Is a degree for art useless?

Liechtenstein
April 17, 2013 9:33pm CST
What's your opinion on the degree for art? Somehow I don't see the point in pursuing a degree for illustration art because I have after I finished with my art major. A diploma is all I need. What it's needed the most in the workforce is experience. So an internship is a better option than a degree because even if I get a degree, it would be useless without experience. I'm guessing it's the same thing with other majors unless the company want to see your degree then what's the point? Besides my skills in illustration can be develop on my own without being force to take on projects that I don't like in a degree given my lecturers.
2 people like this
11 responses
@Paper_Doll (2373)
• Philippines
19 Apr 13
I think that everything matters- education/diploma, trainings/seminars, skills/experiences and of course attitude. I said that because I once worked in the Human Resources Department in the past. And I have to say that all that I mentioned above count. This may be a case to case basis but majority in the government, you need to meet the minimum qualification before you can be qualified for a certain position. Like if you apply as an Engineer because you think you have what it takes, but you do not have the degree then it is impossible for you to be shortlisted. But if I am going to be specific like what you have mentioned above, well I think that you are right. My husband's uncle is the president of a known group of artist in our country. They are currently holding an exhibit somewhere in Manila and they are staying with us. He did not finished degree like my father in law but they are both good in their craft. I think that in this kind of field, knowledge and techniques which you don't really learn from school is important. I would usually hear them talk about the latest trends which involve art/paintings. They also update themselves and make sure that would search how they are going to equip themselves with this new techniques.
• Philippines
20 Apr 13
Well I think that if you really think a degree isn't necessary, then do not enroll for one. I know some people who also think that way and there are some who still want. My husband is a graduate of a 2 year course and would always say that he still wants to enroll again and finish a degree but I think that isn't necessary. I heard him say many reasons as to why so I do not know now which is the real one. But I guess he see this as a fulfillment.
• Liechtenstein
19 Apr 13
Okay maybe in some fields, a degree is a must. But for my field, a degree has zero value. Otherwise, how come a self taught artist(no formal art education) can actually get a job? Yes, I took a diploma course to learn but I'm pretty much taught everything in diploma. I just have to sharpen my skills after I graduate so why study for a degree?
@LocoVa (1)
• Canada
19 Apr 13
Become a forensic sketch artist. They're real and needed in the work force as most evidence in forensics is submitted through witness statements and most witnesses can do nothing more than describe the person they saw doing whatever and that it was bad. I don't think any degree is useless as every degree helps you to improve your personal skills, thus granting you a better quality of life.
• Liechtenstein
19 Apr 13
Forensic sketch artist? I have never heard of that job position before. I don't think my country has that kind of job position.
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
18 Apr 13
But you don't really get internships without the back up of schools, do you? I mean, they do require that someone backs up on your claims so that they know you're not another psycho who goes inside their company. In the same way that a business course in college doesn't guarantee you're going to be successful when you do your own business. Remember that education gives you the foundation. It's up to you what you build on top of the foundation. Things may flop and not work out, but at least if your foundation is solid, you can get on your feet again. However, there are those who became successful even without a degree. But if you have the chance to get the degree, why not? At least you can form networks there with people as classmates, peers, professors and who knows these people might lead you to the top. Then again, it's still up to you in the long-run. Have a great mylot experience ahead!
• Liechtenstein
19 Apr 13
In my country, a diploma(which I'm currently taking) is all you need to get an internship. Besides, my family is not rich. We struggle to pay our bills. So since I see no value in a degree because I can practically learn the same thing cheaper through online classes and books. Like I said, my family is not rich so I wouldn't call it a chance to get a degree because I feel that we might end up bankrupt if I want to get a degree.
• Philippines
18 Apr 13
I would assume that you will include degrees concerning humanities as well. I got a humanities degree. Is it useless. For me, it isn't although I could say that it adds to my knowledge but that's what college education should give you. Concerning your situation, i would agree that internship is a good idea but I think waiting for a diploma isn't useless either. It might be a piece of paper but it's a piece of paper that denotes your accomplishment. Besides, you might need it somewhere down the road. Even companies who seek experience with their future workers would also like a price of paper that says that you did graduate and you earned your degree. It might cement your credibility for the job.
• Liechtenstein
18 Apr 13
Judging by my country's current situation of the art industry. I'll would say an art degree is useless. There are some jobs like a comic artist for example don't need a fancy paper that says you completed the degree. A high school graduate can even apply for a job as a comic artist. But a concept artist on the other hand, work experience is needed more than a degree. You can tell me which is better, an internship which you don't need to pay a single cent allows you to learn everything you need and gain work experience or a degree which you paid a huge sum of money till you became bankrupt just to learn more or less same thing and when you come out to work, you have zero work experience and still need to take an internship.
@jkct02 (2874)
• Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia
20 Apr 13
I think it depends on from what angle you are looking at. While it is unquestionable that a degree is better than a diploma in status, do not forget that the knowledge and learning process you will be getting in pursuing a degree will benefit you greatly and as a result will strengthen your fundamentals. The experience and exposure in the degree course may even open up your mind for you - something you may not think about if you are not in the right company of study mates and environment. In other words, a degree is a preparation course to enable you to walker longer distance and see the world with a broader mind. Unless you are constrained by financial concerns, I suggest you to take a degree so that you can further improve yourself as a person as well as academically. The chance to study for a degree is very likely once a life time thingy. If you don't do it now then you may never will. You may seek the opinions of graduates in your major and see what they have to say about their own experience. I am sure that most of them will tell you that they are a better persons now.
• Philippines
18 Apr 13
I don't think it's useless. While it could be a bit challenging to land a job with that degree, you could also consider that you could do a lot of things from what you've learned from your degree. Say, why don't you go freelancing?
• Liechtenstein
19 Apr 13
I already did some part time freelancing. Manage to earn some pocket money. But I do intend to become a full time freelancer after I finished with my diploma.
@SinfulRose (3527)
• Davao, Philippines
20 Apr 13
There's a certain advantage in getting a degree instead of a vocational course or internship. From what I know, the cold hard truth of reality is that although most courses seem useless, when it comes to promotions, the company usually looks at one's educational background. Most people with degrees have a better chance in getting a higher position than those who don't. Yes, those who had no degree may get promoted until a certain position comes up where a degree is a requirement.
19 Apr 13
for such field chosen actually no degree is necessary but it's a must to take a degree because everything is unsure for security purposes that you might change your mind and wanted to try different job it will be easy for you to switch since you are holding a degree and also for self fulfillment in education
@blackrusty (3519)
• Mexico
19 Apr 13
well now days the degree is not worth the paper that it is printed on they say you have to go get the degree and and why because your the student you have to pay for schooling this is just another way for you to spend your hard earned money i think if your getting hands on it would futher you on in your life just my own thoughts
@bintang9 (196)
• Indonesia
19 Apr 13
No, I don't think that it is useless. For the education field the degree is still needed. We also know that in the art faculty, there so many professor in art. They teach the university students of art. of course when the degree is completed by many experience in art. But I think that achieving the degree need struggling and experience.
@joizee (502)
• Philippines
19 Apr 13
I think it is still necessary to have a degree in arts or any kind of career. The degree is one of the basis of employers to accept an applicant. Here they can say how you do and which school you belong to. Sometimes, companies give high regard to school and grades. Additionally, your degree gives you your fundamentals. Even though you can learn on your own, it teaches you the foundation and basics of arts. However, for some unfortunate people who cannot study, they invest on their experiences like part-time jobs and internships. They even try to have free vocational training and seminars to level up their skills. It both a matter of skill, knowledge and background. The final decision still lies on the hands of the employer. Good luck TrinityDownpour! :)