
20 Jun 12
thanks and i know im going to be staying with Ryan,i dont have it in me to intentionally hurt someone like Ryan. its just that i waited so long for Jay to say those things and just when i stopped thinking about him he pops back into my life and i just dont know. i dont think i could ever be with Jay again, he broke my heart all those years ago and i dont think i could trust him that much again. ive already talked to Ryan about it (somewhat)he doesnt want me to stop talking to Jay but i have been trying to slowly stop talking to him, ya know what i mean? i refuse to go see him in person again. but i do love ryan and i dont want to hurt him. i also dont want to put anymore stress on him by complaining about the lack of time that we get together, he has been working so hard lately trying to save money for us to buy/build a house. i think alot of it is that i miss having someone to joke around with and spend time with. anyway idk i know ima stay with ryan because i love him more then anything and he is the only one i can see me actually spending my life with
@Shazooo (296)
• Malaysia
20 Jun 12
Time. It's the only way to heal. Give it some time and eventually you will forget about it. Ryan, from what you describe him to be, sounds like a loving guy, while jay on the other hand...I don't know..he doesn't sound so warming. If jay really loved you, he would even bother dating other people...sure he may say he love you know...but that's just what every guy says when they want a girl back...you deserve more than that...you deserve someone like Ryan...I've been in your situation before...( well,minus the marrying part...xD) and what ever the guy ( in this case is jay) said, I fell for it...than I saw he had another girlfriend...and she was my best friend....I was so hurt that year...but eventually I met another guy and he is way more loyal...so I advice you...do not fall for every word Jay says...good luck :)
• United States
20 Jun 12
thanks and i try not to. i dont want to mess up what i have with Ryan, it was just so shocking that he got ahold of me out of the blue and said all the things i waited years to hear lol. im glad that you too met another guy and i wish you the best of luck :)
• Valdosta, Georgia
20 Jun 12
I have been where you are right now. I had two guys who I cared for immensely and who both wanted to be with me. One was fun and carefree, the other more serious and the family type. I had to make a choice. The one, let's call him A for now was more of a good time kind of person and I was never secure of his intentions or feelings. The other one (who is my husband now actually) showed me loyalty and unconditional love. Obviously I chose my husband because I was confident of his love for me and I was secure in what we had and still have. "A" just wanted a good time and he didn't really want to settle down and I never knew what to expect. You really can't change that kind of person into a family man and have him settle down. Life is not always fun, what will happen if their not having "fun" anymore, they are going to leave you, no doubt about that... However, Ryan will be by your side through thick and thin. I know it was so hard for me to make that decision but I went with the one who I knew without any doubt in my mind loved me and would be there for me forever no matter what. I think you will fall completely in love with Ryan and when you do your thoughts of Jay will be a thing of the past. I lost my husband for a little while, he left to see his family and I was in "A's" arms crying and all I wanted was my husband. That is when I knew without any doubt who I belonged with...When the one who was holding me became not good enough for my heart I just knew. One day you will figure it out, your heart will tell you the right path to take... I wish you the best and I hope you choose the best one for you. =)
• Indonesia
20 Jun 12
What u had with Jay is memory. Tenager memory. 1st love that never end but not to live for. Its only your passion that u used to dream and had making promised with him years ago. What u feel with Ryan is mature love, not only a passion as you feel with jay. Take time to talk with Ryan, tell him what you want and let him say what he wants to say. Its just good conversation in the right time.