Do you think that women shouldn't work?

United States
January 5, 2013 11:04am CST
Many people have the thinking that women should just stay home and take care of their husband,children, and home. How do you feel about that thinking? My husband said to me today that I'm basically saying I don't want to be a mother because I want to work and take care of bills and have him try staying at home full time. But of course he really doesn't want to do that even if I could find a job to support our family. I know I could work full time. I don't mind working. He just wouldn't be willing to switch places. I think that if women want to work they should be able too. I think it's an individual decision. If a woman wants to stay home and have that as her career then that is her choice. I just don't think others should try and dictate what she does.
3 people like this
23 responses
@nitinnair89 (2900)
• India
5 Jan 13
It's totally wrong. Women must be treated equally as men. So they must be allowed to work if that's what they really like to do... I know there are some places where they treat women like the only one to stay back and work, but it's not right as per me..
2 people like this
• Portugal
5 Jan 13
i agree with you. i think we women should be as free as men. if a woman is married and she wants to work her husband has to respect her wishes. sadly, in some countries women are supposed to just stay home taking care of kids. and the guy is the only one providing for the family. i think thats unfair. life is short and we should be happy doing what we love to do.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
@nitinnair I agree with you. Women should definitely be treated equally. It is sad to see that so many are not. Women should be able to work if they want too. After all we have feelings and desires about what we want to do with our life.
• United States
21 Jan 13
@sweetlove you are absolutely right. You make the perfect point. We all should be able to do what we love. It shouldn't just be the man who pursues his goals and dreams with his wife's support. A woman should be able to pursue her goals as well with her husband's support. It shouldn't be a one sided thing. That would be completely unfair.
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
5 Jan 13
The recognised structure of a family whereby the husband provides while the wife tends to the home and children is rapidly becoming an outmoded concept. I still feel that the husband should be prepared to provide for the family, but this should be allowed to result in restricting the actions of any other family member. Many women have education standards or vocational qualifications that allow them to acquire a better paid job than their husband, so there is no reason why the roles should not be reversed for the benefit of all. Only misplaced male pride would find this a problem. There are also many women who enjoy the work that they do, which would mean that forbidding them to work would be quite unfair. Marriage is intended to be a partnership and neither party should be expected to conform to ideals in that way.
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jan 13
Yeah I completely agree and feel the same way. No one should feel as if they have to conform to some standard of who does what in the family. Some men feel that a woman can work and take care of the family. So if a woman in a sense can do the "man's job" why can't the husband be willing to stay at home with the kids. I do agree that whatever is in the best interest of the family should be considered.
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
8 Jan 13
I think it must be incredibly disagreeable if a woman is made to feel like she has to stay at home to mind the kids, hubs and home. That said, there are some women who are just bone lazy and don't work because of this and they neglect their kids, hubs and home to boot. The thing I don't get is if you want to have a career, and don't want to raise your children or be housebound, why do you have children???
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
10 Jan 13
Your husband is punishing you because he is unhappy. Sounds silly, I know but that's how it is. I was visiting a garden centre one day with a view to buying a tree. I really wanted a palm tree and my partner told me a palm tree would make too much noise when it was windy. Can you believe it??? What an idiot! He was just making stupid excuses because he didn't want to agree to me having what I want. You may be too dependant on your husband. You are giving him too many opportunities to control you. Start to do things while he is at work. Don't tell him. As you become more independent, tell him he is talking rubbish or just stand up to him. This situation you have is not going to improve unless you do something for yourself. I wish you so much because I'm sure you are miserable and I can really understand why.
1 person likes this
@sminut13 (1783)
• Singapore
13 Jan 13
i can really relate with dominique25, my husband is really similar in the sense that he only thinks that he's the one right and i'm not. it could be as mstickle said, that i've been too dependent on him and whenever an argument seems like it's about to start, i just keep quiet and agree with whatever he's saying because if i were to disagree or say otherwise, then he'd be angry which would only be a big headache. i say things out straightforwardly without thinking much and that can sometimes hurt others although i may not be aware. thus he gets upset. so i try not to make a big deal and just go along with him. i really agree with mstickle, sometimes they make excuses because they don'want us to do something they don't like even though we might like it.
• United States
10 Jan 13
I agree with you that a woman shouldn't feel as if she has to stay home. And there are women out there who are really lazy. To answer your question I want to have a career and I have just one daughter. We weren't planning on having a child she was a surprise for us. I however am happy with just having one child. My problem is my husband isn't reasonable. Whatever I want to do he always makes an excuse for why I can't or shouldn't do it. If I want a career: then it's, we don't have the money to do it. If I want to have a full time job: then it's daycare cost to much. If I want to get a second car so that at least my daughter and I can get out of the house: then it's the gas is too much.But whatever he wants to do it's alright. If the finances are too tight for his goals then he says things like: we will have to go without this or that, or things will be extremely tight with no spending room. He makes his goals work but for me it's not worth the time or effort to reach mine.
2 people like this
@sminut13 (1783)
• Singapore
13 Jan 13
in this day and time, i agree that it's usually equal, where the woman and man both work, but there are still some cases where it might not be so. and the reason is simply because the husband is too conservative. not all women like working and that's fine, but there are some who enjoy working rather than doing house chores. but it's unfortunate they have to stay home because of situations. so long as it's mutual between both husband and wife, then if the wife wants to stay home, that's ok but if it's not mutual, then something is wrong somewhere.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Jan 13
Yeah I agree with you if it's a mutual decision then that is a good thing. But if the wife doesn't want to just stay at home and take care of the family in just that way, then her feelings should be taken into consideration. Her thoughts and feelings are just as important as the husbands. The husband should work to keep his wife happy just like the wife strives to do for her family.
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
8 Jan 13
It depends. If the husband can provides everything than the wife perhaps should not have to work. It is not the final word that women can't have their own career. If they have their own job and can handle the family at the same time, then why not?(^^)
1 person likes this
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
8 Jan 13
It's the husband responsibility to provide the family needs so they can't say that their money is their money-its totally not right for me. Anyway there is nothing wrong whether a woman like to have their own career or just be a housewife based on their situations and conditions.(^^)
• United States
8 Jan 13
Yeah I agree with you. If a woman( and most do a fabulous job) can handle family and work then that's great. I think that it makes a woman feel good about herself when she knows that she can do other things besides just staying at home and cooking,cleaning,etc. Also though if a woman has a wonderful husband who provides for HER and the family as well then that is plus too. Some husbands though feel their money is their money and do not feel the need to give there wife a little money for her to do things that she likes to do. Then resentment builds in those situations.
@ShyBear88 (59281)
• Sterling, Virginia
5 Jan 13
Let my start off with that I'm a stay at home mom and that was buy my choice not my husband and he never made me stay home he can't control what I want to do. I see it as that a women doesn't have to stay home if she feels the call of work then she should work that won't stop her from being a mother. Many women are working moms and they are good at it and they are still great moms just like stay at home moms. You have to feel the call to want to be a stay at home mom other wise your just going to get depressed being home all of the time. I don't like working but if I have to I'll help work to make things easier on my husband and he has told me if I got a really good job he would stay home with the children instead of me if we could afford him being home. I also feel that I'm not ready to leave my kids yet. I had a hard pregnancy this last year and I was away from my oldest for month and I know that doesn't seem that long but it felt like forever. I don't want to go throw that again and seeing my child come home to me and not miss me or run in to my arms that hurts. I cried when that happened I know she missed me and wanted mommy but when she saw me she didn't know what to do and it took her a few days to warm back up to me and her dad. I don't want that to happen because my children are only this small once time and I don't want to miss it. My parents where both working parents and they where always there for my brothers and I don't regret them both working and being away from me and my brothers. My mom she needs to work she can't just stay home she goes a but crazy and she is a stay at home grandmother for the most part now and has a part time job. She did have a full time job but her company choice to make it all just that in India people will work and closed down all the US locations. I hated it when people tell me that a women should be at home because they shouldn't they have to want to it should be a personal choice not forced.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
I completely agree with what you are saying. I'm glad to hear that your husband supports you either way. That in itself is a great thing. Yeah I do not like it when other people say that a woman should have to stay home. It should be a personal choice. I think it is just wrong when a person implies that a woman doesn't want to be a mother because she wants to work outside the house, or do other things besides staying home all day. Based on that reasoning then it could be said that men do not want to be fathers because when they get home from work they want to do other things for themselves instead of playing with the kids. It's only fair that a woman should be able to have balance and do things for herself. Sorry to hear that you had such a hard pregnancy. That would be sad to see that it takes our own child/ren to warm up to us after being away awhile. They are only young once and we do have to remember that when we are trying to get through these types of things.
@ShyBear88 (59281)
• Sterling, Virginia
22 Jan 13
I have many working mom friends and they a pretty darn good job with there little ones just as good as a mom that stays at home. Staying home with your kids it's a calling for sure. Yeah my husband is a typical man he wants to come home and relax but for the most part he normally comes home and take care of the kids with me. Oh yes I cried that night she came home because of her reaction but it wasn't her fault she is only 1 years old and hadn't seen me for almost a month. Good thing she wont remember.
@youless (112103)
• Guangzhou, China
6 Jan 13
In this modern city, it is very common for a woman to have her own career. Especially when the family needs to a better finance. It will be stressful for the husband to support the finance only. And the wife can follow the social life when they have a work.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jan 13
Yeah with the economy the way it is these days it is very hard for a family to survive from one income. Most of the time it does require that both spouses work to take care of the family and their financial responsibility. I just hope that more and more women will be free to make that decision themselves.
• United States
7 Jan 13
I think it depends to your culture and traditions. I do know someone who is a stay-at-home Dad, he works part time at my job but his wife is the bread winner. I had a hard time adjusting to being home with the kids for several years, it gets really boring and I hated not being able to contribute to our household income. I do work part time so it helps me from going crazy sitting home all day. I would like to work a full time job in the near future however, child care is expensive and arrangements for days children are not in school can be expensive.
• United States
13 Jan 13
Yeah I agree with what you are saying. I feel the same way. Sometimes I feel like I'm going to go crazy just staying home all day. I do have different activities planned for my daughter and I but it's hard to do new and different things when I don't have the finances to buy more craft or game items. I too would like to work full time. I hope that in the future I will be able to find something that is better for me in a financial way. I agree that child care is very expensive, and sometimes I feel that it wouldn't be cost effective to work outside the home even though I want too.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
7 Jan 13
You live in the US, so you do have that choice. This is something that should have been settled before you married, but we have a tendency not to think of such things. Talk to your husband. Many women choose to work, even though most of their wages go for child care, transportation, clothes, etc. It's your choice.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Jan 13
Yeah I think I'm going to try and find a job where I can work full time. Before I got married we did discuss these things. It was I could work part time if I wanted to or if we didn't need the extra money then I wouldn't have to work if I didn't want too. Though now things have changed a bit. It seems that it always has to be the supporting of my husband and his goals. But I think with time that is going to change. I have spent a lot of time at home and now I would like to work. I hope to find a job where I will be able to take care of the things that I need too.
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
6 Jan 13
In my opinion, wife must stay at home to care for the family matter. But this is not a fix opinion. I am a fair person and if the wife want to get work this is no problem unless the purpose is good and decide both of the couple.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Jan 13
Glad to hear that you are a fair person. And that you would be considerate of your wife and what she wants to do. I think that a woman should be able to work if she would like to. I think it is so sad that many woman feel they have to stay at home when they would rather do some type of work and improve their life and their own self esteem. It's different when the wife has a loving and supportive husband. Then she doesn't mind too much about staying at home. If a wife has a harsh husband then she will want to work to support herself.
@prashu228 (37526)
• India
5 Jan 13
Hi dominique I don't find any reason why women should not work there many women who are working as well as looking /take care of their regular family needs.Women shouldn't work are the line of olden days but in this modern computer world women are looking for work and it is very essential for family needs as the prices of all the products are increasing day by day.Modern women are not dependent they are individual!!
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
I agree with you. With the high cost of everything it is becoming more important that both partners work to help support the family. Even then things can still be pretty tight. It is important that more people start viewing women as individuals and not just as this man's wife or partner.
@Shavkat (137201)
• Philippines
7 Jan 13
For some part of the country, they don't allow their wives to work. They just need to stay at home, take care of the children and her husband. It is still happen, but others allowed the woman to work. It is part of being practical and to empower the rights of a woman.
• United States
14 Jan 13
I agree with you that it's important to be practical. Women should be able to work if it is allowed. Women have just as many things that they would like to accomplish as men do. It is a good thing when a husband or father is considerate of how the women in their family feel.
• United States
5 Jan 13
Yes women should work, because we are equal to men nowadays. In the USA, i can say that women almost have the same responsibility to men. There are some stuff a woman will want, that the man, will not want to give it. Yes women should work.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
Yeah I think whatever a woman wants to do should be her choice. I don't think so many people should feel that a woman needs to stay at home all the time taking care of just family responsibilities. It is important that she has things she likes to do for herself which may include working outside the home.
@RaineC (6)
• United States
6 Jan 13
I think it is the woman's choice. It does affect the whole family and she should discuss it with her partner, but I do not think a man should be the one dictating that a woman should not or cannot work, especially if the money is needed. I do think society still makes it easier on women who choose to stay at home and harder on men who are home, especially if the wife works, and this is not fair. My choice was to stay at home after my son was born, but I look back now and thing we may have been better off if I had continued to work, because I had a bigger salary and much better insurance/benefits plan than my husband did, but I knew I personally would have missed my baby and been too distracted to go back to work in the first year or two.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jan 13
I agree with you. It should definitely be a woman's decision whether or not she will work. I'm glad that you did enjoy staying at home with your baby even though your family sacrificed salary and insurance benefit.It can be tough making those decisions. I know that for me I'm starting to want to go out and work more. I have only worked part time for awhile now. First it was so that we could keep our life simple and focus on volunteer work. When I got pregnant it was so that I could stay at home and raise our child. My little baby is almost two and now I'm ready to get out of the house. There are many factors that contribute to my feeling this way. I hope that in time I will have the circumstances to do this.
@chi2nasrin (1101)
• Malaysia
9 Jan 13
Well, if you can afford it, staying at home is not such a bad idea after all. You can have all the times to do whatever you need and want to do. I have been unemployed for a long time before and I know how boring it is not having anything to do. I agree with you that if a woman wants to work then it is all up to her.
1 person likes this
• Portugal
5 Jan 13
i think its good for every woman to be independent and have a job. we never know what can happen in our future. for example, you get married while you are young. years later, your husband wants the divorce. what will happen to you then? you have no work experience so will be very hard to find a job. so i think that we should work too. i dont judge women that choose to stay home with their kids. i agree with it if the husband's job is enough to pay the bills and support the family. but i think is always good for us, women to at least have some little experience.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
Yeah independence is important. It really does mean a lot for many women. Especially women who want to be able to take care of themselves and pursue their own goals and interest. We never know what could happen in the future, you are right we need to have some type of experience.
• Valdosta, Georgia
5 Jan 13
I agree with you I think it should be personal choice, no one should tell a woman either way what she should do. I don't mind working but I prefer to be home with my kids, especially since I am Home Schooling. But if my husband needs me to get a job he knows I will since I have done it before... It is just my preference of wanting to be home with the kiddos. =)
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
Yeah I think it should always have a lot to do with personal preference. If a woman wants to work or not should be based on what she really wants to do. After all many women/wives work hard in other to help their partner/spouse do what he wants to do. Whether it's going to college, helping him start a business,or just finding a job he likes women are more than willing to help the man in their life. Partners/husbands should be no different when it comes to helping their woman. When these things are done it brings happiness for the whole family.
@kokomo (1867)
• Philippines
2 Feb 13
Well, I think men and women are already equal this days. And If I'll gonna have a family in the future, I think I cannot see myself to be in the house all day long. I want to work and be a successful career woman and business woman if God permits. But of course, I should also practice on how to be a good wife and a good mother while having my career.
@vernaC (1491)
• Romania
5 Jan 13
Women should stay at home taking care her husband and kids If she is very much provided. If her husband can support her wants and needs, then what's working for? But if the family needs financial support and she's able to give that then she should. It depends on both partners of what they want with their lives and how they can accommodate with their situation.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
I don't think that a woman "should" stay home.I think that a big factor needs to be about how the woman feels about what she will be doing. If she wants to work then she could work, if she wants to stay home then she could do that. There are plenty of women who are very well provided for my their husband and yet they still choose to work.
• St. Peters, Missouri
5 Jan 13
I think it's wrong for anyone to try to dictate to a woman where "her place" is. This is an intensely personal decision. It must be a family decision. Not a decision made by any one person. I think it's just as wrong to dictate to a woman where she should be as it is to dictate to a man where he should be. There aren't too many of these conversations where men are complaining that they are being forced to stay home. Or that they are being forced to work. No matter how seemingly progressive, too many people (both men and women) still believe a woman has no choice. But it is equally wrong to tell a man he must be the one to bring home the bacon. This should always be a joint decision. How many incomes are needed? Who has the most likelihood of getting a job that pays the best? Does someone want to stay home? Who wants to work out of the home? These are all questions that need to be asked when making this decision. No one can assume, by gender alone, what the answers to these questions are. It's just that history tends to show that men have more workplace skills and earning power and women are more nurturing so we tend to automatically assume these are the "correct" roles. But just like any stereotype, this isn't always true. And this doesn't take into account anyone's desires.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jan 13
I completely agree with what you are saying. Men do not like to be dictated to about what they are going to do for work, or how,etc. So women should not be dictated too about those types of things either. These decisions shouldn't be based on a person's gender I agree.