Lying to a friend

@buddha3 (1026)
India
February 24, 2013 1:54am CST
Well, it's a very complicated situation. Today I and 4 of my friends were invited for lunch by an employee of our college who works in the administration department. She is like a friend and sister to all of us and we are closer to her than others in our class. So, when we were getting ready to go, my roommate asked my other friends as to where they were going. I was not around when he asked this to them. He is not so close to the person whom we were to visit and hence he was not invited. I thought of telling him when I am leaving, but before that he asked my other friends. Now they didn't know what to say and just said "we are going out". He asked "where?" and they said "just like that", but it was clear that they were trying to hide something. My roommate felt bad and it was evident to all of us. Then to make the situation right, my friends called our host and asked if they can bring my roommate along, and she happily agreed. They now asked him to come with them, but he was already hurt and there was no chance of him agreeing to come now!! So, I too decided not to go and stayed back, while others went. All of us felt bad :( It's so complicated to decide on how to react in such situations and how to handle these situations. I said to my friends that they should have told him the truth when he asked for the first time. There is no point of him feeling bad then because he knows very well that he and the lady who invited us are not too close to each other and it is obvious that she would not prefer to invite everyone!! I'm sure he wouldn't mind if he was told the truth. Someone has invited someone to her house and why would he feel bad about it? Isn't it? What do you think friends? What should have my friends done when my roommate asked them where they were going?
5 responses
@machatago (385)
• Philippines
25 Feb 13
I feel bad for him, they should have told him that they were going to meet up with that particular person. Maybe he would have just nodded and also not join since he and that person is not close to him and ofcourse nobody in their right mind would invite himself to some event that he is not invited right? I think just by saying the truth he would have just shrugged it off and is ok if he is left behind. Right?
1 person likes this
@buddha3 (1026)
• India
25 Feb 13
Exactly, machatago! I too felt the same. That's what I argued with my friends that they should have told the truth and he is matured enough to understand. I know him well, he wouldn't have taken it seriously at all. But they have their own argument, which I feel doesn't make much sense. This is the irony of situations, relationships and life as a whole. Sometimes small things create troubles in human relationships :(
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
24 Feb 13
The truth would have been better. Even though it sometimes hurts one. The lie can hurt one even more.
@buddha3 (1026)
• India
25 Feb 13
Yes, but they thought that telling the truth would make him unhappy about the person who had not invited him. It's about how each individual thinks. They wanted to make sure my roommate didn't develop any bad feelings for the lady who had not invited him. So they tried to hide the fact itself.
• Mexico
25 Feb 13
Yes, I understand that. But lies are never good. They always lead to troubles. Have a super week there.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
24 Feb 13
They should have told the truth. It is the best thing to do in almost all situations to get rid of misunderstanding between friends.
@buddha3 (1026)
• India
24 Feb 13
Yes, telling truth is the best way to deal with these things. Telling lies usually complicates the matter and creates rift between people. But they thought that telling the truth may create bad impression of the lady on my roommate.
• Dhaka, Bangladesh
25 Feb 13
Hi Buddha, we should not tell lies. At all positions and conditions we should tell truth. Have a very nice day.
@buddha3 (1026)
• India
26 Feb 13
aminul, it's not possible to tell truth always. Sometimes there are situations in which we will have to lie, for the good of ourselves and also others. All of us tell lies at some point of time or the other, but it must be such that our lies should not hurt anybody. We must take care that we don't lie unnecessarily, like in the case I mentioned above.
• United States
24 Feb 13
Yes, I think that was handled poorly. Even knowing upfront that he wasn't invited would have hurt but it hurts worse to ask what's going on and you aren't given a straight answer. I was told my son in law and daughter were going to Mississippi without me to see my great grandchild after he or she is born. It hurt terrible. Since, they now decided not to go if I can't go. It's a matter of space in the small car. The big car isn't in good enough shape to take on a long trip. On Bew Year's eve my family went to SIL's parents house and they said it was just for them. It hurt me badly. His mom asked where I was. She expected me to be there too. My daughter called and said to get ready and they would pick me up. I said NO. I wasn't invited. Have a great time. I just cried because it really hurt me to not be included to begin with. We are supposed to be family but sometimes I'm just an outsider and it hurts. I understand how your roommate felt.
@buddha3 (1026)
• India
24 Feb 13
I'm sorry for how u felt Yes, indeed it hurts to the core when someone who is close to our heart keeps us out of these happy moments. It was really not good of them to treat you as an outsider :( Moreover, when you know that someone is 'lying' to avoid you, it hurts still more. That's what my roommate felt. These friends of mine had done the same to me some time back. It was one of the friends who was taking out all for dinner, and all of them lied to me that they were going to market. This time at least, it's not their fault except that they lied. This time it was someone else who had invited us to her home and she is not very close to my roommate and hence she didn't think of him while inviting. He understands it very well. The only thing that hurt him was they lied to him unnecessarily.